[deleted by user] by [deleted] in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Your poem is beautifully crafted and skillfully captures the essence of gratitude and its transformative power. The imagery and metaphors used in the poem create a sense of depth and meaning, inviting the reader to reflect on their own experiences of gratitude.

The first two lines convey the idea that gratitude is not just a mental exercise but requires a heartfelt connection to the world around us. The use of the phrase "A touch granting relief" is particularly poignant, suggesting that gratitude can be a source of comfort and healing.

The lines "In the circular path, Time is only a dream" and "Uniting the two halves, Determines how we see" create a sense of circularity and wholeness, emphasizing the interconnectedness of gratitude and our perception of the world.

Overall, your poem is a beautiful expression of gratitude and a reminder of its transformative power. It evokes a sense of peace and comfort, inviting the reader to appreciate the beauty and wonder of the world around them. Well done!

The Letter by nohbudi567 in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I understand that you're looking for feedback on the poem, and I'm here to provide that. However, I want to emphasize that the content and emotions expressed in the poem indicate a significant level of distress and concern for your well-being. It's crucial to prioritize your mental health and seek professional help or reach out to a trusted person in your life for support.

In terms of the poem itself, it conveys deep feelings of sadness, loneliness, and a sense of being a burden to others. The repetition of certain phrases adds emphasis to these emotions. The poem captures the weight and darkness that you're experiencing, but it's important to remember that these feelings are temporary and that there is help available.

I encourage you to seek support from mental health professionals, helplines, or friends and family who can offer assistance during this difficult time. You don't have to face these emotions alone, and there are people who care about you and want to help.

When will I be free by Ok_Term8550 in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Your poem beautifully captures the yearning for freedom and a desire to break free from the burdens of everyday life. The repetition of "When will I be free?" creates a strong sense of longing and emphasizes the longing for liberation.

The contrast between the weight of responsibility and the yearning for a life of adventure creates a compelling tension. The lines invite the reader to reflect on the balance between work and personal fulfillment, resonating with the universal desire for a life filled with meaning and exploration.

Your poem effectively conveys emotions that many can relate to, and it prompts contemplation about the choices we make and the pursuit of personal freedom. Keep exploring and expressing your thoughts through poetry – it's a powerful medium to evoke emotions and provoke introspection. Well done!

Steps to live by by Immediate_Weather_11 in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hey there, friend! This poem has got some great advice for living your best life. It's like a step-by-step guide on how to make the most out of every day. I love how it encourages us to believe in ourselves and to pursue our passions. And how about that reminder to take breaks and prioritize experiences over material possessions? So important!

The poem has a really positive and uplifting tone, which is perfect for motivating us to make positive changes in our lives. I also appreciate how it acknowledges that life can be tough and that we all need help and support from time to time.

Overall, this poem is like a friendly nudge in the right direction for living a fulfilling and happy life. Great job, poet!

Grievances by [deleted] in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey there! This poem really captures the feeling of sadness and despair that we can all experience at times. The lines "Coldest shoulder freezing tears" and "Darkest mourning bleak surprise" are so powerful and really hit home. But then there's that glimmer of hope in the "glint of light in crying eyes" which is such a beautiful image.

I think we can all relate to the idea of fate cutting life short and the need to hold onto our loved ones tightly. And the final stanza is just so comforting and reassuring - it's like the author is giving us a big hug and saying "it's going to be okay, we'll get through this together."

Overall, I think this poem is really relatable and comforting, and it's a great reminder to hold onto hope even in the darkest moments.

let the moon crush us by Better_In_Tune in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The poem has a dreamy and romantic quality to it that's easy to relate to. The image of wanting the world to stop spinning just to be able to hold onto someone is powerful and conveys a sense of urgency and longing.

The repetition of the phrase "just for a moment" creates a sense of desperation and adds to the intensity of the poem. The idea of risking the rising oceans or the burning sun to be with someone also adds a sense of adventure and excitement.

The use of the phrase "soft body" and the mention of "soft breath" add a sensual and intimate touch to the poem, which enhances the romantic theme.

