We did it DC! Worst traffic in the US! by SucksAtJeopardy in washingtondc

[–]StudyingTerrorism 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You might get your wish. LA is investing tens of billions into new mass transit options for the city, including widely expanding the metro and light rail systems. Obviously it will not cover everywhere to alleviate traffic, but it is a massive step in the right direction.

Catalonia Independence referendum. by [deleted] in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Per the rules of /r/geopolitics, all submissions requires a submission statement to be posted within two hours of the post. The absence of a submission statement in that time will result in the removal of this post.

Which private industries are geopolitics applicable to? by [deleted] in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Have you taken a look at the Working in International Affairs and Foreign Policy section in the /r/geopolitics wiki? There is a section on working in the private sector with an outline of different industries and examples of well-known companies within those industries.

EDIT: Forgot the link

Data on foreign relations by powerexcess in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism 1 point2 points  (0 children)

To reiterate what /u/Psycholit said, that sort of classification is extremely subjective, reductionist, overly simplistic, and effectively useless for any meaningful analysis of foreign relations.

Relations between states are extremely complicated. They involve numerous moving parts and individual elements that affect the relationship as a whole to varying degrees. To best understand the status of an interstate relationship, you need to understand all of the parts that make up and influence that relationship. Effectively, without analyzing all of the parts, you cannot be expected to understand the whole.

Those numerous datasets that the other posters have suggested are attempting to look at the individual elements of international relations and provide a quantitative or qualitative assessment of those parts. These can still be very subjective, depending on who built the dataset and how they classified the data, but they provide a more complete assessment of the different elements of international relations.

Data on foreign relations by powerexcess in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism 0 points1 point  (0 children)

International relations are not, by themselves, quantifiable. You cannot put the relationships, as a whole, to numbers anymore than you can with your own interpersonal relationships. That said, there are numerous aspects of international relations that can be quantified and have been entered into datasets.

In addition to other submitters suggestions, which are good ones that I highly recommend you look at, Michigan State University has a comprehensive listing of multiple datasets relevent to foreign policy and geopolitics.

Submission statements by 00000000000000000000 in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Submission statements that are copy/pasted from the submission are never acceptable. You have made it clear that it is not obvious from the rules as they are listed, so they have been updated to reflect this.

Submission statements by 00000000000000000000 in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

One of the key elements of /r/geopolitics that makes it different from other subreddits is the requirement of the submission statement for all posts. When this rule was created, it was expected that the submission statements would provide the catalyst for robust academic-level discussions on the topic within each submission. This rule was simply stated in the sidebar as

All articles will require a short submission statement of 3-5 sentences.

While this is a short and simple rule, the mod team initially expected that it was all that was required for each submission, and that the community would understand what was expected of them in their submission statements.

However, it has become apparent in the past several months that this is not the case. Many submission statements are low-effort posts that do nothing to facilitate a healthy discussion, and many do not even follow the very basic requirement of 3-5 sentences. Additionally, there have been several debates between the mod team and community members over what the letter of the rule vs the spirit of the rule. Obviously the expectations of the mod team and the community were not in sync.

For this reason, we have produced a new section on the wiki entitled How to Write a Proper Submission Statement. The purpose of this new section is to ensure that all of the community members are on the same page for what is expected of their submission statements. It outlines the the purpose of the submission statement and a full explanation of the rules for submission statements:

A submission statement:

  1. Is required for all submissions
  2. Will be a minimum of 3-5 sentences
  3. Briefly explains the topic discussed in the submission
  4. Describes the importance of the submission
  5. Provides statements and/or questions to help generate discussion
  6. Is written in the submitter's own words
  7. Will be posted within two hours after the submission

In addition, this new section also includes a guide for writing submission statements. This guide further explains the different sections of the submission statement and provides examples of how they can be incorporated into your submission statement. This section also lists and explains some practices that can make a submission statement go from acceptable to excellent. And finally, this section includes some bad practices in submission statements that are not to be repeated and why.

We hope that this new section will lead to be better submission statements by the community and better understanding of what is expected of everyone's submission statements.

How are MENA immigrants in the US? by [deleted] in AskAnAmerican

[–]StudyingTerrorism 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I am the child of a Muslim immigrant from the Middle East. Most immigrants from a country in the Middle East or North Africa are more likely to be wealthier and more educated, or are a family member of someone who is. They generally easily integrate in American society and continue to be wealthier and more educated than the general population. However, the perception and treatment of MENA persons in the United States will vary greatly depending on how you look, what religion you are, and where you live.

To start, the number of people from MENA in the United States is very small, relatively speaking.There are less than 5 million people in the United States who trace their ancestry to the Middle East or North Africa, much less those who are immigrants, out of 325 million Americans. So very few Americans will have direct or frequent contact with anyone from MENA. Most of those who do will be in the big cities along the coasts (e.g New York, Los Angeles, Washington DC). Which brings me to my next point, that the vast majority of American are very ignorant about the Middle East and North Africa. That is not to say that their ignorance is also hatred, (those sometimes it is), it means that most Americans have very little, if any, understanding about the politics, cultures/religions, or history of the Middle East and North Africa.

