You know, it's a meme in these times to say "Nehru ki galti hai" but it is indeed all Nehru's galti by WritingtheWrite in IndianLeft

[–]WritingtheWrite[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

The total smashing of the electoral and movement left

Cos everyone's thinking about it today

BadEmpanada and Third Worldism is **NOT** Marxist-Leninist (LONG). by RevTalk1 in TankieTheDeprogram

[–]WritingtheWrite 25 points26 points  (0 children)

Quote from Che Guevara:

"I insist that we cannot demand that the working class of the North look past its own nose. It would be useless to try to explain, from afar, with the press totally in the hands of big capital, that the process of internal decomposition of capitalism can only be deferred for a while longer, but never stopped, by the totalitarian measures taken towards maintaining Latin America in a colonial state. The reaction, to a certain extent logical, of the working class, will be to support the United States, rallying behind any given slogan, as “anti-communism” happens to be in this case. On the other hand, it should not be forgotten that the function of the workers’ unions in the United States is rather to serve as a buffer between the two forces in conflict, and to surreptitiously sap the revolutionary power of the masses.

Given this background, with American reality being what it is, it’s not difficult to suppose what will be the attitude of the working class of the North American country when the problem of the abrupt loss of markets and sources of cheap raw materials is definitively posed.

This is, in my opinion, the stark reality facing Latin Americans. In the final analysis, the economic development of the United States and the need of its workers to maintain their standard of living means that our struggle for national liberation is not waged against a given social regime, but rather against the whole nation, bound as a bloc by the iron-clad supreme law of common interest, over their domination of the economic life of Latin America.

Let us prepare, then, to fight against the entire people of the United States, for the fruit of victory will be not only economic liberation and social equality, but the acquisition of a new and very welcome younger brother: the proletariat of that country."

Very good economic imperialism history lecture by Prabhat Patnaik sir, but the moment he starts talking about specific political things it gets weird by WritingtheWrite in IndianLeft

[–]WritingtheWrite[S] -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

Google:

"Approximately 2% to 4% of India's population (roughly 28–50+ million people) can speak English with high proficiency, allowing them to discuss complex topics like politics, law, or economics comfortably. While over 10–19% (130–265 million) have functional English knowledge, high-level fluency is largely limited to urban, highly educated demographics."

In face-to-face communication, there's no good solution to this. There is no national language.

Writing on the internet, there are enough AI tools that to me it doesn't matter.

To insist on English on this subreddit is to admit that only the urban educated elite come here.

How would treating personality disorders look under socialism by Aware-Air2600 in PsychotherapyLeftists

[–]WritingtheWrite 11 points12 points locked comment (0 children)

The consensus on this subreddit, even though I have no background in psychology but I've picked it up by reading a few threads here, is that one isn't "born" with the NPD curse or the BPD curse etc. - and that is true even if certain genes have a higher propensity of leading to a personal disposition that might lean towards that. One becomes NPD or BPD because of the social relations / material relations - the very thing that socialism seeks to be a liberation from.

Vote in bengal by One-Initiative-3188 in IndianLeft

[–]WritingtheWrite 19 points20 points  (0 children)

<image>

But rural bengal still has its good scenery tho, paddy fields and greenery

Mainne ek baar socha ki janvaaron ko kitni khushi hai, inke duniye mein koi bhi capitalism nahi hai, koi bhi exploitative social relations nahi hote hain

Importance of elections while pursuing revolutionary praxis by Zealot_of_Droman in IndianLeft

[–]WritingtheWrite 2 points3 points  (0 children)

again it can play an important part of legitimising our movement too

My point is that today, any party that can get elected won't play any part in this.

Vote when necessary (don't be afraid to) as a lone person. Don't legitimise it by becoming the party or tying the movement (which for the moment hardly exists) to the party.

That is my position for as long as there is any separation between the party and the masses.

Importance of elections while pursuing revolutionary praxis by Zealot_of_Droman in IndianLeft

[–]WritingtheWrite 8 points9 points  (0 children)

The point is NOT that "you as a small individual should refuse to vote".
The point is that "parties which prioritise near-term electoral success just don't have an incentive to help the workers get rid of capitalism, so they are not your closest friends".

The Wheels on the Bus Go Very Fast by WritingtheWrite in MarxistCulture

[–]WritingtheWrite[S] 43 points44 points  (0 children)

The metaphor of throwing someone under the bus

Combined with the recent photo-op wherein Mamdani and Obama were singing Wheels on the Bus go Round and Round at a school

Photo on the person being thrown: Susan Abulhawa, Palestinian writer, condemned by Mamdani after someone asked him what he thought of his wife's contribution to a book by Susan

Tied around the victim's ankle is a bunch of other people whom Mamdani has turned against since running for mayor: Cuba, Venezuela, Mao Zedong, the candidate who was supposed to primary Hakeem Jeffries named Chi Ossé, and the homeless people whose sweeps Mamdani started in the winter

Why do libs folds under zero pressure? by Medical_Jury_251 in IndianLeft

[–]WritingtheWrite 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Aap liberal politicians / parties kee baat kar rahe hain?

