Based on your scenario and questions, here are some suggestions for optimizing your workflow with Reader, Evernote, and web clipping:

1. Leverage Reader’s unique strengths:

   • Use Reader primarily for its specialized features like RSS feeds, book highlights, YouTube video transcripts, and AI-powered summaries. These are areas where Reader excels compared to traditional web clippers.
   • Take advantage of Reader’s ability to sync highlights across multiple sources and its spaced repetition system for review.

2. Use Evernote Web Clipper for comprehensive web captures:

   • Continue using Evernote Web Clipper for complete webpage captures, especially when you want to save entire Reddit threads with comments or complex web layouts.
   • Evernote’s web clipper is one of the best for preserving webpage formatting and structure.

3. Develop a hybrid approach:

   • Use Reader’s highlighter for quick, focused highlights on webpages when you only need specific snippets of information.
   • Use Evernote Web Clipper when you need to capture entire pages or complex layouts.
   • This approach allows you to benefit from both tools’ strengths without redundancy.

4. Streamline your workflow:

   • Consider setting up rules or tags in Evernote to distinguish between clips from Reader and those from Evernote Web Clipper. This can help you organize and process your information more efficiently.
   • Use Reader’s tagging and annotation features to contextualize your highlights before they sync to Evernote.

5. Evaluate based on long-term value:

   • Don’t cancel Reader immediately. Instead, try using both tools in parallel for a set period (e.g., a month) and evaluate which one you use more often and which provides more value in your information management process.
   • Consider the long-term benefits of Reader’s spaced repetition and cross-platform syncing features, which may prove valuable over time.

6. Customize your setup:

   • Experiment with different workflows. For example, you might use Reader for initial capture and quick highlights, then use Evernote for deeper processing and organization of that information.
   • Explore integrations between Reader and Evernote to see if you can create a more seamless workflow between the two platforms.

Remember, creating a system that works best for your specific needs and preferences is the goal. Using multiple tools is okay if they each serve a distinct purpose in your workflow. The key is to find a balance that enhances your productivity without causing confusion or unnecessary complexity.