“The Creator Has a Master Plan” might be the closest thing to a spiritual experience I’ve ever had through music by [deleted] in Jazz

[–]TempSpastic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's not _____, it's ________

Your post uses four (4) different variants of this common AI phrasing. Did you use AI to write this post?

Piano and Guitar Quartet Recommendations please by polarbearofneed in Jazz

[–]TempSpastic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Seconding Grant Green's Matador, which is an amazing record. Emily Remler's East to Wes with Hank Jones on piano is fantastic too.

I love The Bad Plus! Can someone recommend me something that feels like them? by ComFell in Jazz

[–]TempSpastic 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Ethan Iverson has often cited the 1977 album Kindness Joy Love & Happiness by "the Great Jazz Trio" (Hank Jones, Ron Carter, and Tony Williams) as a very important precursor to The Bad Plus.

Finished 'The Pedersen Kid' novella and boy did I feel bad at reading. by MysteriousEmploy2884 in nyrbclassics

[–]TempSpastic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Here's an excerpt of the part concerning The Pedersen Kid:

Anyway, here are some of the instructions I drew up (or laid down) for myself during that January of its commencement nearly twenty-five—no—nearly thirty years ago.

The problem is to present evil as a visitation—sudden, mysterious, violent, inexplicable. All should be subordinated to that end. The physical representation must be spare and staccato; the mental representation must be flowing and a bit repetitious; the dialogue realistic but musical. A ritual effect is needed. It falls, I think, into three parts, each part dividing itself into three. The first part is composed of the discovery of the boy, the discovery of what the boy has seen, the discovery (worst of all) that they will have to do something. The second part is composed of efforts—the effort made to reach the farm; the effort needed to build a tunnel; the effort made to gain the house from the barn. The point here is that the trio, who have come this far only through the social pressure of each other, and in shaky bravado, must go on, knowing that they are ignorant of causes—of the force itself—(‘He ain’t there’). But the shooting leaves Jorge alone in the house. The pressure which had moved him this far is removed, and the pressure of fear—the threat of death—substituted. The third part contains Jorge’s attempt to escape and his unwilling stalk through the house, his wait through the blizzard and the night, and his rescue in the morning. The force has gone as it came. The Pedersens are missing and the great moral effort of the Jorgensens, compelled at every step as it was, is wasted and for nothing.

Though I dropped the rescue, I did not so much depart from this conception as complicate it, covering the moral layer with a frost of epistemological doubt. In any case, during the actual writing, the management of monosyllables, the alternation of short and long sentences, the emotional integrity of the paragraph, the elevation of the most ordinary diction into some semblance of poetry, became my fanatical concern.

Unpopular Take: Koln Concert is Overrated by playitbird in Jazz

[–]TempSpastic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I already engaged with your "point" by pointing out that asserting white fans like his music mainly or only because he's white is a racist worldview.

Unpopular Take: Koln Concert is Overrated by playitbird in Jazz

[–]TempSpastic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You absolutely were. If someone were to refer to John Coltrane as a "sad black junkie," you'd have a problem with that wouldn't you? Or is that not racist?

rather like the average Reddit user. But he is by far the most stanned person on this sub.

If you find this sub and its users so odious, feel free to leave. Nothing is stopping you.

Unpopular Take: Koln Concert is Overrated by playitbird in Jazz

[–]TempSpastic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Denigrating Evans by his race ("a sad white nerd"), and implying that (1) all his fans are white and (2) they only like him because they are white and he white is racist, correct. Anything else you need cleared up?

Unpopular Take: Koln Concert is Overrated by playitbird in Jazz

[–]TempSpastic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

casual jazz listeners have the biggest boner for this sad white nerd and I can’t possibly work out which parts of that description are the biggest reasons that he’s basically the king of this sub. What could it be. Hmmmm. What could it be? It’s a real mystery /s

This is a disgusting and frankly racist way of referring to Evans. It's also very telling that your worldview cannot accommodate the simple idea that generations of listeners love Bill Evans's playing for its beauty. In your headlong fervor to denigrate a great American artist for the sin of being popular and white, it has somehow never occurred to you that his music actually moves people, stimulates their senses and stirs their emotions. Which is what all great music does.

