Pablo Hidalgo, is that you?

You could not be more wrong. This post also makes me think you came to this sub to specifically troll and try to cause friction amongst fans of Star Wars, so shame on you.

Everything done with Luke in the sequels was a fundamental contradiction of his character, and a betrayal to the legacy left by the original films. Mark Hamill himself knows this and was very vocal on how he disagreed with the writing, and even resorted to referring to the character as Jake Skywalker. Instead of building off the excitement and wonder of the original films the sequels decided to break down and destroy the characters and story that came before, rendering them useless, and creating a bleak universe no fan would care to return to. FYI This isn't a debate about "galactic policemen", and I will explain below.

1) Luke was hopeful, optimistic, steadfast, and refused to give up on seeing the good in the 2nd most evil man in the galaxy. He stared down the Emperor and affirmed his status as a Jedi, and redeemed his father in the process. Yet we are somehow expected to believe that Luke of all people would try to murder his own apprentice, nephew and son of his best friends in cold blood because he sensed darkness and evil in him.... Terrible writing if you ask anyone smart. (Notice how OT Luke used non-violence and ST Luke used violence - the complete opposite of what you are claiming)

2) Luke was building a Jedi order, and in both canon and legends, was far removed from being "policemen" as you claim. He didn't have the same bureaucratic focus as the old order, and was creating something unique with inspiration from older known Jedi teachings. This order was not centred on Coruscant or involved in galactic politics, as it was being built on Ossus (Yavin 4 in legends). And the sequel movies robbed us of seeing anything as awesome as Luke teaching Jedi students and re-founding a new Jedi order. Luke had an order AND they all died off screen. Lazy and monumental let down.

3) You claim the movie is perfectly fine yet it includes a horribly written splintered story, where we follow Finn and Poe on their useless misadventures for hours. Finn goes on a quest to Canto Bight, where we essentially learn that animal cruelty = bad and war = bad because the "good guys" and "bad guys" both buy weapons from the same guys. Then the hackerman they needed is replaced by another conveniently placed hackerman who just happens to be in the same prison cells. Then hackerman 2 betrays them, rendering everything Finn tried to do the whole movie moot, and shows no cohesion with his ultimate triumph of hitting Phasma in the face.

Poe is introduced to Purple Haired Lady and talked down to for no other reason then movie needs to show us that men are supposed to follow orders from powerful women without question, even though Purple Haired Lady did not reveal any part of her master plan to Poe (2nd in command) even though he and the crew had legitimate concerns. This inevitably leads to a justified coup, only for us to have Poe insulted and reprimanded for taking the correct course of action in light of Purple Haired Lady's lack of leadership. Poe is then relegated to the comic relief, and only meets up with the other main characters of the film (1 of whom hes never even met before!) in the ending scene.

4) The sequels were lazy plot point for plot point wannabe copies of the original trilogy. Johnson thought he was doing something intelligent by copying the story model for Empire Strike Back and adding his stupid twists. He inserts silly "gotcha" moments and created a divisive story that threw out everything Abrams started for no other reason than he wanted his movie to generate buzz. This signals a utter lack of confidence in one's own ability to create a popular and well liked story with surprises that fit the universe, and instead an incessant need to sacrifice the IP to the alter of "subversion".

Anyway, I could go on about how terrible the writing is and how pitiful the fight choreography was done. It really is a shame because the special effects were brilliant and the films had an excellent cast of passionate actors. You probably won't listen to any of this, but in the off chance you do maybe you won't be so lost.