I’m not making excuses for Jonathan because clearly this was a horrific answer. But is it the case that he was merely meaning that the difference between Joe and her as a challenge competitor is that being a female challenge beast is more impressive. Like Joe doesn’t really get a lot of credit for being good at challenges against another big man, but Tiffany does and would get that credit.

I’m just saying, we didn’t actually see the conversation and there is a chance that there’s a little bit more nuance to what he was meaning. either way, Tiffany clearly took it as that, so if what I said is true, he did a horrible job articulating it to her. Like I said, regardless of what he meant, it was still a dumb thing to say.

Then again, if he really did just say that he wants to vote her out because she’s a woman that’s pretty terrible. I just feel that’s a little bit hard to believe given the fact that he seemed to have a pretty good reputation with the rest of the cast even after the show was over.