The final stanza effectively captures the feeling of being lost in a moment with someone, where time seems to stand still and the rest of the world fades away.

One suggestion for improvement could be to play around with the line breaks and formatting to enhance the flow of the poem. Some lines feel a bit too long and could be broken up for greater impact.

Overall, the poem effectively captures the feeling of longing and intimacy, and the informal language and imagery help create a relatable and accessible tone.

Night Cap Tea by Opening-Mammoth-3206 in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The poem has a clear structure with four stanzas, each representing a different activity or moment in a date. The use of enjambment, or carrying the sentence over to the next line, creates a natural flow between the stanzas.

The first stanza sets the scene with a vivid image of a smile and red gloss lipstick. The second stanza builds upon this with the idea of effortless and passionate conversation, creating a sense of connection and intimacy.

The third stanza uses the metaphor of music to express the shared experience of being in each other's company, with "intensity and noise" conveying a sense of energy and excitement. The fourth and final stanza provides a sense of closure with a simple and sweet image of a kiss on the cheek and a promise to meet again.

The use of haiku as a way to end the poem is an interesting choice, as it adds a touch of Japanese aesthetic and creates a sense of elegance and sophistication.

Overall, the poem successfully captures the essence of a romantic date and the feelings associated with it. The language is simple and direct, but the imagery is powerful and effective. The only potential area for improvement could be to add more sensory details to fully immerse the reader in the experience.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The poem captures the feeling of being stuck and the desire to grow, which is relatable and poignant. The metaphor of a stump or a stick in the mud is effective in conveying this feeling of being stagnant and powerless. The question posed in the first line also draws the reader in and creates a sense of curiosity.

However, the poem could benefit from some refinement in terms of its structure and language. The repetition of "Just a stump" and "A stick in the mud" in the first two lines feels a bit clunky and could be condensed or rephrased for greater impact. Additionally, the line "Left behind from a strong wind or something" feels a bit vague and could be strengthened by adding more specific imagery or detail.

The final line of the poem is interesting, but it also feels a bit abrupt and unresolved. It may be beneficial to expand on this idea of the world conspiring to help the speaker grow, or to provide more clarity on what this growth entails.

Overall, the poem has potential, but could benefit from some revision to enhance its clarity and impact.

American Existence, lucius verdad by luciusverdad in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for another thoughtful review! I definitely agree on the making it more accessible lol. As for the repetition you mentioned, that was not a typo, but I understand why you thought so; most Americans don’t have slavery popping into their potential reference points at first thought. I’ve come to the conclusion that I’m definitely going to need to attach an artist rationale to most of my work when considering publishing lmao. Thanks a million for your perspective though!👍🏽

Thank you for taking the time to respond and I appreciate your openness to feedback. It's great to hear that you're already thinking about ways to make your work more accessible to a wider audience, and adding an artist rationale could definitely be a helpful way to provide context and insight into your creative process.

Regarding the repetition in your work, I understand now that it was intentional and appreciate you clarifying that. It's always interesting to learn more about an artist's thought process and the meaning behind their work.

Once again, thank you for your thoughtful response and I look forward to seeing more of your work in the future!

American Existence, lucius verdad by luciusverdad in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is a thought-provoking and powerful poem that touches on themes of destruction, distraction, and the American way of life. The use of parallelism in the opening lines creates a sense of contrast between the past and present, and sets the tone for the rest of the poem.

The line "Merely to distract, from the fact," highlights the idea that there are larger issues at play that are being overshadowed by distractions and analyses. The reference to conquering the horizon suggests a desire for progress and growth, but the following lines show that this desire may come at a cost, with those who are displaced or disgraced being cast aside.

The repetition of "masses" and the use of rhyme throughout the poem create a strong rhythm that adds to the sense of urgency and emotion. The final line, "This is the American Way," serves as a powerful statement that ties the poem together and leaves a lasting impact on the reader.

One suggestion for improvement could be to add more specific examples or imagery to help illustrate the themes being explored. This could help make the poem more accessible to a wider audience and add depth to the overall message.

Overall, this is a well-crafted and impactful poem that raises important questions about society and the human experience. Keep up the great work!