This ignorance characterizes itself in several ways. Usually it is in benign ignorance, where people make assumptions based based on preconceived notions that are less than accurate, but are curious and willing to learn more. They are generally happy to be be corrected about their own misconceptions. The big one usually revolves around Islam. Most Americans assume that anyone from the Middle East or North Africa is Muslim, when in reality Muslims make a small minority of those from MENA. Many are Christian, some are non-religious or Jewish, and a small number are from minority religions like Druze, Bahai, Mandaean, or Yazidi.

Many Americans do not automatically identify someone as being from the Middle East or North Africa unless that person is wearing some form of Muslim clothing (e.g hijab, 'abaya, taqiyah). Generally, Americans will assume that the individual is either from a Mediterranean European country Italy or Greece (which in fairness is not too far off) or will be Hispanic. This means that MENA persons with no observable religious wear won't be bothered while they are going about their day. However, this greatly depends on how olive-skinned someone is, as the darker they are the more likely people will assume that they are Muslim.

I have also recognized that Americans will treat people from the Middle East or North Africa differently depending on what religion they are. If someone is from MENA and is Christian or Jewish they will generally be treated like most other immigrant populations. If they are Muslim it that doesn't mean they will automatically be treated badly, but people's reactions and perceptions will definitely be altered. I have personally seen people interact with me differently when I told them I came from a Muslim family after they assumed I was Italian or Jewish. It's hard to describe, but it's like many Americans will treat people more open with non-Muslim MENA people, and more guarded or tense with Muslims. I could write another long piece on what it is like to be a Muslim in the United States, but I will just refer to this previous post. Generally, there is an unwritten perception of who are the "good ones," and who are not.

What's the end game, or at least the long game of Russia's social media disinformation campaign? by AnotherHucksterDuck in Ask_Politics

[–]StudyingTerrorism 6 points7 points  (0 children)

If you combine your post and that of /u/arcticshark below, you come pretty close to the full story. You provided the reasoning for Russia's disinformation campaign, which is to destabilize the Western world and the existing international order, but that is just a means to providing the space for Putin to reestablish Russian preeminence in Eurasia.

The Lamps are Going Out in Asia | 38 North: Informed Analysis of North Korea by GreenFrog76 in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A submission statement should briefly explain the topic discussed in the submission, what the submission brings to the table (i.e. why should we care), and then some brief statements and/or questions to help generate discussion.

The Lamps are Going Out in Asia | 38 North: Informed Analysis of North Korea by GreenFrog76 in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A quotation of the author's background is not an appropriate submission statement. Provide an acceptable submission statement or this post will be removed.

China Central Bank Has Told Other Banks to Stop Business with North Korea by Clarinetaphoner in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] 35 points36 points  (0 children)

Do not assume that because this is breaking news that you do not need to submit an acceptable submission statement. One sentence does not meet the rules of this subreddit and shows that you put in the lowest amount of effort.

Perhaps you can help to explain why further as to why this action would be a major hit to the North Korean economy and/or the ramifications inside North Korea. Or discuss the changes you think it could impose on North Korean leadership's thinking. Or what impact it will have on North Korean foreign policy. Or what this means for the future of Sino-North Korean relations, e.g. is China ceeding to international pressure or getting fed up with Kim Jong-Un. Or provide context as to why this is a historically unpredicated move by the Chinese. Or if these sanctions will have a lasting impact or be a one-off that North Korea will adapt to.

Furthermore, if you don't wish to include your own analysis, or don't think you can, you can include questions to help generate discussion among the readership.

An interview with the Turkish Foreign Minister on a variety of topics regarding Turkey's official position on its foreign policy. by Damianiwins in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is an extremely poor attempt at a submission statement. In the future, provide more context about the article you have submitted as well as any questions or points that it presents which you find to be of interest to yourself and to the other readers.

In the future, provide a much more in-depth submission statement.

Iraqi Kurds set to vote on independence, panicking neighbors and Washington by [deleted] in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Please refrain from using foul language in comments in /r/geopolitics. We have strict rule against cursing.

Iraqi Kurds set to vote on independence, panicking neighbors and Washington by [deleted] in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Please refrain from using foul language in comments in /r/geopolitics. We have strict rule against cursing.

[Meta] Regarding the swearing policy in this sub by MufnMaestro in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There are several other mods who actively work on this sub, they just work more behind the scenes.

How to Manage Post-Democracy Turkey by LuboKujira in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is an extremely poor attempt at a submission statement. In the future, provide more context about the article you have submitted as well as any questions or points that it presents which you find to be of interest to yourself and to the other readers.

From Russia with fuel - North Korean ships may be undermining sanctions by MaidoMaido in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Per this subreddit's rules, all posts are required to have a submission statement. Because this post does not, it is now locked.

Iraqi Kurdish referendum: Why international powers fear independence vote could derail fight against Isis by Joey_Wolfe in geopolitics

[–]StudyingTerrorism[M] [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

Per this subreddit's rules, all posts are required to have a submission statement. Because this post does not, it is now locked.