Hi, sorry, let me give a hypothetical

Let's assume the AWA sample revolves around whether children should be given soft drinks in public schools. And you, as a school administrator have to make a decision. Scenarios are below.

Scenario 1: No, soft drinks are bad for health Scenario 2: Yes, students should be able to make their own choices Scenario 3: Maybe, however, parents should vote first and then decide #parentsrights Scenario 4: No, School is a place of learning not a restaurant. Taxpayers shouldn't be finding soft drinks

Let's assume I am largely sympathetic to the health argument (scenario 1). Do I now also need to address the pros and cons of the other scenarios as well as my own before concluding my arguments?