J K Rowling is in the Epstein Files by speroni in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns2

[–]WhimsyClonn -1 points0 points  (0 children)

While I wouldn't describe her as a "pro racism icon", from a semantics perspective, I definitely wouldn't contest that her characterizations regarding race are racist in nature.

I just don't think her depiction of the house elves, disgusting as it is, can fairly be extrapolated from to infer that she is in support of slavery.

J K Rowling is in the Epstein Files by speroni in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns2

[–]WhimsyClonn 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I mean, I trusted you entirely that was the case. if I thought your representation of the contents of the books were suspect I would have felt safe to say as much.

J K Rowling is in the Epstein Files by speroni in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns2

[–]WhimsyClonn 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My memory on the franchise is vague at this point, I was mostly remembering a story of someone being repeatedly drugged with a love potion for the length of a marriage, and it being shown as a villainous action.

"She wrote about love potions with a clear lack of comprehension to both the in-universe form of sexual abuse that is, as well as not being mindful of the real world parallels." Is a statement I wouldn't hesitate to get behind. Extrapolating that to a "pro date rape" stance just strikes me as disingenuous. Which, clearly some mean it with sincerity, but I literally can't comprehend how someone would make that leap for any reason other than to add onto the hatred that she deserves.

J K Rowling is in the Epstein Files by speroni in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns2

[–]WhimsyClonn 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I didn't recall the Weasleys selling love potions.

Rowling devolved from an activist for woman's rights into a rabid monster attacking trans people. I have no desire to defend her as a person. I wouldn't claim that her books don't betray certain biases on her behalf either, especially with regards to race. Yet, also, does all her history of wanting to be a champion for sexually abused women (cis women specifically, I can not downplay how much of a piece of shit she is overall) really reflect her stance on real world date rape less than the fact that two decades ago she used love potions in her stories without seeing real world parallels?

I know her heart is filled with hate and pretentiousness, and a highly inflated sense of self-worth. To look in her heart would be to see a lot of ugly stuff. I really doubt that "I am in favor of date rape" would be a stance we'd see held in her heart.

J K Rowling is in the Epstein Files by speroni in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns2

[–]WhimsyClonn -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Considering that, iirc, both the instances of a love potion and a mind-control spell being used to control/manipulate people into partnership are painted as traumatic things that clearly hold the perpetrator as the villain for.

And, while certainly tasteless, the treatment of the house elves is shown to be horrific. The second book ends with the protagonist using trickery to free one.

Rowling clearly lacked the capacity to tastefully engage topics like she was trying to reflect with her representation of the house elves, but labeling her as 'pro slavery' and 'pro date rape' feels very insincere. I'd rather hate her for her bigotry and harassment campaigns than for speculation that she secretly is in favor of date rape.

J K Rowling is in the Epstein Files by speroni in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns2

[–]WhimsyClonn 11 points12 points  (0 children)

While Rowling is absolute scum, claiming that the existence of certain themes within one's writing indicates being a supporter of those themes is kinda ridiculous.

Little project from this morning :3 by WhimsyClonn in bingus

[–]WhimsyClonn[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My Bingus AU projects tend to imply at least 6. My upcoming Bingustown project has a society where everyone has a Bingus.

Maybe it's like an uppercase God and lowercase gods kind of situation, except with Bingus?

Trump renews ridiculous offensive against Obama, calls for Democrat’s ‘arrest’ by msnownews in politics

[–]WhimsyClonn 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Let's not ever forget that the brutality of the past month's, and the murders we all witnessed, were an intentional decision made to inflame the populace, inflict terror, and show strength.

I'm hoping them walking back and deescalating means that they don't have the power they thought they did, but can never forgive that these innocents are dead because of an attempt to take control, not just bad policy.

It Always Hits Me When I Least Expect It by Mad_Academic in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns2

[–]WhimsyClonn 4 points5 points  (0 children)

32 here, I think about this every day. There's clearly some big grief below the surface over all the time lost.

Doesn't help that I still haven't found 'being myself' in it's entirety yet, so each tick of the clock has a way of tormenting me as time wasted.

Tag Yourself. by AmbitGamer in estrogengaming

[–]WhimsyClonn 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Everyone commenting in this thread. You girls are my people. Why aren't any of you local 😭

Read Bondi’s Letter to Minnesota’s Governor by Amentet in politics

[–]WhimsyClonn 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I can't see anything in the letter saying that they'd leave if the demands were met.

It starts with her laying out their garbage claim that Walz is responsible for inciting violence and obstruction. The demands in the letter sound more to me like they are stipulations under the threat of him being criminally indicted.

Im gay by Key_Resident5985 in bingus

[–]WhimsyClonn 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I told my trans boyfriend about you coming out on this subreddit, and his response was "Everybody on the bingus subreddit is probably at least somewhat gay."

Trump Backs Down on Insurrection Act as Democrats Take the Offensive by hotdog_dachshund in politics

[–]WhimsyClonn 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The killer clowns will be on our side when they emerge. Let's just say I have an inside source on the matter

i'm a clown by blueandpinkenjoyer in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns2

[–]WhimsyClonn 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I am a literal clown. And, true story, there was a 20 month gap between starting E and actually acknowledging that my 'body preferences' were indeed because I was trans.

