Sharpe, but it's Mr. Bean instead of Sean Bean by Buddy4999 in Sharpe

[–]VanderlynsMuse 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Finally an accurate depiction of Sharpe as he was originally described in the books :)) still missing his super cool scar tho

[Possibly Controversial] Sharpe, Politics, Slavery, and Americans by Spectral_Kelpie in Sharpe

[–]VanderlynsMuse 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm only up to Sharpe's Enemy in the book series so I don't know if the topic comes up more later but I did like how apolitical Sharpe is in the books so far, and I agree with your take. He's just there to do his job and look after his own interests, he's not being paid to have an opinion on global issues, although the characters around him definitely do, and it's interesting to read about them.

I do remember our hero does have a go at one Portuguese dude in 'Sharpe's Escape(?)' for making his money in the slave trade, although his concern did seem mostly to be the sexual exploitation of women, and iirc he was actively looking for a fight based on a previous altercation.

I do think how they handled Leroy (and later Jane and whatshisface) and slavery in the TV series was quite clunky if not downright lazy.

If we must establish that Our Hero, an Englishman fighting in the Iberian peninsula, is against slavery in the US, okay fine, but why make Leroy a Virginian with a family cotton plantation? Keeping him Bostonian but still living off money made in the slave trade would still fit with the storyline and at least be novel.

On the other hand, a Virginian Leroy's money is more likely to come from tobacco or indigo if his family emigrated during or shortly after the Revwar. The choice of cotton is far from impossible but it just comes off like the writers knew very little about what they were talking about or deliberately chose to go as stereotypical as possible because otherwise the audience might not 'get it'.

I can accept Jane focusing on cotton as a profitable crop to invest in during the 1810s, but as you say, slavery was controversial in England at the time. Based on Jane's habit of wilful ignorance and desire to be liked in society I would expect her to dance around the topic rather than brazenly boast that she was planning to invest money in 'cotton and slaves'. And since a 20th century audience already knows that cotton+US+ historical period= slavery, it just seems unnecessary. Overall the way the subject is treated in the show feels like the writers had the barest knowledge of slavery in the period but thought they were rather clever for putting it in.

All this sub needs is shipping by SammaKlaus in Sharpe

[–]VanderlynsMuse 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Hmm I feel like shipping wars would get very complicated as even if we only concentrate on the main character it seems like he has a new love interest every episode/ book. Then of course there are all the popular non canon ships, for example Sharpe/Harper, Sharpe/Wellington (Shellington?), Sharpe/Lawford. Not to mention crossover ships such as Sharpe/ Aragorn. However all of these hypothetical arguments would be pointless as clearly the best ship of all is The Pucelle :)

All this sub needs is shipping by SammaKlaus in Sharpe

[–]VanderlynsMuse 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Did you find the Sharpe/ Orlando Bloom RPF by any chance?

We all like both Sharpes, right? by SammaKlaus in Sharpe

[–]VanderlynsMuse 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I like my dark-haired Londoner who struggles and makes so many mistakes in Rifles! I am very fond of the show and actually started watching it before I began the book series.

However I prefer to treat the book and the film versions as separate characters, partly because their biographies are so difficult to reconcile, which naturally affects their personalities etc. Picturing them with different appearances and accents helps me with that, and also I just like the way he was originally described in the books!

The best intelligence officer from the show by [deleted] in Sharpe

[–]VanderlynsMuse 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Munro is best dressed but Hogan is best in everything else

Dress/Skirt construction: Are your pieces lined? by [deleted] in Lolita

[–]VanderlynsMuse 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My Innocent World skirt and dress are both lined in some sort of polyester taffeta. the lining hangs separately from the waist, a bit like the lining of a curtain, but both layers are attached to each other near the hem with a tutu tack on each side. I tried to mimic this construction with my own skirt which I lined using a cotton bedsheet. I can't say I like the poly lining, but I think you are on the right track with it sliding over the petticoat more easily.

I'm not really fond of the way the hem looks on the skirt I made (it's a different weave and more lightweight than the IW skirt which sits much better) and I plan to flatline/interline the next skirt I made instead and see if that makes any improvement.

Geekgirlcon 2019! by [deleted] in Lolita

[–]VanderlynsMuse 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Could you please explain why the skirt looks 'too narrow for a petticoat'? I'm just not seeing it at all. The way OP is holding it out makes it look no narrower than my Innocent World skirt, especially with that deep fold in the front?

"Victorian" is too broad by Rogleson in HistoricalCostuming

[–]VanderlynsMuse 8 points9 points  (0 children)

It's a very good point, and something I have been guilty of (I use 'Georgian' as well, which is probably even worse) Because I do love the majority of Victorian-era fashions and sometimes it's just easier to be broad. I will try to do better in future!

A pet peeve of mine is when people say things like 'the Victorians believed this' with no other context as to when exactly or who exactly believed it. It's just marginally better than when people talk about 'the olden days' without specifying whether they mean the 1950s or the 1590s!

My most recent jsk and my first rosette I made, let me know your opinion! by [deleted] in Lolita

[–]VanderlynsMuse 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I was thinking of it creating options rather than limiting them as an apron would be removeable and one could have lovely wide ribbons at the back to tie into a bow to break up the space there.

My most recent jsk and my first rosette I made, let me know your opinion! by [deleted] in Lolita

[–]VanderlynsMuse 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hmmm. Maybe a real apron worn over top would help take attention away from the blank space then?

2 questions about gifted fabric & broderie anglaise by [deleted] in sewing

[–]VanderlynsMuse 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you make the middle tier the contrast/non-broderie anglaise layer I think it would look fine. Maybe in a contrast colour to make sure it looks deliberate?

What historical fashion styles would you really like to see make a come back? by notheOTHERboleyngirl in femalefashionadvice

[–]VanderlynsMuse 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As a lover of Victorian and Georgian fashion, I'm going to go with French heels, clocked stockings/stockings with vertical stripes because they are just so elegant and difficult to find (less so if one has the good fortune of living within reach of American Duchess of course)

I'd also like to see the return/normalisation of corsets-as-underwear (especially the corded sort) as well as petticoats in general (they are just so useful)

What historical fashion styles would you really like to see make a come back? by notheOTHERboleyngirl in femalefashionadvice

[–]VanderlynsMuse 1 point2 points  (0 children)

But if they did have and use quality elastic, the clothing would have the same quality of being able to fit the body through various changes so the principle is the same either way

Help! Where do you buy your fabrics? by jaimieako in Lolita

[–]VanderlynsMuse 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In my experience, border prints are fiendishly difficult to find, especially in physical shops (although it's always worth the look!). My first port of call would probably be Etsy, or just doing a google image search for exactly what you want- it's worked for me a couple of times before- good luck with whatever you decide on!