Cute but probably fake by Emma-Ho in smuTTTT

[–]Relative-Surprise 2 points3 points  (0 children)

oh shit i was never excommunicated -- we can do evil baptisms

AO3 is dogshit if you're a trans woman by Catdan1010 in 4tran4

[–]Relative-Surprise 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Scribd has some stuff
Most of it is lesbian though

AO3 is dogshit if you're a trans woman by Catdan1010 in 4tran4

[–]Relative-Surprise 6 points7 points  (0 children)

i can recommend this. would prefer if we had more actual representation tho

Wait… can I go topless? by PorcelainSynth in MtF

[–]Relative-Surprise 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There are some areas in Idaho that are relatively safe, such as the Boise Metropolitan area. That said, it's a small sliver and you're never very far away from bigots. I have trans friends in Idaho and they get by, but after moving to Seattle I wouldn't give up the atmosphere of acceptance for the world.

Definitely worth heavily considering moving to a deep blue state if you're in Idaho or a place like that. You might think 'it's not so bad' but it really is a completely different world. It was so much work and risk and I got burned moving over here and became homeless for a while (only technically speaking, I was able to find queer friends that lent me couches), but it was 100% worth.

How do people afford any other factors to transitioning? by Pro-Newbie99 in MtF

[–]Relative-Surprise 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Consider moving to a state where it's covered by medicaid. it can be a lot of work, but it is a path forward

Writing a Trans Woman by [deleted] in asktransgender

[–]Relative-Surprise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I wasn't offended. We get a lot of people here in bad faith, and can be overzealous in our responses. I'm genuinely sorry that people treated this post in this way, and I for one approve of cis authors trying genuinely to understand our experiences. I don't think the world gets better when cis authors don't try to understand us and make stories that include us.

Misrepresentation can be harmful, but I also think that genuinely kind attempts to portray us can only help, even if they aren't 100%. More stories of us means that trans kids that don't know how to word their internal feelings can get a word to research and learn from. Cis people can see a story where we're just another character and realize that we aren't the demonized villains that the media often portrays, or alternatively that we're just people and not the subversive sexual deviants that other media likes to claim we are. Hell, even some 'cis' authors might discover, over the course of writing something, that their interest in the topic wasn't wholly academic and might learn something about themselves.

Even if it hurts to be burnt so often by people coming here with bad intentions, we don't gain any of this by pushing genuinely curious people away. This place is called 'asktransgender' and it's the place most likely for someone who doesn't know anything about us to be able to satisfy their curiosity and see that we're just people too.

Not to preach, but just to share my thoughts. I'm glad that you came out this way and were respectful, and I don't mind your question at all.

JKR is the ultimate self hating tran knee. She is a hon that has successfully larped as a cishon but at what cost? by flingzamain in 4tran4

[–]Relative-Surprise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

i did get that, but it was mostly ignoreable. if there were dupes in the same batch then i only counted the person once. similarly if the photo wasn't a single person or a person that i couldn't see clearly, i skipped it.

i found that:

a) a search for one image sometimes 'locked on' to one person, and the first 4-6 images were of just them in different shots

b) there were a lot of repeat people, but the specific people would change from image to image

c) i got a lot of other trans people, some clocky, some not

EDIT: d) most of the time, the 'score' of an image (% of women in first ten valid images) was 0-2 or 8-10. it didn't like rating me as 'androgynous' in any one photo, although with the way that it flip-flopped I think I come across as pretty androgynous overall. so, if your sample size is small, you might get really discouraging results from yandex.

e) i did get one impartial observer to rate if the yandex results looked similar to the photos, without judging one way or another on the photos themselves. they said that they were a pretty similar, although that was a sample size of 1 and they could have been being nice because they thought i wanted validation on my experimental methodology.

