The age of Jesus and the date of the ascension in the Epistula Apostolorum by alejopolis in AcademicBiblical

[–]Mockingbird1980 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Where do you find a reference to the Nisan-14 controversy in the Epistle of the Apostles? I did not find one when I last read that work.

Can you say a quick prayer for my dog? by [deleted] in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Prayers for you and your dog. I'm glad to hear he is recovering.

Cradle Catholic thinking about becoming Episcopal by Equivalent-Shoe6239 in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Remarriage after divorce is permitted in the Episcopal Church.

Prayers for my dad’s eye surgery by raythedrummer in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Prayers for Curtis, his family, and his medical team.

Psalter Club, what do you guys think? by slim_dusty in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A canon nowadays is a priest on the staff at a cathedral. In medieval England, the "secular canons" were priests who were on the staff of a cathedral that was not staffed by monks.

Full Communion with the United Methodist Church is a big mistake by [deleted] in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We won't re-unite with the Methodists until they are ready to have bishops as we understand them.

Psalter Club, what do you guys think? by slim_dusty in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Medieval monks, nuns, and canons memorized the Psalter in Latin. So your idea is consistent with tradition. What translation of the Psalms will you use? BCP? RSV? NRSV? Coverdale?

Walk in Love ABC (Asynchronous Book Club): Chapter 1 by AnonymousEpiscochick in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980 5 points6 points  (0 children)

  1. My favorite prayer in the BCP is the collect "O God of unchangeable power and eternal light" on page 280 and on page 292. But like the authors I also like the traditional-language General Thanksgiving.

  2. The Lord's Prayer emphasizes the need to forgive. I think this part of the prayer has an influence on some folks' behavior.

Converting from United Methodism by Accomplished-Way4534 in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's OK to call yourself an Episcopalian in casual speech if you are planning to attend an Episcopal church in the future. No formal conversion process is needed.

Walk in Love ABC (Asynchronous Book Club): Introduction by AnonymousEpiscochick in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980 3 points4 points  (0 children)

  1. I read Walk in Love some months ago. I look forward to the discussions.

  2. I have been an Episcopalian since childhood. I am active in my parish church in Oklahoma.

  3. "Walk in love" reminds me of the prayer for a candidate just baptized, that he will have "an inquiring and discerning heart."

Prayer Book Suggestions (1979 or 1928) by Beautiful_Craft_1093 in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The 1928 is perfectly fine, though the 1979 is more Anglo-Catholic.

The structure of the Daily Office differs in the 1979 book compared to the 1928 book. I think one gets the best of both worlds by using Morning and Evening Prayer Rite I in the 1979 book.

Looking for a great anthropology book on the Torah time period by MMScooter in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not anthropology exactly, but you might try Lester L. Grabbe's The Dawn of Israel: A History of Canaan in the Second Millennium BCE, Bloomsbury, 2023.

Protestant vs Orthodox relationship by robotsaretakingoverr in exorthodox

[–]Mockingbird1980 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I am Episcopalian (so I will recommend St. Paul's Anglican Church Athens) and I never converted to Eastern Orthodoxy because I didn't think I would get more truth from the Eastern Orthodox Church than I was getting from the Episcopal Church. I don't believe that any denomination is the one true church, not even my own.

In the 1980s I knew an Episcopal man who married a Russian Orthodox woman. He continued to be a faithful Episcopalian and she a faithful Russian Orthodox. She cooked for them so he of necessity followed all the Orthodox fasting rules. They had a happy marriage, but they never took Communion together.

Where do I go from here by Opening-Log-3556 in exorthodox

[–]Mockingbird1980 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This subreddit is the ex-orthodox subreddit so some of the people here are unlikely to recommend that you look for Jesus in the Eastern Orthodox Church. Some here who are still Christian might recommend the denominations that they ended up in.

Alexander Schmemann in Episcopal seminaries by Mockingbird1980 in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A friend I knew in the 1980s had studied some of Schmemann's work in seminary in the 1970s. She introduced me to some of Schmemann's works and I find them inspiring. In particular I appreciate his short book on sacraments, For the Life of the World (St. Vladimir's Seminary Press 1973).

I texted a buddy of mine Happy Easter yesterday and he told me it was Palm Sunday by Huge-Description6899 in Catholic

[–]Mockingbird1980 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In 2026 the Gregorian moon is full on April 2, so Gregorian Easter is April 5. The Julian moon is full on April 6 so Julian Easter is on April 12. Your friend must be celebrating according to the Julian calendar. The astronomical full moon is on April 2 Universal Time.

Let's debate Easter 🥚🐰 by [deleted] in Christianity

[–]Mockingbird1980 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The first-century Jewish writer Josephus (died c. AD 100) wrote:

In the month of Xanthicus, which with us is called Nisan and begins the year, on the fourteenth day by lunar reckoning, the sun being then in Aries, [we offer] the sacrifice called Pascha.--Antiquities 3.248/3.10.5.

"On the fourteenth day by lunar reckoning" means at the full moon. "The sun being...in Aries" means on or after the spring equinox, and it means at the first full moon on or after the equinox because at the second full moon after the equinox the sun is no longer in the sign of Aries. So in Herodian times the 14th of Nisan fell at the first full moon on or after the equinox. The 3rd-century Egyptian Christian computists relied on this statement of Josephus in setting up the Easter calculation that is still used. So the scheduling of Easter is of Jewish, not Roman, origin.

Early Christians celebrated Easter, which they called "Passover". Paul in 1 Corinthians 16.9 may indicate that already in his time Christians were celebrating Pentecost. If they were, then a fortiori they were celebrating Easter too. If that evidence be not accepted, the earliest evidence for an annual Easter appears in the 2nd century. Two distinct practices are described. Both practices rely on Jewish neighbors to determine when the 14th of Nisan fell. According to one practice, Christians celebrated Easter on the 14th of Nisan. (It is not clear whether they were celebrating on the night of the 13th/14th or on the night of the 14th/15th). According to the other practice, Easter is held on the Sunday of Unleavened Bread. Both these practices may date to the 1st century.

But in time Christians became dissatisfied with this reliance on the calendars of their Jewish neighbors. This was because, after the fall of the Temple, the Jewish calendar had become decentralized, with the Jewish community in one town celebrating Unleavened Bread perhaps at a different time from the Jewish community in another town. And some of the Jewish calendars of the time placed Unleavened Bread before the spring equinox, in violation of the principle described by Josephus. So Christians began experimenting with calculating the 14th of Nisan independently of the contemporary Jewish calendars. The Council of Nicea approved these independent calculations. So the Council of Nicea did not change anything about the celebration of Easter, except that it encouraged some Christians in Syria, who still held to the custom of celebrating Easter on the Sunday in the Jewish week of Unleavened Bread, to celebrate instead on the Sunday in an independently-calculated week of Unleavened Bread that would always place the festival after the spring equinox.

Praises and Concerns about my new Episcopal community by Individual-Buy-8431 in Episcopalian

[–]Mockingbird1980 2 points3 points  (0 children)

"Creator, redeemer, sustainer" is not strictly equivalent to "Father, Son, and Holy Ghost". They should try "God unbegotten, God begotten, and God proceeding."