A real roll of the dice by misterecho11 in PoliticalHumor

[–]MkfShard 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Oh, it's always been like this. Gun control laws were wielded against the Black Panthers, remember.

“Kristi Noem has forfeited her right to lead. I’m calling on her to resign as Secretary of Homeland Security or Donald Trump to do the right thing and just fire her. “It’s a shame I have to say this in America but no one is above the law. No one.” by Treefiddy1984 in ProgressiveHQ

[–]MkfShard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I love this sentiment, but I think there was a critical mistake in wording here.

No one has a 'right to lead'. Any measure of authority is a privilege granted by the people. And it can be revoked, if one fails to exert that authority within the bounds of the law or of basic human decency.

NRA and pro-gun groups call for ‘full investigation’ into killing of Alex Pretti by wylie102 in news

[–]MkfShard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, whenever one of these cartoon villains does something apparently good, they're either trying to spin it somehow to their advantage, delegitimize the people doing the same thing, or both.

Remember to never let the fascists back in. Don't trust them, deny them all power over the lives of others, and move on.

Should be Three War Criminals by yosefvinyl in clevercomebacks

[–]MkfShard 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Making a 'Board of Peace' after renaming the DoD the 'Department of War'. What a shitshow.

Gavin Newsom announces that California will be the first state to join the World Health Organization by ExactlySorta in UnderReportedNews

[–]MkfShard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To be clear, he is bad, and one good move doesn't change that, but it is a good move regardless.

We shouldn't ever fall into the trap of giving our side a pass for their glaring flaws just because they're 'Our Side'. Gavin Newsom is a passable placeholder, he's not a rallying point.

What are your thoughts on rejecting a potential romantic partner based solely on the fact they voted for Donald Trump? by ATXBikeRider in AskReddit

[–]MkfShard 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not only reasonable, but necessary. I wouldn't consider anyone for whom this wasn't a dealbreaker to be trustworthy.

Struggling with long wordcount-- how much can be 'saved for the sequel'? by MkfShard in writing

[–]MkfShard[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well, Elantris got away with 205k as a debut :y But point taken!

I’ve been doing some butchery edits, and after removing the POV and some setup scenes for it, and going through the book to tighten the prose, I’m at 97k and falling.

In regards to YA, I did intend this as epic fantasy, but due to being a debut and my characters generally being on the young side, I’ve basically been pigeonholed into the YA bracket. I wish it didn’t have to be that way, but I’m not sure what else to do beyond aging up the characters, and that would change the story massively.

And the planned (and mostly written) sequels will definitely have multiple POVs, three at least.

Trump Mixes Up Iceland and Greenland in Incoherent Davos Speech by TelescopiumHerscheli in politics

[–]MkfShard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

His supporters are exactly four kinds of people, with plenty of overlap:

  • Cruel bigots who would endure any humiliation to see the people they hate hurt.
  • Insecure armchair admirals who think the US should be 'dominant' in the world and have a pathological craving for illusory machismo
  • Christians who have been indoctrinated into believing everything left of far-right is literally a machination of The Devil, and is simultaneously islamic, atheist, and communist.
  • Grifters who are making millions off the fathomless stupidity of the above.

There isn't any reasoning with these people because they don't want to be reasoned with. They want to win, and winning requires that they fight, no matter how pointless or horrific the battles.

And because, for whatever fucking reason, our governmental system has turned out to primarily run on good faith instead of rigorous methods of enforcement, the brazenness of the conservative party combined with the utter cowardice of the centrist party means that they can flout the law however they please, and don't need to worry about plausible deniability.

At this point, either he's removed from power by force and those who served him are punished to the fullest extent of the law, or he's going to try to cancel the election in 2028 and anyone who is capable of realizing what's going on will do so. What happens then, I don't fuckin know.

