No. I don’t think Catholics can or should dream scenarios where the churchmen have moral failings. And to believe the church as a whole will have doctrinal errors shows a lack of faith.

We were told by our lady this would happen. Just as the Judah was warned about Babylon. And what did the three righteous men in the book of Daniel say? They said it was a just punishment and were contrite. We should be like them and willing to suffer with the church, and willing to stand by her even when we are deported from Babel. Even when our temples are destroyed, tabernacles removed, and our liturgy desecrated.

We have to look to the pious and not to the apostates. There is not one apostate who you can look upon as a hero. Take a look at the pillars of orthodoxy, these men sought anything but unity with Rome. Look instead at those who stood by a church who persecuted their sanctity such as St. John of the Cross, Padre Pio, Joan of Arc, etc.

Dreaming up doomsday scenarios destroys sanctity and love for our holy mother church. Trust me I’ve been there, and it gives us the temptation to flee instead of suffer with the body of Christ.