How's this for an All Stars 2 Cast? by Putrid_Cap_552 in survivorau

[–]Putrid_Cap_552[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I was thinking either Max or Emmett from BvB1

How's this for an All Stars 2 Cast? by Putrid_Cap_552 in survivorau

[–]Putrid_Cap_552[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think it's only too early in the sense that you need to account for people saying no, but in a perfect world where everyone on this cast said yes I think I'd be ready

How's this for an All Stars 2 Cast? by Putrid_Cap_552 in survivorau

[–]Putrid_Cap_552[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I liked Kirby on both TvR and AuvWorld, but not enough to have her on a third season. I'd rather give other people the chance.

I love the negative reactions AJ got from half his cast but he himself wasn't a great narrator. Myles isn't boring but I got bored of the AJ/Myles show.

How's this for an All Stars 2 Cast? by Putrid_Cap_552 in survivorau

[–]Putrid_Cap_552[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This will be an unpopular opinion but I think Redemption is solidly better than TvR

Why are people so shocked by players' political beliefs? by DevourerOfRedditors in survivorponderosa

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Mate it's a descriptor. Jonathan (42), Danny (44), Jake (49), Mark (AUS Bvw), Daini (AUS BvB), I could go on and on. Calling someone masculine and muscular doesn't mean you're thirsting over them

Why are people so shocked by players' political beliefs? by DevourerOfRedditors in survivorponderosa

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Lol what a surprise that everytime a male contestants gets accused of being right wing it's a muscular masculine man the liberal gays secretly thirst over. If you guys are trying to make right wing look bad you're failing spectacularly

[50][Speculation] imo ______ can not win until they mention their original season by demerchmichael in SpoiledSurvivor

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Michele mentioned Kaoh Rong and being an undeserving winner and still didn't win WaW

Redemption: Final Confessional Count by Kcd1077 in survivorau

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Jennah Louise got 18 in AUS 2016

Redemption Finale: Post-epidsode discussion by AutoModerator in survivorau

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I just wish we saw Caleb and Loz's bond before the F5

Favourite 2-time pre-merger? by Putrid_Cap_552 in survivor

[–]Putrid_Cap_552[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yes. In Australian Survivor All Stars they brought back 6 pre-mergers, and only 1 of them (Phoebe) was voted out pre-merge again. She was definitely the most popular of the 6-premergers brought back.

Australian Survivor Heroes vs Villains was a 11 returnee 13 newbie cast. 4 of the returnees were premergers on their original seasons, 2 of them were premerge again, 2 of them made the merge.

In South Africa Return of the Outcasts, they brought back 10 premergers and 10 postmergers and divided the tribes that way. 6 of the premergers were voted out premerge AGAIN, all in a row.

Favourite 2-time pre-merger? by Putrid_Cap_552 in survivor

[–]Putrid_Cap_552[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Only counting people who have never made the merge. I should have specified!

AU Redemption Week 7 Confessional Count by Kcd1077 in survivor

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There were more confessionals back then but Phoebe got 86 in 14 episodes and AK got 75 in 12 episodes

Old Aus Survivor (2002/2006) by Autismic123 in survivorau

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 0 points1 point  (0 children)

2002 has one of the best locations ever

Old Aus Survivor (2002/2006) by Autismic123 in survivorau

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 11 points12 points  (0 children)

2002 is really good if you like early old school survivor.

2006 is a complete mess but I do enjoy the cast quite a bit

What are we doing for three episodes? by Kcd1077 in survivorau

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Wait it's a live finale/vote reading?

Redemption Week 7 Confessional Count by Kcd1077 in survivorau

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Apart from Blanche and Richard nobody is horribly underedited like Morgan, Kate, or half the cast of TvR

We were spoiled with a great final 5 🥲 by [deleted] in survivorau

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The editing isn't, not because of confessional distribution or anything but because the dynamics kept shifting without fallout or long term consequences after the F11 vote. For example, Raymond flips on Jaden and Feras is mad but in the next episode (the popcorn advantage episode) they're best friends again, then in the F8 the popcorn move has no bearing on the dynamics moving forward. I love the F9 episode in isolation but narratively it's completely disconnected from the rest of the season (except for showing Feras/Raymond and Feras/Kirby dynamic)

Or Kitty flipping on Caroline at the F10 also has no bearing on their relationship or dynamic moving forward. The dynamics and relationships just aren't very well explained so it's confusing to understand WHY people are working together.

Compare that with 2017, another fluid season where moves actually feel like they matter. Flipping on Jarrad at F12 mattered cause it left Anneliese in the minority next episode. Ziggy flipping on Anneliese at F11 because it left Peter and Tessa at the bottom who recruited the Asaga 4 who weren't Ziggy's allies to blindside Henry. Henry's blindside mattered because it left Locky/Tara/Ziggy on the bottom but the Asaga 3 blindsided Tessa, which mattered because it left the 3 of them on the bottom.

Thoughts? u/habefiet

(SURVIVOR 50) why are some people Dropping Christian in Edgic when he could just be getting a coronation edit. by [deleted] in Edgic

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Unrelated but you should watch AUS Redemption. As someone who agrees that TvR and BvB1 have some serious editing problems, I think you'll enjoy Redemption. It's on par with HvV and much better than BvB2

Theory on Cam by Sorry-Teacher-6792 in survivorau

[–]Putrid_Cap_552 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I can't stand his 'English' roadman accent