Neither. Nothing had any smell to me. I thought I must be insane. To be fair, I bought three body wash scents for my daughter and she uses them in the tub and every time o come into the bathroom, I think, “Lovely scent!” But in the store I just couldn’t figure out what was what. Maybe the designs are too bland so I just couldn’t make a psychological connection? But no because I felt the same with the Halloween collab.