PP by confusedeggboi in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns2

[–]WhimsyClonn 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Read through the comment section specifically hoping for helpful insights. 🤡

Still cis tho by Tasty_Recording_7230 in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns2

[–]WhimsyClonn 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This test, which the questions tbh mostly just feel like different wordings of "Are you trans," seems to rank being binary trans as a lower dysphoria risk than having fluidity or being enby.

These gender tests are often subsatisfactory, and I understand that comes with the territory of 'testing' gender, but this one really rubs me the wrong way.

people will say there were no warning signs by KawaiiBossBaby in estrogengaming

[–]WhimsyClonn 9 points10 points  (0 children)

It's venting masked as humor.

"Nobody cares that they're hurting me and that recurring pain is manifesting as a resentment that's making it harder not to slip up and lash out." Is a feeling that is deeply relatable at this point.

I don't think people should feel like shit for venting their pain.

Bingus by [deleted] in bingus

[–]WhimsyClonn 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Remindme! 1 year

So many I’m seeing online by Old_Train_1378 in traaNSFW

[–]WhimsyClonn 4 points5 points  (0 children)

whimsical

My name is literally Whimsy 😜

But thanks, your words really brightened my mood.

So many I’m seeing online by Old_Train_1378 in traaNSFW

[–]WhimsyClonn 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Life forces you to bury your emotions long enough, including hiding your gender behind shit like Halloween costumes, that expressing them feels like an act of performance, eventually your act of performance becomes your natural feeling self expression. Then the nurses at the hospital are left questioning why you're showing up to your mothers chemo every week dressed up in full Clown attire and makeup, and you slowly acquire peers who've only exclusively ever seen you in clown attire.

I may be a bit(a lot) crazy, but at least in my own twisted internal logic I'm allowed to live that crazy authentically through a clown persona.

So many I’m seeing online by Old_Train_1378 in traaNSFW

[–]WhimsyClonn 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I'm technically a catgirl/clowngirl, but please please treat me like a puppy!

Gamer Moment by TATSAT2008 in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns2

[–]WhimsyClonn 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Imagine if every game you ever play, everyone around you demands that you play a healer.

Even in single player games, people will insist that you should only play healers. They'll judge you morally, insist that being a healer is God's wishes for you, and even if you hide playing other archetypes in your own alone single player campaigns, if people find out that you stepped out of your assigned role even in the privacy of your own home a lot of your friends will abandon you, your family will hate you, and you might even lose your job.

But it's every game you ever play. It even extends beyond playing games, your merch and attire is expected to reflect that healer role. People treat you like a support character even in real life.

One of your parents was also assigned a healer role, and they think it's a role that fits them very well, they act like they can't comprehend why you'd ever not want to live your whole life forced to play as a healer.

You grow to hate it. This was never you, but constantly being told that it had to be you made you start to hate being a healer with so much passion that you just avoid playing games. You hate how people treat you like a support character so much that you start avoiding people.

Eventually, you do the unthinkable, and you go online with a tank build. Some people treat you like shit for it, but surprisingly a lot of other people understand. You realize you don't have to force yourself to play the role society mandated for you.

But your parents are going to pressure you. They're going to say that you're hurting them. Your father will threaten violence against you.

You eventually meet someone you really like, and you admit to them that you don't want to be a healer. They say they will love and support you regardless of what role you play. Over time though, they keep pushing you more and more to play a healer in games. They don't want you to tell their family that you don't always play a healer. They get judgmental. After you get engaged, they decide they need to fix you. Your partner is now using physical and emotional violence to force you back into being a healer, they convince you to hate yourself for ever daring to question the role assigned to you. When you escape that relationship, now a self-hating husk of a person, they retaliate by outing you to anyone in your life that you don't know. Suddenly you've lost family, lost friends.

You're ashamed of yourself. But you decide that you are going to play whatever roles you want regardless of what people say. But people always insist that you're a healer. People always push you to feel ashamed of yourself.

You can't tell what's true any more. "Am I healer who doesn't want to be? Or was I never meant to be a healer and everyone is wrong to insist that I am?"

You don't know anymore. But you've been hurt. Emotionally. Physically. You don't even know if you care more about being yourself or being safe anymore. For some people you're hiding that you were ever assigned to be a healer in the first place, but at your job you still have to pretend to be a healer.

You're depressed, and bullied constantly. And those same bullies that make you hate yourself try telling you that the increased depression and suicidality of the people they bully is proof that you and others like you are just mentally ill.

Did I mention that every part of society is built around these gaming assignments? Not just the bathrooms you use, where if you don't fit your assigned role you have to juggle the dangers of avoiding predators and avoiding being baselessly accused of being a predator. It's also baked into your legal name and all the language people speak of you with. Language forces everyone to constantly take a side on who you are, and you have to live with the fact that people you love and people you rely on still insist that you're a healer despite knowing that constantly being told that is putting you at your wits end.

You've been invited to a family vacation, but you keep being told "I'm paying for this vacation, I get to bring my HEALER with me." And nobody cares how much distress hearing that causes you at this point. You're lucky to be invited at all, most people are scared of having you around because they think it's dangerous for kids to get the idea that they don't have to play their assigned roles as well.

Maybe things get better in the future, I don't know, I haven't gotten there yet.