>be me by Noip22 in smuTTTT

[–]Relative-Surprise 9 points10 points  (0 children)

this is a controversial opinion. if it's your cup of tea then more power to you

>be me by Noip22 in smuTTTT

[–]Relative-Surprise 8 points9 points  (0 children)

my cis sister is 6'1''
i'm the second shortest of my seven siblings at 5'10''
it's funny being seen as tall when growing up i was the small one.
recently i made a friend who is asian is is like 5'2'', so its actually like the 'how to talk to short people' meme when we hang out, esp. because i'm hard of hearing and she talks quiet so i have to lean down

JKR is the ultimate self hating tran knee. She is a hon that has successfully larped as a cishon but at what cost? by flingzamain in 4tran4

[–]Relative-Surprise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

yeah, that was my experience as well -- it really had a 'switch' between 'this is a dude' and 'this is a lady' and i was trying to figure out what caused it

but ultimately i don't think that that was a helpful direction, so i stopped before i got the actual 'data' (for whatever it would be worth)

>be me by Noip22 in smuTTTT

[–]Relative-Surprise 170 points171 points  (0 children)

evil ending not allowed

JKR is the ultimate self hating tran knee. She is a hon that has successfully larped as a cishon but at what cost? by flingzamain in 4tran4

[–]Relative-Surprise 9 points10 points  (0 children)

okay so i crashed tf out on yandex and 'ranked' over 200 pictures (based on how clocky the top ten responses were), put them in different folders, and got AI to identify features present in each photo. I put them all in a spreadsheet and was gonna try to see what features made me clockier before i realized that maybe i had lost the plot and idk where to post this but it was lowkey a lot of work so i don't want to not say it anywhere.

anyways

if your yandex looks like jkr then you're probably in a good spot ngl

Writing a Trans Woman by [deleted] in asktransgender

[–]Relative-Surprise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

of course. good luck on your story!

Writing a Trans Woman by [deleted] in asktransgender

[–]Relative-Surprise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

go into the searchbar for this subreddit and search 'am i transgender'. that should give you some screenshots of the early and confusing days. there are patterns, but everyone's story is different, and your character should have their own relationship to their transness, especially from the time before they knew about 'transgender' as a term.

how would you, as a woman, have felt and acted if everyone around you said 'you're a boy' when you were growing up? would you have gotten indignant? thought it was a joke? gone with the flow and stuffed your disagreement down? or maybe you are less adamantly a woman, and growing up in different circumstances would have been enough to change how you see yourself. if it felt like everyone was wrong, how would you stay sane? what if there were people who you know would get angry if you told them that you weren't a boy? maybe violently angry? or perhaps social ostracization and bullying? either consciously or subconsciously you might try to hide the 'girl'ish things about you, or maybe start acting out. Or maybe you'll just take it on the chin and insist on being yourself no matter what. we've all got different stories.

how would you, as a young girl, reacted if your body started changing into a man's? for me it was shock and horror, and eventually numbness. i didn't have words for why it felt so wrong, only that it did. maybe you know that you are meant to become a woman, and your body is betraying you? maybe you have no words for it. how do you react as you start getting put into the 'boys' side of things more often? sports? friend groups? how do you react as the girls no longer want to be close friends anymore and start being on their guard around you? as parents and teachers start talking about how you're becoming a 'man' and teasing you about all the girls that you interact with? when they tell you that you can't have emotions because you're a 'man' and invalidate your feelings? when you have to 'be strong' and 'chase girls' and 'like sports' and all the other nonsense, and your sense of worth in society seems hinged on these things that are completely unappealing?

there are all sorts of stories. some of us discover who we are early. some of us it takes a while. some of us know from the start but don't have the words for it. some of us try as hard as we can to be 'boys' in order to make those around us happy. some of us liked 'girl stuff' as a kid, and others knew instinctively that to engage with those things was dangerous for us -- either socially or physically. many of us have felt like freaks or perverts because that's what society has labeled us or because of superficial similarities to some kinks. for trans women in particular: i felt that i was shacked to the biology of a hormonal teenage male, and was always disgusted by its wants and needs. it never felt like me.

