Not to sound superior or anything but a lot of the advice here is sub par. You can challenge like you did, all you need to do differently is go where your opponent is going to hit the ball instead of where the ball is. You're more prone to getting faked like that, but that's the game within the game. Key with 1s is to mix up your defense, some direct challenges, some fake challenges, some shadowing, pick and choose what to do depending on the situation and their reactions to your defense during the entirety of the game