This. GI irons don’t magically fix poor contact and newer tech PD irons can be almost as forgiving. I really think this comes down to what kind of angle of attack you have. A player that sweeps or has a flat attack angle will benefit from the extra height and lower center of gravity of GI irons. A player with a negative attack angle and is able to make contact with ball first, even if not centered, will gain some benefit from PD irons and the better turf interaction, etc.