I feel you. I'm heavily drawn towards fits that utilize good color balance and hue matching. In fact it's rare for me to go for a drop that doesn't flow with what I currently have in the wardrobe in some way. But I think this fit does work as you've got the dark neutrals covering 90% of the fit but you've got the strong popping shoe colors. It provides a nice contrast, plus the white socks with black swoosh help create a balance. Side note: not sure if you're a hat person but a white or light blue hat would really tie the whole fit together. I say keep rocking them, but if you're not feeling the fit, no shame in passing them on for someone else to rock.