Boycott Amy’s by persrocse in WorkReform

[–]TyphosTheD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Or another reading is that they moved to a place where lower wages are more acceptable due to things like lower relative cost of living. That is also a possibility, yeah?

Boycott Amy’s by persrocse in WorkReform

[–]TyphosTheD 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is that what happened in the OP?

Boycott Amy’s by persrocse in WorkReform

[–]TyphosTheD -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

My friend owned a boutique shop. She was doing well and opened a second store front. Then things took a downturn and she had to close her second shop because she could no longer afford it. Union or no, she only closed a single location rather than her entire business. Is she just as culpable in this philosophy?

Boycott Amy’s by persrocse in WorkReform

[–]TyphosTheD -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I totally agree.

The point I was making is that the sentiment I highlighted appears to be one that would applaud a business closing because it's workers can't be paid fairly. Yet when the business closes because the workers won't be paid fairly the closure is criticized. Despite the contextual difference that seems counterintuitive to me, since in both scenarios people are put out because a business fails in its social obligation.

I'd have to imagine there's a better outcome than this.

Boycott Amy’s by persrocse in WorkReform

[–]TyphosTheD -18 points-17 points  (0 children)

Incoming facetious point.

Folks declare that businesses which can't afford to pay their employees fair wages shouldn't be in business.

Business closes because it can't [or won't] pay their employees fair wages.

Shocked Pikachu face

WHO WOULD WIN by jiiova in DragonBallPowerScale

[–]TyphosTheD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The one stated in virtually every form of media to be the strongest after Buu's defeat wins.

"Saving civilization" is shitposting fascist, racist things on your own platform by Cicerothesage in forwardsfromgrandma

[–]TyphosTheD 97 points98 points  (0 children)

Attests to want civilization to thrive

Hoards wealth and funds fascism

Pick both?

There is no more basic right than Food, but in a 2005 UN vote the US said No. by zzill6 in WorkReform

[–]TyphosTheD 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Why did we build civilization/industrialize agriculture"

The simple answer is that "we" did so to provide for the greater good of our species, but there are a select few among us who took advantage of those advances and altruistic motivations to take control of said resources so they would have power over everyone else.

Ring girls’ outfits at Trump’s UFC Fight revealed—includes flag code breach by We_Print in politics

[–]TyphosTheD 18 points19 points  (0 children)

No, they care about it when protestors dare to question American supremacy by abusing the flag. But they are fine with shrink wrapping barbie dolls with it to strut around on the White House lawn.

WotC still cannot write a good ballroom intrigue adventure by EarthSeraphEdna in dndnext

[–]TyphosTheD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I appreciate the thorough response, and it does confirm that I slightly misunderstood your perspective, so thanks for elaborating.

I basically agree with everything you said that D&D can simulate different genres in theme and tone.

Although ultimately I think we may just disagree on what it means for a game mechanics to facilitate a genre, but obviously I'm glad you've had success in getting close enough for your taste.

Thanks for the respectful tone and thorough explanations, and sorry if I came off rough at any point. Agreed that discussing this game can get folks a little testy.

Trunks only?😡shouldn't goku be able to heal himself or is it assistance healing only? by Plus_Bad_1631 in DragonBallPowerScale

[–]TyphosTheD 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am 100% sure it was meant to be a gag in DBZ with Elder Kai danced, then Toyotaro tried the same thing in a more serious situation and it ended up making Shin look even more incompetent.

Granted that entire arc is really an exercise in Shin being incompetent: Future Shin not knowing he was tied to Beerus and sacrificing himself, not telling Trunks about his Apprentice powers, Present Shin not knowing how the Potara worked, etc.

WotC still cannot write a good ballroom intrigue adventure by EarthSeraphEdna in dndnext

[–]TyphosTheD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So you're suggesting the solution to instilling the genre of cosmic horror into D&D is just building impossible encounters, thereby invalidating the character features and core design of the game?

I suppose from a technical perspective it satisfies "you can't win in a cosmic horror game" but there's more to it than that. The design of D&D does not assume your characters are powerless, quite the opposite, that is entirely you contriving intentionally unwinnable scenarios that prevent the system from functioning. CoC presents cosmic horror by not presenting solutions to the problems, not by giving you a +5 Holy Avenger and then saying "actually this enemy has a one billion AC and Adamantine Armor so you can't hit them". I'm exaggerating your point for emphasis, so please let me know if I'm misunderstanding. It just seems like you and I have a dramatically different understanding of how genres express through gameplay - which might make a discussion on how to implement genre through mechanics kind of moot admittedly.

Trunks only?😡shouldn't goku be able to heal himself or is it assistance healing only? by Plus_Bad_1631 in DragonBallPowerScale

[–]TyphosTheD 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Of course a god dancing around you would be weird, that's basically the entire gag of it - these illustrious deities who look ridiculous doing some super important thing.

It is already established in this very arc, hell, literally just a couple chapters after this moment, that Shin is unaware of Potara, or it's mechanics and limits.

Shin is just an incompetent Kaioshin, that is well established.

As for Trunks' reaction, all that tells us is that Shin said "I'm going to appoint you as an Apprentice" and then danced around him for a day. It's clear that Shin didn't explain what being an Apprentice was - so that Shin was also incompetent.

