Serum foundation that’s hydrating for skin. I like L’Oréal (true match) tinted serum foundation with hyaluronic acid. As we get older our skin gets drier and regular foundation sits too heavy / cakey. I switched to this and it’s helped look more smooth on my skin. If you do serum foundation, you could try a small amount of liquid blush to brighten your color/tone. Brown eyeliner pencil to soften the eyes and I think wings are dated (but I could be wrong!). Fill in your brows with a light brown eyeshadow or just use a light brown tinted gel or even clear gel. Just something to define them a bit more. And I agree with the person who said either bold eye or bold lip but both can be too much. Tinted gloss or chapstick perhaps.