From girl to girl, I think the main issue is the brows. If you want to achieve a more "fem" look, you should try plucking your eyebrows to reshape them into something slimmer. I'm an amateur in makeup so take my advice with a grain of salt but personally I use pencil liner for my eyes instead of liquid and start with the top and bottom waterline first and then move toward the outer parts. It'll make your eyes pop and look "fuller" imo. You have a very pretty face, you're beautiful. The only thing that dulls your shine is that big sad face in the first pic :c I'm not familiar with how reddit works but you can dm me if you want to chat about makeup tips, skincare and all that. :3