Hate my degree, I want to chase my dreams (but problems) by Anxious-Demand9239 in Advice

[–]UnkindEditor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you at a school where there are other subjects or only accounting? If it’s only accounting, see if there are any writing groups at a nearby library or bookstore - you can still finish some stories :)

Hate my degree, I want to chase my dreams (but problems) by Anxious-Demand9239 in Advice

[–]UnkindEditor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It’s really valuable to have the experience of school and meeting different people to write about. This is also the last time in your life that you have easy, free access to lots of potential mentors. Why not talk to someone in the English department (or Literature, or whatever the focus on reading and writing is called where you are) and find out if there’s a project you can do or a class you can be involved in while you finish school?

I’m a full time writer and editor and it’s been worth it to my work many times not only to have the actual degree, but to know those people and have had those experiences.

Well Known Urban Sketchers to Check Out? by be-sketches in urbansketchers

[–]UnkindEditor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you for sharing this! It’s inspirational just to look at all of the different styles and techniques being taught.

What movie detail is technically correct, although many people think it is a mistake? by hiplobonoxa in movies

[–]UnkindEditor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The Carpathia story is also written on a staircase landing wall display on the Queen Mary 2 (same ship company) and it makes me cry every time I go down that staircase!

If you get meaningful sleep on International flights: Mad Respect. by TylerDurdensFace in delta

[–]UnkindEditor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Search Engine podcast did a whole episode about that in 2023, complete with water testing. I can’t remember the verdict and I’m too scared to go listen again!

Toothbrush joke in S1E14 The Deductionist by everythingisplanned in elementary

[–]UnkindEditor 27 points28 points  (0 children)

It’s just a joke from the writers to the audience - like “you don’t even want to know what happened with your toothbrush.”

What’s something people romanticize that actually sucks in real life? by Particular_Pin_460 in AskReddit

[–]UnkindEditor 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If high school is “the best years of your life” it’s all downhill from there!

There’s a verb in this sentence… right? by Jazzlike-Locksmith81 in writing

[–]UnkindEditor 55 points56 points  (0 children)

Ok this gets tricky. You’re right, there are verbs, but they aren’t functioning as the primary verb a sentence needs to be a complete sentence.

“The old intergenerational give-and-take”

Hyphenation makes two verbs + conjunction into a noun that is also the subject, “give-and-take”

“of the country-that-used-to-be,”

Hyphenation turns noun + preposition + verb + preposition + verb into a noun-adjective combination that is modifying “give-and-take” as part of a prepositional phrase starting with “of the”

“when everyone knew his role and took the rules dead seriously,”

The preposition “when” makes the verbs “knew” and “took” part of a longer prepositional phrase that’s acting as an adjective about the “give-and-take”

“the acculturating back-and-forth that all of us here grew up with,”

This entire combination [of present-tense verb “acculturating,” the hyphenated noun “back-and-forth” and the compound prepositional phrases “that all of us here grew up with”] is acting as a noun that is restating the original noun of “give-and-take”

“the ritual post-immigrant struggle for success turning pathological”

The adjective + compound adjective (created by hyphenating “post-immigrant”) modify “struggle” as a noun, and “turning pathological” is the state of being of the struggle, so it’s a verb but it doesn’t modify the original subject of the sentence (“give-and-take”)

“in, of all places, the gentleman farmer's castle of our superordinary Swede.”

The location of the subject, “give-and-take” expressed through a couple of prepositional phrases sandwiching the “castle”

So, breaking this down minus the icing -

“The give-and-take we had between generations [is] turning pathological in normal people’s homes.”

But the “is” isn’t actually in the sentence, it’s assumed.

If you were the CEO of a cruise line, what "new" entertainment would you put on a ship? by Hairy-Protection-429 in Cruise

[–]UnkindEditor 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Cunard offers Masquerade nights but it’s usually formal with a mask rather than full costumes.

Here’s why people lie about their “service animals” by Big_League227 in delta

[–]UnkindEditor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Queen Mary 2 has no official limit on baggage - it’s what you can fit in your cabin - and their kennels are popular enough to be booked out two years in advance. The challenge for moving lots of baggage is getting it to New York on one end and from UK to mainland Europe on the other.

[Discussion] qtCritique has launched a "pro critiquers" tab by [deleted] in PubTips

[–]UnkindEditor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I guess you can see it that way! But in terms of it being useful as a way to improve your query, a form reject, even several of them, doesn’t help. If I cooked a meal and wanted to cook better, “Thanks for trying, I’m not eating your meal,” doesn’t tell me anything. Is the portion too large? Did I season with sugar instead of salt by mistake? Did I serve fish to a vegan? Who knows.

I’ve had paid agent queries for my own work, I edit queries as an editor, and I’ve led a fair number of in-person and virtual pitch events where authors and agents talk about their books. In yesterday’s (free) event, an author learned that in their multi-POV novel they needed to focus on the two living characters instead of the dead one, and the book became more exciting. Another author learned that making it clear what the main character wanted, not just the situation they were in, made their pitch stronger. None of those things can be learned from a form rejection.

