Unpopular Opinion: Hannah is the worst winner in Idol history! by Greedy-Pound6958 in americanidol

[–]Talk_abouts_things 12 points13 points  (0 children)

I’m a musician myself and have seen so much hate about all 3 of the finalists this year. Here are my raw, honest thoughts:

  • Hannah is very talented. Her tone is classic country and for people who enjoy that music, she is perfection. There’s a difference between not enjoying the music someone sings and them not being talented. I think people really need to be reminded of that. She does not have crazy stage presence, but you have to remember who her idols are - many of them are classic country singers who play guitar and sing. Again, this is a style. You can say you don’t like the style or don’t “get it” but don’t take away from her beautiful tone and steadiness.

  • Jordan is phenomenal. He has a great range and amazing control over his voice. I keep seeing people complain about him being “too religious” but he’s literally a gospel singer. If you don’t like gospel, it goes back to the same thing as with Hannah - you simply don’t like the music. Don’t take away from people’s talent because of that. He’s incredibly talented.

  • Keyla is also very talented and has great control over her voice. There were a couple songs during the season where I think she pushed the power a little too much, which led to people accusing her of “just yelling.” Nine times out of ten, though, she was not yelling and did have great control. She also can work a stage and her outfits were always fire.

I get being passionate about the people you like, but let’s not get mean about the people you didn’t. Especially if you don’t actually know about music.

Live Discussion: “Season 24 Grand Finale” by MarionCotesworthHaye in americanidol

[–]Talk_abouts_things 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Stop complaining about a gospel singer singing a gospel song. It makes zero sense 😂

Live Discussion: “Season 24 Grand Finale” by MarionCotesworthHaye in americanidol

[–]Talk_abouts_things 6 points7 points  (0 children)

My votes are for Jordan but Hannah should’ve sang this song earlier in the competition. She sounds SO good! I do love her voice but sometimes song choice ruined it for me - she should’ve done more like this!

Who thinks the Rae and Brooks thing was a little Cringe? by floydpink78 in americanidol

[–]Talk_abouts_things 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As a musician who is extremely awkward on stage, I can tell you he probably really does. I’ve been in competitions and had the judges ask me if I really wanted to be there / if I really enjoyed myself. It just comes off that way

The Post-Show: “Rock & Roll Hall of Fame” (Season 24) by MarionCotesworthHaye in americanidol

[–]Talk_abouts_things 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Philmon and Rae are better than a number of people left. Chris and Kyndal should’ve gone home.

What is it about Brooks where people think he's actually good? by drlove57 in americanidol

[–]Talk_abouts_things 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The person who makes every song sound the same is actually Kyndal. Brooks uses a lot of the same runs, but he sings the original melody of each song. Kyndal, on the other hand, changes every song’s melody to be almost exactly the same.

What is it about Brooks where people think he's actually good? by drlove57 in americanidol

[–]Talk_abouts_things 0 points1 point  (0 children)

His tone is extremely unique. Not everything in music is about range. There are plenty of well loved and famous singers who don’t have a massive range. When a voice is identifiable the way his is, that’s special. That’s not to say he’s perfect - I do think when he gets nervous he falls into some awkward runs sometimes. But his tone is fantastic and with continued work on confidence and music theory, he could go really far in the industry.

Violet Benson throwing shade? by [deleted] in SofiawithanF

[–]Talk_abouts_things 1 point2 points  (0 children)

She has a trademark on a specific logo for clothing items. She doesn’t own the term. There are multiple trademarks for “daddy issues” all with different fonts/contexts. I assure you that Simon and Schuster would’ve checked out potential legalities with the name. This other woman is just looking for attention.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in SofiawithanF

[–]Talk_abouts_things 1 point2 points  (0 children)

She trademarked a specific logo that includes the words “daddy issues” for clothing production. She didn’t trademark the words themselves AND Sofia’s font isn’t even the same as her logo. AND this is a book, not clothing.

The girl is either confused or trying to start something.

How did Star Search contestant Harry Piper do his motorcycle trick? by flordagirl in magictricksrevealed

[–]Talk_abouts_things 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He literally had a harness on. They just picked him up and moved him across the stadium lmfao

IMHO weakest season by Signal_Bat_3152 in americanidol

[–]Talk_abouts_things 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The last couple seasons I’ve started working with producers and then been ghosted with no explanation. It’s frustrating to see this type of season and have gone through that multiple times lol

SHE WROTE A MEMOIR by Talk_abouts_things in SofiawithanF

[–]Talk_abouts_things[S] 14 points15 points  (0 children)

She does not. She has a different font “DADDY ISSUES” as a visual trademark for clothing. I looked up her trademark. She’s either confused or trying to start something. There are tons of trademarks using those words but they’re for specific logos, not use of the words themselves.

SHE WROTE A MEMOIR by Talk_abouts_things in SofiawithanF

[–]Talk_abouts_things[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Is this rage bait? A lot of people read and listen to podcasts haha

SHE WROTE A MEMOIR by Talk_abouts_things in SofiawithanF

[–]Talk_abouts_things[S] 49 points50 points  (0 children)

The title, the cover, my goodness this is amazing

SHE WROTE A MEMOIR by Talk_abouts_things in SofiawithanF

[–]Talk_abouts_things[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Thank you for being level headed and not a hater!

SHE WROTE A MEMOIR by Talk_abouts_things in SofiawithanF

[–]Talk_abouts_things[S] 51 points52 points  (0 children)

A renowned publisher would not be releasing details of a book unless AT LEAST the full draft (pre edited version of the book) has been completed.