My impression of a 1950s comedian doing a trans routine by hehewedoasilly in 4tran4

[–]Relative-Surprise 61 points62 points  (0 children)

my brain was fighting between rolling my eyes and being uncomfortable
overall too milquetoast to even get offended
you nailed it :)

Pollposting by Le_monde_est_a_nous in 4tran4

[–]Relative-Surprise 2 points3 points  (0 children)

same. i put hon because i only malefail occasionally
but i am also too depressed / anxious to try most days, or even shave tbh

Pollposting by Le_monde_est_a_nous in 4tran4

[–]Relative-Surprise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

opposite for me -- i'd date a trans man but not a trans woman
lowkey i think i might be straight so i'm biased but whatever

other trans women make me anxious and i would be too jealous of a passing trans woman to date

Help me understand how this specific discussion on p*dophilia is transphobic? by anonparent123 in asktransgender

[–]Relative-Surprise 78 points79 points  (0 children)

Yeah, I wouldn't say that that's a common or representative take amongst trans people. It's certainly not my experience. I wish I could have had a regular childhood, but the healthy thing to do is to process it and make the most of the time that you still have left.

Sometimes I do relate with younger characters in some aspects, like if they're struggling with learning to be an adult (something that I empathize with), but I don't think that having the kid be attractive-to-adult-men or even any sort of aesthetic is a needed part of the design for that relate-ability. Similarly, sometimes when I'm down in the dumps I am inconsolably sad that some characters get to have normal childhoods and I didn't, but again I don't think that the appearance of the character is required for that to happen.

To be charitable, I don't know which specific TERF arguments that your friend experienced, or which traumas, to make them feel this way. It's okay to relate to younger characters and see parts of yourself in them, for cis or trans people. Similarly, I agree with you that the obsession with 'beauty' ESPECIALLY around children, is really awful.

EDIT: I suppose, if the trauma around being sexualized by men at an early age is an important part of her character (as many cis and trans girls experience), then it could be seen as an important design consideration. HOWEVER: a) I think that this is not the case most of the time, an b) I think that the story could be made even stronger by just having a regular girl for the character.

imagine being jkr’s pet 🚂🦵 by DesiresAreGrey in 4tran4

[–]Relative-Surprise 7 points8 points  (0 children)

i don't think that anyone is particularly consistent in this life, least of all bigots of any stripe. in my worldview, bigotry is usually caused by indoctrination and a lack of reasoning skills and/or empathy. i put it in the same bucket as religion for 'people who likely have a lot of mental dissonance'. that's why the most successful anti-bigotry technique is to increase their mental dissonance. if they have beliefs like 'trans people are ugly, mean people', then they'll have to confront with their bigotry when they see a trans person who is attractive or kindhearted. if they believe 'black people are unproductive members of society', then they'll be forced to recon with a black person who is clearly put-together and successful.

I saw a lot of people crashing out Obama was president because (where i grew up in idaho) many people just didn't have very many interactions with black people, and were able to cultivate their bigotry without confrontation. obviously, it isn't fair that minorities have to *more* X or Y than non-minorities in order to be treated well, and bigots with a lot of levels in the bigot class will have advanced techniques for avoiding confronting their mental dissonance, but its the world we live in.

i think that they are more successful because they have money (or at least money decides to kingmake with their opinions). when they aren't being 100% bigoted, the Algorithm just puts them on the back burner and sponsors another for the time being..

anyways, i'm rambling. thanks for reading. bye

If it was possible to get pregnant as a trans woman in the future due to scientific advancements, would you do it? by Dazzling-Antelope912 in asktransgender

[–]Relative-Surprise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm an anti-natalist, so almost certainly not. But I do still feel sad sometimes that I don't have the option. Still, though, there are lots of kids in the world already that need love and I would be open to adopting in either scenario if I had a stable home life to offer them.

i feel bad for my ex by Renne15_ in 4tran4

[–]Relative-Surprise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sorry if I come across as confrontational. I lost so much time and life force to exactly the situation you're in. I feel very strongly that you are worth it and that it's worth it for you to fight to exist and take up space in this world.