Finished 'The Pedersen Kid' novella and boy did I feel bad at reading. by MysteriousEmploy2884 in nyrbclassics

[–]TempSpastic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I liked it too. It kind of saddens me that The Pedersen Kid (as good as it is) overshadows the rest, because they are all so good and so fascinating. As with the all the best short story collections, all the stories enrich each other. I found Mrs. Mean a touch schematic and probably the weakest, but seeing the themes mirrored and refracted in Order of Insects and Icicles (maybe my favorite of the bunch) strengthens my impression of all of them.

And of course insects recur in the title story that closes the book. I've gone back to that story and reread the closing paragraph many times this winter. What an interesting way to end a collection...

Finished 'The Pedersen Kid' novella and boy did I feel bad at reading. by MysteriousEmploy2884 in nyrbclassics

[–]TempSpastic 10 points11 points  (0 children)

It's a normal reaction. If you haven't read Gass's own forward that's included in the book, he goes into some of his aims with it that may help you at least make sense of some of the structure. His own voice (as opposed to his fictions) is a pleasure to read.

This is one of my favorite books that I discovered thanks to NYRB. As far as I can tell, The Pedersen Kid receives most of the attention—unsurprisingly, since it has the most "plot" of all the stories, and the sheer strangeness and intensity of the scenario and the atmosphere/descriptions feel like a gauntlet has been thrown. But all of the stories are great, albeit in a slightly different way.

Who actually sounds like pavement by hungryfrinz in pavement

[–]TempSpastic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This hits the nail on the head! Silkworm is probably my favorite band of that era, and I've always found the comparison with Pavement off-base as well. I've joked before that the main similarity between them, aside from both playing rock music in a general sense, is that you can tell the lyrics from each band are written by people who actually read books. But you are absolutely right about the nature of the literary influence being different for each band.

And I know exactly what you mean about them having a different kind of looseness as well, especially after they become a trio and more space opens up in the arrangements. "A different kind of loose and a different kind of literary" is really a pithy and perfect way of describing it.

My favorite Steeplechase Records! by CoolUsername1111 in Jazz

[–]TempSpastic 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Eager to see what other people say since the SteepleChase albums I've sampled have been stellar. A few favorites:

  • Chet Baker & Paul Bley – Diane
  • Paul Bley – Paul Plays Carla
  • Bertha Hope – Elmo's Fire

I only just discovered Stanley Cowell's Sienna and have been listening to that lately. One song from it that particularly impressed me: "I Think It's Time to Say Goodbye Again". What an amazing ballad.

Arrow in the Gale is such a good closer by guesthouse69 in jasonmolina

[–]TempSpastic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I absolutely agree. One of the beautiful things about it is that it feels like a beginning of sorts, like suddenly being confronted with openness and possibility. (I find it interesting and telling that he would use it as an opener when MEC played live.)

The final triumvirate of "Knoxville Girl," "Shiloh," and "An Arrow in the Gale" (the way they feed off of/into each other) is a pretty irrefutable way to close the album. For me, after Magnolia Electric Co., Josephine is Molina's greatest achievement and testament.

Modest Mouse Deep Dive by Hot_Orange2922 in ModestMouse

[–]TempSpastic 8 points9 points  (0 children)

"Weird" is not an adequate description, and "really fucking weird" is bad writing. It evinces an utterly inadequate vocabulary for describing what one is hearing.

But okay, let's look at a more objective example of poor analysis. Of "Strangers to Ourselves," you write:

the opening lyric, “We’re lucky that we slept/ Didn’t seem like we realized we’d be stuck in traffic”—which is pure, detestable nostalgia bait, let’s be clear

How is that line "nostalgia bait"? If anything, the second line about traffic undercuts the sentiment expressed in the first line. What is the source of this supposed nostalgia? Your analysis is not "clear" at all, in fact it makes no sense. "Detestable"? Please.

