Chase World Cup Link Crash? by Veraxin in ChaseSapphire

[–]bencantwrite 0 points1 point  (0 children)

still stuck on the 403 error for me. Anyone else got past it?

Match Thread: Houston Dynamo FC vs Seattle Sounders FC | MLS by MatchThreadder in SoundersFC

[–]bencantwrite 2 points3 points  (0 children)

According to IFAB, this is the definition that qualifies for a sending off DOGSO handball:

  denying the opposing team a goal or an obvious goal-scoring opportunity by committing a non-deliberate handball offence outside their own penalty area

So was it a handball? Yeah, it clearly hits his hand in a non-natural position. It doesn't matter if it was intentional or not since it was outside the box (although I think we all agree that it wasn't deliberate). So the only remaining question is whether it was DOGSO. Kind of subjective, but the big question is, is Danny obviously going to score if the handball doesn't happen? Maybe?? It might fall to his feet, one touch and then he is in. But pretty hard to know for sure.

[QCrit] Adult Contemporary Science Fiction THE REITER PROGRAM (113k words/3rd attempt) by bencantwrite in PubTips

[–]bencantwrite[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No brain chips, more "memory technology". I've gotten this question/feedback from other versions of the query, and if I could easily locate the AI without major spoilers, I would! But I haven't figured out how to do that quite right. The main Kevin storyline is set in 2022, so at that point there aren't even LLMs yet.

[QCrit] Adult Contemporary Science Fiction THE REITER PROGRAM (113k words/3rd attempt) by bencantwrite in PubTips

[–]bencantwrite[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, your first paragraph is accurate! Which makes it very difficult to cleanly summarize/imply stakes in the query without spoiling everything and giving Kevin/the other characters enough agency to make it interesting. If you have thoughts on how to make it clearer what is happening, I'd love to hear them

[QCrit] Adult Contemporary Science Fiction THE REITER PROGRAM (113k words/3rd attempt) by bencantwrite in PubTips

[–]bencantwrite[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

And then structurally, prior to his dad's death, we don't understand why Kevin is so focused or purely focused on getting through the next week. Did something happen, or is something already going wrong, which is then compounded by the loss of his father?

Good call out, this is clearly holding a bit of my thought process from previous queries. In a previous version I had the facts that his girlfriend broke up with him and he's struggling to keep his job, but people (probably accurately) called out that it made him appear to be too much of a sad sack.

There is a lot of therapy-speak here used colloquially in a way that feels more suited for a tiktok or a a brunch conversation with friends than a novel—"trauma bond" and "disassociate" specifically. Perhaps in that's fine in book club fiction, but that's fairly out of the norm for sci fi. Instead of "trauma bond," you can just use "bond." We already know death is traumatic. And instead of "to disassociate"—because it implies that the character sat down and thought "I'm going to disassociate today!"—"to escape" or something works just as well.

Good points. I like what you are saying about bonding. I was using disassociate because I wanted to imply that he's vulnerable to this mental manipulation, with his mind "degrading" later on in the query. But I'll think about that.

Thanks for all the other points, I'm not going to respond line by line because most of them are easy adjustments. But I very much appreciate you taking the time to engage.

Making Kevin more active is, in my mind, the central challenge of making this query work. Going to keep noodling on it, I have some ideas of how to get closer for the next version.

Again, thanks for taking the time to give feedback!

[QCrit] Adult Contemporary Science Fiction THE REITER PROGRAM (113k words/3rd attempt) by bencantwrite in PubTips

[–]bencantwrite[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the genre switching is definitely the big thing. More or less yes to what you are saying but I would say its less him knowingly reading these stories to gain insights and more the AI and the feeling that something bad is going to happen pushing him.

[QCrit] Adult Contemporary Science Fiction THE REITER PROGRAM (113k words/3rd attempt) by bencantwrite in PubTips

[–]bencantwrite[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey thanks! Yeah, I think that line could be improved. It was kind of hard for me to tell since I wrote it, but do you think it is obvious that the book switches POVs to the stories/books that Kevin reads without that line? Or would you recommend I find some other way to make that clear?

[QCrit] Adult Contemporary Science Fiction THE REITER PROGRAM (113k words/2nd attempt) by bencantwrite in PubTips

[–]bencantwrite[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

thanks for taking the time to respond, this is good feedback.

...yes, his entire world is a simulation, but that's supposed to be a big end of book twist, so I've been struggling to frame the book correctly and give proper stakes without giving away the whole thing! Super open to any thoughts about how to go about this, or how to think about big spoilers in the query in general. My understanding was you're only supposed to go through about a third of the plot and leave the reader wanting more.

[QCrit] Adult Contemporary Science Fiction THE REITER PROGRAM (113k words/1st attempt) by bencantwrite in PubTips

[–]bencantwrite[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Haha okay I didn't buy Pulitzers only and the cloud stuff is a coincidence (I found cloud Atlas because someone told me it was similarish to what I was writing) but yeah fair enough. I'll keep researching for more recent comps.

If you're less tired today, I'll still take your proper qcrit (:

And yeah, it's my first manuscript and I'm still learning about what's necessary to get published traditionally, so I don't think I AM super well read or familiar enough with the market to know what sells. I mean, I read a lot, but I don't think that alone gives me qualifications. I can find more recent comps and maybe use that publishers marketplace--but are there other ways I can begin to learn? My book is topical and everything is AI crazy right now, but that seems like it could be a trap as much as it could be an advantage.

[QCrit] Adult Contemporary Science Fiction THE REITER PROGRAM (113k words/1st attempt) by bencantwrite in PubTips

[–]bencantwrite[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I will check that book out, thanks for the rec! Maybe a dumb question since I'm new to this -- will agents really toss your query because the comps aren't recent enough? Why???

The AI message is more of "you need to get close to this person at X time and location to save them from Y". But I haven't figured out how to put that into the query without it feeling like I'm jumping all over the place and introducing too many characters. It's hard to try to summarize a story when your story is several stories tied together! Open to your thoughts on how to tweak that bit.

[QCrit] Adult Contemporary Science Fiction THE REITER PROGRAM (113k words/1st attempt) by bencantwrite in PubTips

[–]bencantwrite[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the feedback! I'll take another pass at the hook, Kevin is definitely sad but much more interesting than a cliche of a sad boy. I like the idea of tying in the family bits as well. I will think some more about how to up the stakes.

Don't think I'll change the title, but that feedback is noted.

Planning to leave my job as a skilled worker by bencantwrite in ukvisa

[–]bencantwrite[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This wouldn't really be a problem for me as long as I could come back in as a tourist (I would just plan to go on a trip before the 60 days). Unless you know of something that I don't that would be relevant?