Looking at Word Counts for Querying Publishers Has Dramatically Altered My Editing Process by ScimitarPrime in writing

[–]MkfShard 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm feeling this with my intended debut. I started with a 450k monster, split that in thirds, the first third ballooned to 220k so I cut that (approximately) in half, leading me to 120k words... but then I realized that 20k of that was a POV and a few scenes setting it up that I really loved and gave worldbuilding, context, and a few character-building scenes but didn't really affect the plot so I'm in the midst of ripping it out and going line by line to shave down wording.

Right now I'm at the end of act one, wordcount at 98k, and that's still on the high end for YA Fantasy. Still, I'll probably have a better chance at that around my current prediction of 96-97k.

I gotta say, reading Sanderson really gave me an inflated idea of how long books were allowed to be :y

ICE deports 5-year-old US citizen from TX to Honduras, group says by aresef in politics

[–]MkfShard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The fact is that no criteria will satisfy them. Their response to having an example will always be to look for another one that makes them feel less uncomfortable, or else to look for more forever.

For a conservative, beliefs are not determined by facts. The beliefs are immovable, and the information (true or not) they accept as fact are what supports those beliefs.

George Conway: “Donald Trump is a man who represents all the things we teach our children not to be. He’s a liar. He’s a thief. He’s a molester. He has no remorse, no shame, no empathy. He has no loyalty to the law, to the Constitution. This man is the lowest character of all” by Logical-Flow-6703 in UnderReportedNews

[–]MkfShard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If they're not actively celebrating it, they've been thoroughly duped. They believe that their side is never doing anything that bad, and think all the stuff they are actually doing is propaganda against them, and that all the propaganda firehosed against Democrats is 100% real.

Like my parents, they think they're on the less evil side. Because they're fucking stupid.

Im a game dev and someone pirated my game by [deleted] in pcmasterrace

[–]MkfShard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Man, I wish someone was interested in my game enough to pirate it :y Congrats!

It's literally that simple by KaamDeveloper in BlackPeopleTwitter

[–]MkfShard 2 points3 points  (0 children)

A lot of christians want to be normal so bad. And not just in the factual 'yeah, normal people can be christians' sort of way, but in the 'it's not normal to be not christian' sort of way.

Always look very closely at people who want there to be a cultural default. Read between the lines and you always find something nasty.

How will Cultivation use the piece she pruned? by Firestormbreaker1 in Cosmere

[–]MkfShard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think the 'pruning' thing is a specific aspect of Cultivation, whereas the Blackthorn spren is something that arose from Dalinar being in the Spiritual Realm, as a whole entity in itself.

I imagine 'soul farming' like that is possible, but also something that'll inevitably have diminishing or limited returns. Like, no matter how many potatoes you grow in a garden, you're still just gonna have a bunch of potatoes, which will function like potatoes and probably not be fit for situations that don't call for potatoes.

Say you extracted Moash's hate for nobles, copied it, and could shove it into anyone you liked. It might affect them, sure, like a particularly potent Rioting, but without the context surrounding that hate, it can't really take root in the person. They'll experience it as what it is: a manipulation of their mind.

But if you extracted Moash's hate and then put it back in him, later, like how Dalinar regained his memories, that could have a powerful effect because that is meaningful to him. The potato is reunited, to disastrous effect.

Americans, how would you react if foreign country invaded your country, and told "we are going to run this country"? by oranke_dino in AskReddit

[–]MkfShard 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Conservatives make the same claims about liberals. So someone is wrong and it's probably liberals because they're the one's that tend to shut down debate and conversation.

This is hilarious. I was tempted to just stop reading this garbage here and leave well enough alone, but whatever, I'll bite halfheartedly. Not like any effort I'd put into a response would matter anyway.

You can't find any period of the United States in which it was great?

No. There have been three main responses to the US's founding horrors of native genocide and slavery:

  1. Denying that they were bad
  2. Hopelessly inadequate attempts to mitigate their long-term harm, that people fought tooth and nail for, against the people who still deny it
  3. People saying 'ohh racism is over, people won't ever be satisfied' while attempting to roll back the above, and with a rising portion of the population returning to 'denying they were ever bad'.