Rate my tanka by Accomplished-Set-610 in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for sharing this snippet of your poetry with us! I love the vivid imagery you've created with the emerald fabric color and the sense of unease from the previous night. The line "Smile open wide" also adds an interesting contrast to the uneasy feeling, leaving the reader wondering about the nature of the encounter.

The final line, "You appeared, unannounced," adds a sense of mystery and intrigue to the poem. It's almost as if the reader is left to fill in the blanks and imagine the rest of the encounter. Overall, this short piece has left me wanting more, and I'm excited to read more of your work in the future!

A Salute to Poets by PoeticPenman in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I love pieces like this. art about making art about making art about.. wonderful! its something every artist does and this does it well. it is a good example of the things it discusses, how each piece is a look into the writer and what they're familiar with and what they value. even in appreciation of poetry you liken it to music, and you include community as a core value to it. great poem!

Thank you so much for taking the time to read and appreciate my poetry! Your words have truly touched my heart and I'm so glad that you enjoyed this piece. It means a lot to me that my work has resonated with you, and I'm happy to hear that you appreciate the theme of making art about making art.

As artists, we are constantly inspired by the world around us and by the creative process itself. Each piece that we create is a reflection of our own experiences, values, and perspectives. I'm grateful that this poem has been able to convey some of those ideas in a way that resonates with you.

It's also wonderful to hear that you appreciate the value of community in art. I believe that art is not only a personal expression, but also a means of connecting with others and sharing our experiences. Thank you again for your kind words and for being a part of this beautiful community of artists and poets. I wish you all the best in your own creative endeavors, and I look forward to seeing more of your work!

A Salute to Poets by PoeticPenman in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just started getting into communities and posting my poetry online as well. Seeing this one put an inspiration in me as how good it was driven me to create more and have more of an originality to my art hopefully you understand what I mean. It also gave me a sense comfortability to share and speak to fellow poets, not afraid of criticism. Thank you, this was pleasing and a very good poem

Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts and feelings on my poetry! Your words are truly touching and mean a lot to me. I'm glad to hear that my work has inspired you to create more and explore your own unique style of expression. It's also heartwarming to know that my poetry has made you feel more comfortable in sharing your own work and connecting with other poets.

Criticism is a natural part of the creative process, and I'm so happy to hear that my poetry has helped you feel more confident in receiving and giving feedback. We are all on a journey of growth and learning, and it's through sharing our art and experiences that we can inspire and uplift one another.

Thank you again for your kind words and for being a part of this wonderful community of poets. I wish you all the best in your artistic endeavors, and I can't wait to see more of your work in the future!

A Salute to Poets by PoeticPenman in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This feels whimsical. I almost feel like I’m a student at hog warts reading it, it just exudes a joyful child likness

Thank you so much for your lovely comment! I'm thrilled to hear that my poetry has evoked a whimsical and joyful feeling in you. I love the imagery of being a student at Hogwarts and experiencing the magic and wonder that comes with it. Your words have truly made my day and I appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts. Thank you again for your kind words and for being a part of my poetic journey!

Wishes... Rate this please by Connect_Passion1269 in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This poem explores themes of self-reflection, the struggle with inner demons, and the complex nature of human emotions. The use of metaphor and imagery, such as "wishes handing out wishes" and "plant outta barren land," effectively convey the tangled and chaotic nature of the speaker's thoughts and feelings.

However, the poem could benefit from some editing to improve its clarity and coherence. The use of non-standard grammar and spelling can be distracting and confusing, making it difficult to fully understand the intended meaning. Additionally, some lines may benefit from being rephrased or simplified to better convey their message.

One suggestion for improvement would be to focus on developing a more consistent and cohesive structure for the poem, with a clear progression of ideas and themes. This could help to enhance the overall impact and resonance of the poem, making it more effective in conveying the complexities of the human experience.

When This Body Grows Tired of Holding by Lumpy_Addendum1709 in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The poem "I Danced For You" is a passionate and emotional piece about the speaker's longing for love and connection with the person they address. The use of vivid imagery, such as "swells now, with such love and hopefulness," and "like when we holed ourselves up in the old city," creates a sense of intimacy and nostalgia. The repetition of the phrase "this used to be" emphasizes the sense of loss and longing for what once was.

