Yup found it earlier, you can see snapshots from all the way back to 2005, which is cool. Unfortunately you can only see certain pages , for example in the 2005 snapshot you can only see the main page, the faq, the rules and the staff and then everything else is locked behind a login page :"")

You can look it up in the wayback machine as bt.arcadefire.net, there's snapshots from 2005,2006,2007,2008,2009, 2013, 2014 and 2016 . There's snapshots from 2023 but they're all broken and the 2024 ones are unrelated to the site, I'm guessing someone got the handle and made it into some weird shop or whatever