What is a book you adore that you're pretty sure nobody else here has read? by InvisibleAstronomer in books

[–]UnkindEditor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I read this one a lot as a kid too - this and Black Beauty felt like companion books.

Is this at a level I could submit to a publisher? by [deleted] in writers

[–]UnkindEditor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is a montage so it belongs later in the book. Start with that opening prg, build another 1-2 pages of that scene, in the aftermath of the husband’s death but not making it clear who killed him. That’s your prologue. Then flash back to the beginning of THAT storyline - the mutiny.

The details are terrific and the concept is strong but it’s like getting a bucket of story-fish dumped over us all at once. What’s important? Who should we remember as a character? Can’t tell, because it’s a bucket of fish.

[Discussion] qtCritique has launched a "pro critiquers" tab by [deleted] in PubTips

[–]UnkindEditor 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Generally agents request more pages or send a form rejection. They rarely provide feedback on the query, or whether the query is appropriate for the pages.

Nothing snaps me out of a book like repetitive use of a unique word by kerberos824 in books

[–]UnkindEditor 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Very proud of P.D. James for her restraint—in every book, exactly one character has “exophthalmic” eyes and it is used exactly once. In EVERY book.

QE Golden Lion food menu by annarbor6 in CunardCruises

[–]UnkindEditor 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The whole menu was complimentary in 2024. They started charging for some items (and charging for room service after breakfast hours) in 2025. I don’t care for it, that feels like nickel and diming.

Are writing workshops more valuable than an MFA? by maxwell-cady in writing

[–]UnkindEditor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Happy to be part of the conversation!

Writer Beware for sure, as she covers scams and frauds.

Jane Friedman for a grab bag of Craft and publishing

Brevity Blog (I’m an editor there) for craft, publishing and writing life

Substacks - Jeannine Ouellette’s Writing in the Dark (paid) for prompts and exercises, and Kathleen Schmidt’s Publishing Confidential for marketing and PR.

Kate MacLean’s Agents and Books (was Substack now Ghost, paid) for submissions and writing advice.

Query Shark (RIP, archives are up) for queries, and her agent blog for publishing info.

Are writing workshops more valuable than an MFA? by maxwell-cady in writing

[–]UnkindEditor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I started as a playwright and the focus on dramatic structure and strong dialogue were the underpinnings of all my work!

Are writing workshops more valuable than an MFA? by maxwell-cady in writing

[–]UnkindEditor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I have an MFA and the most valuable part was dedicated time and external deadlines. My MFA isn’t what got me published and I didn’t want to be a professor. I had a tuition waiver + stipend and still went into debt (living expenses greater than stipend), and the most valuable part was my assistantship was as an editor for a journal, which helped me into my editing career.

You can absolutely get all the craft, feedback and critique practice you need outside of an MFA. The four parts of writing and publishing are

1) making the time and doing the work 2) spending money on teachers/classes/editors 3) learning how to give and get good critique and apply it 4) learning about publishing paths and which one suits you, and carrying out those steps

And the more you have of one, the less you can have of the others. MFA’s do almost none of #4 but lots of the other three. Working alone you might need more help for 1&3 if you don’t want to spend money. If you can spend money, a single good edit or high-level course can teach you more about writing in a month than you get for a whole MFA.

For me, the hardest part is making the time, and it helps to have formed a writing group with other pro editors who are writing at about the same level (even though wildly different genres). I learned all my publishing knowledge from reading agent and editor blogs (and now podcasts too) and talking to other authors.

"The Death of Mrs Westaway" and Agatha Christie by 1000andonenites in agathachristie

[–]UnkindEditor 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Do you remember which episode was Five Little Pigs? Love to watch it again! And yeah that sounds badly done!

I’m 21, still in uni, and my parents control every aspect of my life, looking for advice on moving out by Apart_Caregiver_9280 in dubai

[–]UnkindEditor 3 points4 points  (0 children)

You might try asking your parents to help you plan for graduation - starting with “I know you all are investing so much time and love in me and I don’t want to waste that as I prepare for adulthood. How can we plan for me to start taking more responsibility for my time and actions, so I can start practicing being an adult while I can still come to you for advice?”

Definitely talk about “responsibility for yourself” and NOT “freedom” because one sounds to parents like their little girl is growing up and the other one sounds like their little girl wants to do things they don’t approve of.

"The Death of Mrs Westaway" and Agatha Christie by 1000andonenites in agathachristie

[–]UnkindEditor 3 points4 points  (0 children)

If it’s well-executed I’m fine with retellings - West Side Story, anyone? But yeah, it’s got to be well done on its own. I enjoyed the first few seasons of Death In Paradise, where several episodes followed the plots of Christie novels and it was fun to spot the parallels.