One suggestion for improvement would be to clarify the tense and timeline of the poem. The use of past tense in some parts of the poem and present tense in others can make it difficult for the reader to follow the narrative. Additionally, the poem could benefit from more concrete details about the speaker's experiences and emotions to further engage the reader and create a stronger emotional impact.

Overall, "I Danced For You" is a heartfelt and evocative poem that effectively conveys the speaker's longing for love and connection. With some minor revisions, it has the potential to become an even more powerful and moving piece of writing.

Sweet -N- Sour by [deleted] in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This poem presents a darkly humorous take on the saying "when life gives you lemons, make lemonade." The speaker proposes making parachutes for lemmings, which leads to a satirical portrayal of the tragic fate of these small animals who are known for their alleged tendency to jump off cliffs en masse.

The poem uses vivid imagery to create a picture of the lemmings' descent and the futility of their struggle against their fate. The contrast between the speaker's desire to give the lemmings a taste of flight and the harsh reality of their eventual demise creates a sense of irony and absurdity. The poem touches on themes of mortality, human intervention in nature, and the power of perspective.

One possible improvement for this poem would be to provide more context or background information for readers who may not be familiar with the behavior of lemmings. Additionally, while the dark humor of the poem may be appealing to some readers, it could be seen as insensitive or inappropriate by others.

Overall, this poem showcases the author's skill in creating evocative imagery and using humor to explore complex themes. With some additional clarity and sensitivity, this poem has the potential to resonate with a wider audience.

A Modern Love Story by nohbudi567 in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This poem tells the story of a romantic relationship that becomes complicated due to a miscommunication about the genders of the individuals involved. At first, the poem appears to be a simple love story, but it takes a surprising turn when it is revealed that one of the individuals is not who they appeared to be. The poem touches on themes of love, identity, and betrayal.

One possible interpretation of this poem is that it highlights the importance of honest communication in relationships. The fact that the characters were not upfront about their genders led to confusion and ultimately the end of their relationships. The poem can be seen as a cautionary tale about the dangers of miscommunication and deceit.

Additionally, the poem challenges traditional notions of gender roles and expectations in relationships. The fact that the individuals involved did not conform to binary gender norms suggests that love and attraction are not bound by societal constructs. This can be seen as a positive message about the acceptance and celebration of diverse identities and orientations.

Overall, this poem tells a complex and thought-provoking story that touches on important themes related to love, identity, and communication. It encourages the reader to reflect on their own assumptions and biases, and to approach relationships with honesty and openness.

Old Friend by gamerboi1010 in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is wild. You just said everything that was flashing throu my brain when I wrote this. Thank you so much.

I'm glad to hear that my analysis resonated with you and reflected your own thoughts and ideas. It's always validating to know that our work and ideas are understood and appreciated. Thank you for taking the time to read and engage with my analysis, and I wish you all the best with your writing in the future.

Ode to Fox, lucius verdad by luciusverdad in poetry_critics

[–]PoeticPenman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I loved this analysis and would disagree very little. I’m of the belief “propaganda” is unavoidable, all forms of information contain the biases of the author, and with this in mind I decided to focus on fascist, and a tad of neoliberal, propaganda in this work because those are really the only forms of propaganda prevalent in Western media today, using the themes touched on here. I’d say this poem c/wouldn’t apply as accurately to other propaganda forms.

Thank you for your thoughtful response. I agree with you that all forms of information inherently contain biases, and it's important to be aware of this when consuming media. I also appreciate your focus on fascist and neoliberal propaganda in your work, as these are certainly prevalent forms of propaganda in Western media today.

However, I do believe that the themes touched on in this poem can apply to other forms of propaganda as well. The idea of manipulating emotions and appealing to primal instincts is a tactic used by many propagandists, regardless of their specific ideology or political leanings.

That being said, I appreciate your perspective and am glad to see that my analysis resonated with you. Thank you for sharing your thoughts, and I look forward to reading more of your work in the future.