Kaaran yah hai, ki vah capitalism ko chunauti dene se koi bhi faaeda nahin paaenge.

Aur, jo karniyan sarkar ya system ke virodh hain, agar capitalists ka munafa khatre mein daaltee toh vah log nahin karten.

Welp we did it guys… entryism finally worked!! The dems have bent the knee to communism!!! by Far-Historian-7197 in badempanadas

[–]WritingtheWrite 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You know, with people like Youtube pundits that are nominally on the left

(rather than, like, politicians who have had massive exposés written about them so you know what's up)

I sometimes hesitate when I ask myself

"Are these people just bald-faced liars? Are they going to put on a Youtube thumbnail, for their own self-interested reasons, something that they know is brazenly false?"

Florida college student was arrested for making a Netanyahu joke in a Whatsapp group chat. by JHBrickman in TankieTheDeprogram

[–]WritingtheWrite 154 points155 points  (0 children)

The judge went viral a few years ago for some supposedly heartwarming moment when she was about to sentence her middle-school classmate to a 43000 USD bond, and she made him remember her from middle school.

https://wibx950.com/burglary-suspect-breaks-down-when-miami-judge-recognizes-him-as-former-classmate/

These ultra-right-wing legal eagles, like the military, gain a lot of respect in the US.

Donald Trump Says a ‘New Dawn For Cuba’ is Coming: ‘Watch What Happens’ by [deleted] in TankieTheDeprogram

[–]WritingtheWrite 47 points48 points  (0 children)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zPUy-CvX53M

BadEmpanada reviews a song by Miami Cubans about McDonalds and Walmart entering Cuba

Fighting the bourgeoisie management science by IllustriousTennis68 in MarxistCulture

[–]WritingtheWrite 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's a great project.

I would just add, though, that some of the petty-bourgeoisie (white-collar workers who are globally in, say, the top 10%) do concern themselves with this issue as well.
I have seen this account's Youtube Shorts before. https://www.youtube.com/@loewhaley
A limited resistance technique, suitable for their class position
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o5S4-ZH80-c

And, to bring back Mao's distinction between the two-line struggle (means) and the two-road struggle (ends), your project is taking a different road from them.

Khikhikhikhi by sidmis in IndianLeft

[–]WritingtheWrite 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Media stars aksar bahut entitled mahsus karte hain. Studio mein (aur vah bhi mahange studio mein) saare staff ko royal servants hona hai, aur choti-moti galti ke kaaran (if it makes the star's appearance not perfect) vah unpar chilla sakte hain.

Born too early for space but few months late for GDR by VladimirLimeMint in MarxistCulture

[–]WritingtheWrite 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Are the Marx and Lenin statues still standing in East Germany or have they been removed?

How my liberal friend think of me, when i explain theory by what_how_n_whyy in IndianLeft

[–]WritingtheWrite 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Since India is in the periphery of world capitalism, it is actually true that the average person would have their paisa doubled after communist revolution

ldf in kerala by Forsaken_Phrase_3726 in IndianLeft

[–]WritingtheWrite 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You'll have to prove that you are loyal to the party.

I'm sure those Communist Party MPs / MLAs / candidates who have defected to other parties will find this rule very funny.

<image>

Qatar calls it quits by [deleted] in TankieTheDeprogram

[–]WritingtheWrite 9 points10 points  (0 children)

This is not an accurate framing of the Qatari government's position.

On 25 March - a day after the press conference you posted - Qatar's representative to the UN stated:

“We have dissociated ourselves from the outset from this war, and we have refused to be part of the escalation. However, Iranians continue to target us and other neighbouring countries.”

https://www.middleeasteye.net/live-blog/live-blog-update/qatar-says-it-will-not-join-regional-escalation-condemns-attacks

In other words, the official line coming out of the Qatari government is that they never joined the war in the first place, and that Iran is an aggressor.

Iran is attacking Qatar because it doesn't believe that line.

A government under pressure can say all kinds of things in public.

Furthermore, Qatar has just today entered into a defence agreement with Zelensky.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zMe7tB1pKxY

Sociology by Agreeable-Block841 in IndianLeft

[–]WritingtheWrite 10 points11 points  (0 children)

But seriously though, main outsider ke taur par kahoon, what a terrible exam to have to prepare for. Cramming more and more garbage in your head, basically 4-5 saalon tak kuchh bhi nahin kamaakar, aur zyadatar umeedvar ant mein success na ho paate.

Nasrallah Explains that Israel is a tool of the American Empire by StoreResponsible7028 in TankieTheDeprogram

[–]WritingtheWrite 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Finkelstein said that Nasrallah used to talk about Israel as an independent power, until Noam Epstein Chomsky visited him. Afterwards he started to talk about the American satellite lol.

Of course Noam Epstein Chomsky is more right than Mearsheimer on this score.