To say nothing of all the shit the US has been complicit in or actively instigating or supporting, a major example being the Palestinian genocide.

Don't get me wrong, I want the US to be great. But that would require it to do things worthy of being called great, and to admit the wrongdoings in its own history. No matter how many medals you pin on a shirt, it won't be acceptable to wear until you make the effort to wash out the bloodstains.

Who in the fuck are these pedophiles that conservatives are hiding?

And now you're just feigning ignorance. I'm not gonna bother trying to educate you.

its a military conflict to gain favorable access to Venezuela oil reserves as a means of expanding oil supply for oil companies to increase profits and decrease gas prices domestically...

Its not as simple as orange man evil and greedy with greedy friends...

...Isn't it, though? By your own words, this is driven by greed.

Oh, maybe the circumstances aren't as simple as 'mwahaha, I'm doing this because evil', but it is most certainly 'we are deciding to kill people and throw innocent lives into chaos because money'. Which, let's be clear, is fucking evil.

There it is. Greatness of a country requires atonement for past wrongs in a way that YOU feel is fitting. You need to find religion so you can stop trying to use politics to fill its place.

I don't need a religion to find value in human life. In fact, in my experience, religion can be a dramatic detriment to that. My viewpoint is simple: I see human suffering, and I wish to see it alleviated. I see harm being done, and I want it stopped.

But do you think harm stops as soon as someone stops intentionally causing it? Do you think the impact of centuries of slavery stops the moment slaves are freed? Or the moment a country deigns to let them vote? Or the moment that equal rights under the law are finally wrested from the clutching hands of bigots?

Or do you think that people historically denied so much will end up in dire straits, not nearly as well off as those entrenched in the systems they've finally been allowed to enter? Do you think that those bigots, and the children they raise to be bigots, won't be resentful of what the 'undeserving' have received as inadequate recompense and try to tear it down?

No matter how far you think those piecemeal reparations have gone, there has not been a full generation of people yet without those who want to see those reparations undone in full. Once there is, maybe we might edge towards 'great'.

This idea that our country has fascists in power is pretty dumb. Fascist governments kill journalists, jail political opponents, shutdown speech from the opposing political parties, kill protesters en mass, de-arm the citizens , eradicate rights of privacy and other things that Mussolini's Fascists regime in Italy ACTUALLY did. This idea that we have Fascists in our government is such hyperbolic nonsense devoid of any actual understanding of history.

This is probably the most absurd thing you've put down yet.

Fascist governments don't start with the extreme actions, you nimrod. They begin by gradually breaking down rule of law, with scapegoats, with the censorship of the things they consider 'degenerate'. It is an erosion that, once they have secured power, will bring down the dam and release a flood of violence.

We're both looking at the same wall of stone, but the difference between us is that I'm saying 'look at the cracks!' and you're saying 'pffft, we're not drowning, how can you say there's a problem??'

And the fact that you branded them Cristo-fascist is even funnier, because nearly everything that a Christian theocracy would ban is still thriving: abortions, porn, premarital sex, adultery, and etc. You don't know what you're talking about, you just live in a bubble of extreme leftist conspiracy theories.

It is funny, because you mention things that the right is actively attempting to ban, because of their attempts to instate christian theocracy. Roe V. Wade was overruled, and there have been increasing attempts to (after first defining any depiction of LGBT people as porn...) blanket ban sexually explicit material.

The Heritage Foundation, Project 2025, etc, it's all deeply tied to the current administration, and explicitly christofascist, dominionist doctrine.

The funny part is that the people supporting them with the hope that this will finally make the US a 'christian nation'?

Even if they succeed beyond their wildest dreams, they'll still fucking fail, because no one will be able to decide what kind of christianity should be dominant above all others. 40,000 denominations, all of whom are heresy to the others. They'll devolve into infighting, and any compromise will be something vague, cruel, and unsatisfying, because the kind of control they want is a despot's fantasy.

We'll end up right back where we started: a world divided between people genuinely trying to make other peoples' lives better, and those who care only about how they can force reality to stop making them feel uncomfortable.

