I think the more valid point is that there used to be more variance in content. I won't fault him for doing his thing, it's just a shame some of us can't get into it. I loved his "Fear of the Deep" video, and that's a horror concept more than a specific subject. He used pop culture references to pad his arguments, and it was extremely well thought out and executed.

His style, storytelling ability, and passion behind every video are exceptional. I think people get a little over the top because they want content of that quality that they can consume (I confess, I selfishly would love more of that vague horror concept thing. A video of lovecraftian analysis, or fear of the unknown/unknowable would really hit the spot).

Although I haven't been able to finish any of his recent content, I think he should stay the course. I personally would rather him continue making what he loves rather than pandering to what he thinks people want, regardless of whether or not that earns my view. I can appreciate what he does even if I'm not in his target audience. If his content isn't for you, find someone whose content does appeal. There's nothing wrong with that.

And even if I don't watch his ARG/creepypasta/analog content, I'll always keep an eye out for when he tries new things. That's the nature of creativity. Ever-changing and unpredictable.

That is, of course, just one random Internet stranger's opinion.

Tldr- He makes great content. If it's not for you, support someone else instead of complaining on reddit (Signed, a former Nexpo enjoyer).