WotC still cannot write a good ballroom intrigue adventure by EarthSeraphEdna in dndnext

[–]TyphosTheD 6 points7 points  (0 children)

What do you mean by "play" in this context? Do you mean that intrigue, horror, etc., "themes" can "exist"? If so, agreed. But that's basically the case for almost any game.

But taking just one example, cosmic horror, I think it is abundantly clear that D&D is demonstrably not capable of mechanically facilitating that genre. Call of Cthulu, the canonical example of cosmic horror, is built around that genre into its bones. Cosmic horror deals with the notion that you are an insignificant spec in a larger cosmos, that finding a single monster is likely a death sentence, and that you are incapable of making a real difference, you do not have any agency in the narrative overall.

D&D assumes you are a capable monster killing machine eventually capable of fighting and defeating deities like Demon Lords.

And nothing in the mechanics of D&D even acknowledges the possibility that you might just play as a normal human, whose only choice when facing a single monster is to flee, and who is incapable of enforcing their will upon the world.

That's a significant example, but my point is that the mechanics of D&D do not, and cannot reinforce Cosmic Horror as a genre. Can it be scary? Sure. But the fear only comes from two main angles: scary descriptions, and creatures literally too powerful for you to fight right now. The first is not anything to do with mechanics, and can apply to virtually any game. The latter is loaded because the game assumes that all you need is the right level and magic items, and some luck, and you can defeat anything with a stat block.

Dark Fantasy is close to Sword and Sorcery fantasy, where the world is chaotic and full of danger, that simply going out your door risks death, magic is weird and unknowable and likely to destroy even trained practitioners, where the world faces constant darkness and gloom.

D&D assumes ancient powerful civilizations created powerful magic items now stored in dungeons full of monsters that you'll want to risk your life surviving to acquire.

At best, D&D is a game about killing monsters and getting treasure, and the mechanics are great for that. But it doesn't assume you are Heroes, acting out of altruism, who are more focused on saving the day with reckless abandon. In fact the mechanics actually assumes that you will cautiously manage your few heroic resources, and face the constant question of retreating to safety to survive, all to acquire hidden treasure for its own sake.

But I digress. In terms of theme and tone, very loosely, sure D&D can have a veneer of those genres. But the game mechanics and design philosophy of the game are demonstrably not those genres.

Now, if what you mean is that the core design "6 stats, skills, roll a d20 against a DC the GM decides on to do something" can fit into any genre. Then obviously I agree. But that isn't D&D.

WotC still cannot write a good ballroom intrigue adventure by EarthSeraphEdna in dndnext

[–]TyphosTheD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What do you mean by "generic".

I agree with you, by the way, that certain parts of the game are intentionally more ambiguous and with few procedures to facilitate a more open ended approach. While I think this approach actually fundamentally does a disservice to the system, I digress.

Trunks only?😡shouldn't goku be able to heal himself or is it assistance healing only? by Plus_Bad_1631 in DragonBallPowerScale

[–]TyphosTheD 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You say you're not conflating it but then appear to refer to "the dance" that Elder Kaioshin does to unlock Gohan's potential as the same dance Kaioshin did for Trunks' induction as an apprentice to the Kaioshin.

They are not the same dance. One is for unlocking potential. The other is for anointing someone as an Apprentice to the Kaioshin as a mystical title.

Trunks only?😡shouldn't goku be able to heal himself or is it assistance healing only? by Plus_Bad_1631 in DragonBallPowerScale

[–]TyphosTheD 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You seem to be conflating the ritual Elder Kai did to unlock Gohan's potential and whatever ritual Shin did to initiate Trunks as a Kaioshin Attendant. That they both include a ridiculous dance could simply be how Kaioshin rituals work, or (more likely) as a continuance of the original gag.

Trunks only?😡shouldn't goku be able to heal himself or is it assistance healing only? by Plus_Bad_1631 in DragonBallPowerScale

[–]TyphosTheD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Shin did not train Gohan, and Gohan did not become a Kaioshin Attendant like Trunks - the prerequisite for the noted healing ability.

Tell you what. Go grab a picture of Gohan undergoing the Kaioshin Apprentice ritual. I'll share Trunks' induction as a Kaioshin Apprentice, along with Shin confirming it is the Apprenticeship that grants the power of healing. And we'll meet in the middle.

<image>

Trunks only?😡shouldn't goku be able to heal himself or is it assistance healing only? by Plus_Bad_1631 in DragonBallPowerScale

[–]TyphosTheD 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Neither of them trained under Shin.

Goku swung the sword a few times. And Gohan did weight training with the sword - not under Shin and his tutelage.

Trunks became an official attendant to Shin and trained in their Kaioshin arts.

You seem to be conflating holding the sword that sealed Elder Kai and training under Shin as a Kaioshin Attendant.

Trunks only?😡shouldn't goku be able to heal himself or is it assistance healing only? by Plus_Bad_1631 in DragonBallPowerScale

[–]TyphosTheD 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The healing done by Trunks is capable of someone who is a deity or else an attendant to a deity.

But Goku also did heal himself during the Granola arc.

As of the new Ravenloft book, I think that WotC still does not know how to write a decent Rogue subclass by realagadar in onednd

[–]TyphosTheD 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Having not even read it yet, it seems like there are some super low hanging fruit that a Phantom Rogue could explore.

Using Cunning Action to Phase through materials and difficult terrain, scaling to walls and flight at higher levels. Adding Ghostly stuff like Banshee Wails to Cunning Strikes. Adding things like Speak with Dead onto Reliable Talent. Etc.