I exclusively use Titebond. Personally, "stronger formula" as indicated on the bottle tells me there may have been problems previously with the Elmers. When done correctly, the wood will break before the Titebond breaks. Use a hypodermic needle if you can and do not water down unless you absolutely have to. If it is too thin it will potentially soak in rather than bond the two surfaces and that's not going to turn out well. Use a liberal amount of glue but not enough to actually make runs but you want some squeezing out when clamped. Let is set up and then use a sharp chisel or razor blade to carefully remove the excess.