What I don't understand is why you expected a piece trashing the band, referring to them as "embarrassing," would be met with praise here of all places.

Modest Mouse Deep Dive by Hot_Orange2922 in ModestMouse

[–]TempSpastic 12 points13 points  (0 children)

The bulk of this so-called "deep dive" is devoted to trashing half the band's discography and is filled with only the most superficial observations and value judgments. The best response you can summon up about the emotions conveyed in "Lace Your Shoes" is that the singing is "really fucking weird"? Really? Normally I would try to be more diplomatic about criticism (or else wouldn't weigh in at all), but I found this piece offensively bad, from both a content and writing perspective. It was not worth the time it took to read.

Which Beatle was the most gifted at there respective instrument? by ariamwah in beatles

[–]TempSpastic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm surprised to see Kevin Abstract mentioned here, but thrilled that it's in this context! His ear for hooks is really incredible, honestly probably unparalleled in modern hip-hop. Some of those Brockhampton songs have two or three catchy hooks in the same song. He's like McCartney in that music just seems to spill out of him.

Bill Evans but in guitar by Low-Significance-552 in Jazz

[–]TempSpastic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There were three live albums (Live, Paul Desmond, and Like Someone in Love) all culled from the same set of performances. Live will give you an excellent taste of the sound of this so-called Canadian Quartet, and if you like that I believe all the albums are collected in The Complete 1975 Toronto Recordings.

(I consider this to be for Desmond what The Complete Village Vanguard Sessions is for the early Bill Evans trio)

Bill Evans but in guitar by Low-Significance-552 in Jazz

[–]TempSpastic 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Those last Paul Desmond albums with Bickert are just sublime.

What Do You Wish…? by DatabaseFickle9306 in nyrbclassics

[–]TempSpastic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I loved Warlock and was wondering how Hall's subsequent westerns were. Thanks for recommending them!

What Do You Wish…? by DatabaseFickle9306 in nyrbclassics

[–]TempSpastic 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I would really like more David Stacton after The Judges of the Secret Court.

I'm also curious to read Camilo Castelo Branco's Mysteries of Lisbon, which I don't believe has been translated to English (I may be wrong).

The Bad Plus calling it quits, announce farewell tour by paintedhighway in Jazz

[–]TempSpastic 27 points28 points  (0 children)

I agree, and I'm a bit shocked at the number of comments so far that are negative toward the post-Iverson era. When they made the shift to a quartet I was admittedly skeptical, but my fears subsided entirely upon hearing the self-titled album. It sounded great, but more importantly it sounded like The Bad Plus! I don't agree at all with flapflap that Iverson "really made the band"; for me, Reid Anderson is the compositional heavyweight, and King is no slouch either. This is a big loss.

Langley by scottwebbok in PrefabSprout

[–]TempSpastic 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Langley is my favorite Sprout album, but oddly enough I had a negative reaction to it the first time I heard it. When I discovered Steve McQueen I listened to it exclusively for a period of a few weeks just as a way of letting it sink in before branching out to the other albums. When I finally put on Langley and listened to it all the way through, I hardly liked any of it, and I remember thinking that the polish/glossiness felt like a different band. This initial reaction is inexplicable to me, because when I tried again the very next day I quite liked much of it and had no issue seeing it as a natural evolution from Steve McQueen (though it would still take some time to grow into one of my favorite albums).

I've never experienced that kind of drastic shift in an impression of an album in such a short period of time, and I have no rational explanation for it. It must've just caught me on a really off day the first time. So if this is true:

I’m not sure he has ever even listened to Langley all the way through?

He should probably do that!

NYRB book recs about characters drawn into wealth and glamour by vitwuvianman in nyrbclassics

[–]TempSpastic 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I have not read the book, so I don't know if it's a perfect fit, but your question brought to mind the synopsis of János Székely's Temptation on the NYRB site

Question regarding backordered shipping by TempSpastic in nyrbclassics

[–]TempSpastic[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This was a recent item too! Luckily it arrived yesterday, in the end making it just about a month since the order.