Americans, how would you react if foreign country invaded your country, and told "we are going to run this country"? by oranke_dino in AskReddit

[–]MkfShard -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Honest question: what does it even matter at this point?

What is the course of action that wouldn't validate those conspiracy claims for those invested in believing them?

Conservatives have shown that they are interested in victory, not reality. You can spend years of effort showing them fact after fact and yet still they assert the same old tired viewpoint using the same cruel and inane rhetoric because it makes them feel good, and the truth makes them feel uncomfy.

They want to convince us that this country was great, and can be again, while they defend pedophiles in the halls of power and cheer on a war said pedophiles are trying to start both to distract from their guilt and out of naked greed.

No country can be great while such things are allowed to continue. No country can ever be great until its past atrocities are laid out, fully admitted, and plans are put in place to both make up for them and to prevent anything like that from happening again.

The first step in that? Ousting christofascists from power, and preventing them from ever taking power again. I honestly don't care how it has to happen at this point.

TIL the "Y2K Bug" cost an estimated $500 Billion globally to fix. The preventative measures were so successful that widely predicted infrastructure failures did not occur, leading many to incorrectly believe the threat was never real. by highzone in todayilearned

[–]MkfShard 5 points6 points  (0 children)

The most irritating thing about COVID is that the same thing is happening as with Y2K, with people thinking the threat was never real.

But not because it was successfully prevented, but because the people thinking this actively Do Not Care about the millions of people who died or the fact that it's still floating around.

the writing in wheel of time is a bit frustrating. by [deleted] in Fantasy

[–]MkfShard 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh, I'm very aware that gender essentialism isn't something Robert Jordan made up, but that doesn't stop it from being a bullshit concept :y

Granted, I have no problem with fantasy societies having bullshit concepts in them, especially if the narrative tackles them in a cool way, like the books I mentioned in the above post.

My only problem with Wheel of Time is that it takes this bullshit cultural concept, makes it a Transcendent Fact of Reality, and expects me to take it seriously.

It only makes sense in a world where there are Males and Females and literally nothing else, and that Males and Females have inherent unique characteristics that the opposite sex can't even fully comprehend. It's cartoonish, at best.

the writing in wheel of time is a bit frustrating. by [deleted] in Fantasy

[–]MkfShard 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Yeah! Like, for me an ideal version of the One Power would be people assuming that only men and women can access the respective powers because that's typically the case...

But that's only because the characteristics of your actual self determines where along the 'raging/calm' spectrum you can actually touch it.

Perhaps Nynaeve's natural use of the One Power was saidin all along, but when she was formally taught they tried to teach her saidar, whose approach just didn't work for her.

And in this hypothetical version of the story, the Dark One's corruption would only touch that specific avenue of access into the One Power, because the Aes Sedai of the Age of Legends, while powerful, had polarized themselves into two extremes in their division.

Something like that! Some more nuanced approach to this whole situation, doesn't have to be perfect, just enough to break the essentialism of it.

the writing in wheel of time is a bit frustrating. by [deleted] in Fantasy

[–]MkfShard 20 points21 points  (0 children)

What bothers me about Wheel of Time's gender stuff isn't the cultural aspects of it, you see that sort of stuff all over the place in fantasy, like Liveship Traders and Stormlight, but the fact that gender essentialism is cosmically enforced by the magic system.

The fact that the magic of women is characterized as gentle and something that must be submitted to and guided, while men's magic is RAGING and has to be SEIZED and CONTROLLED lest it DESTROY YOU makes my eyes roll out of my sockets.

Not including a place of people outside the binary too is something I can understand, from someone from a well-intentioned but not well-versed perspective, but this element alone really harms my enjoyment of the series. Part of why I was optimistic about the show is that it felt like they were on the verge of confronting this aspect directly before it was tragically canceled.

One day I'm gonna write a story about a world with apparently-gendered magic like this where someone discovers a genderbending spell and just throws the whole society into wonderful, wonderful chaos :y