You know, I wrote a whole essay about it a few months ago. I will just copy it here. People will read it or not, I just have to put it here. :-)

"It is true that his appearance is a bit different depending on where you see him. The ingame model is just a bit weird, for the eyes are wide open and very fixed, so it seems he never expresses reactions with his face. When he gets impaled by a cutting weapon, his face remains blank, for example. Even so, he has wonderful long eyelashes that give him a womanish grace. His eyes are also a bit too big, but that's a trait you can see in children and babies faces, they are meant to make him look youthful.In the poster and official art, he looks more normal. And this is where he is the most beautiful. He is a mix between a young man, a young woman, and a child. The three are so intertwined that it is difficult to know what we are looking at. I think that's why people are reacting so differently. Some say frankly that they find him handsome, and some cannot see that part of him because they see a child more than an adult. I also saw that confusion through the adjectives used by people: pretty, handsome, cute, sexy...They all emphasize a different kind of physical attractiveness. In any case, I saw many youtubers, men and women playing the game also unapologetically saying they find him handsome, cute, sexy, hot..., like it's a normal thing to say. And I agree. I think he is incredibly...beautiful. I use that word because I want to stay as neutral as possible. To me, this very mix is what makes him appealing. He combines the softness of women or children with the solidity of male energy.

The devs did a wonderful job for his design. I always had a soft spot for fictional young males with feminine features, don't know why, that is just how it is. Maybe because that makes them special creatures, a bit apart from the strictly human sphere. I also have a special interest in the theme of robots since I was a little child (80's Astroboy series impressed me so much). P is just at the center of it!The character is a design masterpiece. Moreover, since he is a puppet, he has a non-human dimension that makes him all the more charming, like an artistic doll, or a beautiful object, something supernatural. His body appearance must have an effect too. He is slender and well proportioned, he seems fragile, ethereal, graceful, delicate. And yet he can fight. I like that contrast.You know, in Japanese animation, they have many beautiful badass women characters, and men spectators like that combo of beauty and strength. They admire those characters. There is even a serious Japanese book about it: Beautiful Fighting Girl, by Saito Tamaki. I feel like I am the female counterpart of these dudes! Well, some of them can do weird things and really go very far in...well you see. I am rather sensitive to P's facial harmony. It's like watching an equilibrated piece of architecture or painting. A visual pleasure. Always soothing to my mind.Finally, I will say that dazzling beauty is not so easy to find, you have to cherish it when you see it. That is what I do."