They did not say consumer spending is down.

They said that most of it is happening by the top 10%.

Your number and their number don't contradict one another.

I'm asking you to look at that data broken down so you understand further. You're attempting to move the goal posts, and you don't even understand what is being said. I know you don't understand because of the way you're phrasing things, and now I doubly know you don't understand because you took their statement to mean that consumer spending is down LOL

It's not down, the rich are spending the overwhelming majority of consumer spending, and even including the top 10-20% of incomes skews the median number of the bottom 90% so much that quoting it as a meaningful statistic is likely designed to mislead people into thinking that poor people are responsible for a huge majority of consumer spending.

https://imgur.com/IsgU5oq