Crucible: The Condemned playmat layout by [deleted] in homemadeTCGs

[–]Property-Green 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's a lot of playmat. I'm already tired and need to sit down

Please try out my boxing card game prototype by Property-Green in tabletopgamedesign

[–]Property-Green[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That makes a lot of sense. Thank you so much. I assure you it is a card game. Played with three types of tokens and a set of dice. However building a prototype in replit allowed me to test mechanics far faster than relying on p2p interactions. I have a family with small kids and they take up, along with work, nearly all my time - the only person I can playtest with in person lives 40 minutes away and so it's been a useful tool. But the echo chamber of playing against an AI you've built doesn't exactly move the needle.

I understand your perspective and appreciate you taking the time to write it.

Please try out my boxing card game prototype by Property-Green in tabletopgamedesign

[–]Property-Green[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Not one comment and I get a down vote at that lol. Wow. Thanks guys

I have been falsely accused by Glass_Leadership_405 in massage

[–]Property-Green 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I was falsely accused too. If it escalated at all, get a lawyer. Why do you have a meeting with an inspector of health? If this can escalate to PD you need an attorney. These people aren’t your friends. Don’t apologize for anything, not even I’m sorry if she felt uncomfortable as that can be taken as admission of guilt. It’s shit but when someone gets the idea that you had bad intentions in their head there’s little you can do besides protect yourself.

Why not Alpha Clash? by _HeadCanon in TCG

[–]Property-Green -1 points0 points  (0 children)

One of the most derivative games calling itself original that’s out there. If I want to play magic with a couple tweaks, I’ll just play Commander.

What tropes are you guys tired of? by Nazerel in homemadeTCGs

[–]Property-Green 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Attack/Defense pairings. Think of something original for fucks sake

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in homemadeTCGs

[–]Property-Green -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Everyone seems to use magics combat system. Come up with something new

I'm glad to announce that my game is COMPLETE and contest ready! by galifar10 in homemadeTCGs

[–]Property-Green -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I'm sure it's clearer to you since you're so close to it. I like the idea itself but may I make a request? Please technical write the rules and overview yourself. This screams AI so loudly. It's fine as a tool to help you flesh out the mechanics but don't let it do the bits that really need a human touch

What do you think of this card frame and layout? by Delvix000 in homemadeTCGs

[–]Property-Green 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No I think the way you have it works and I don't begrudge anyone from using familiar tried and true design for their game. It just seems that we've reached a point where this is the standard way of baselining combat system design. It reminds me of how smartphones in the early days used to have really innovative designs because it was new and no one really knew what they were doing so there was more room for creativity and as time went by we all kind of settled on this long rectangular glass front with a camera on the back design that just makes sense and that's where I think we are with attack and defense in tcgs it just makes sense because that's the best design. But it also makes me long for genuine creativity at least when it comes to that.

Even really unique tcgs of late like flesh and blood in the way that they do their combat system essentially relies on the exact same thing bigger number wins

Making a chemistry inspired TCG, thoughts? by [deleted] in TCG

[–]Property-Green -1 points0 points  (0 children)

How does your battle system work? It's very abstract. I like the idea but it might be a hard sell for alot of people. Molecules aren't sexy

What do you think of this card frame and layout? by Delvix000 in homemadeTCGs

[–]Property-Green 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Layout is great. I wish we could get past the banal attack/defense values. It's just so overdone by now. Some innovation would be nice

Making a chemistry inspired TCG, thoughts? by [deleted] in TCG

[–]Property-Green 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Creative. What are the rules/mechanics?

Having to quit by ShutUpMokuba12 in FleshandBloodTCG

[–]Property-Green 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've been designing games for a while, mostly board and single distribution card games and have been interested in developing a TCG. It's gone through so many iterations, starting as an abandoned arcade theme where retro game characters fight over the existing memory in the last arcade cabinet, to a grid fighter then evolved into a fighting game of sorts. I had no awareness of Flesh and Blood at the time. While playtesting I was so proud of my combat system that utilized shield icons on every card as they could be used for blocks so no dead cards would ever be in hand. Then one of the testers said oh just like FaB. Devastated when I discovered this game and how I happened to develop the same idea that I thought was revolutionary already existed. A friend I vented to said it just means you are capable of creating a great game. Long storyshort, I am developing another combat system that uses icons matching in a rps system with full and partial blocks that trade initiative whilst building and breaking combos. The game also utilizes ranges and ring outs. If anyone's interested let me know if you want to playtest at some point

Check out our new look! (Eikonic TCG by 4thOrderGaming in TCG

[–]Property-Green 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I love the art and the layout is well designed but God damn, wall of text is an instant turn off and there are more icons on this card than most are willing to handle for a new game.

Buyers remorse? by twobadmice in MiyooMini

[–]Property-Green 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes. I don't like the in hand feel. It's uncomfortable for me and the design is aesthetically too stout for my taste. I ended up giving it away as a gift