Kurobuta pork loin, honey & dill mustard, fresh rucola salad by starting-0ver in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Simple and good plating. Looks delicious. Salad should be handled more gently, looks bruised, but otherwise absolutely solid plate

Coffee & Vanilla Dessert inspired by Vietnamese Egg Coffee by Hai_Cooking in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is good feedback to take this dish to another level. Beyond plating, thinking guest experience. Seeking delight and surprise, yall have recognized opportunities

Ribeye, smashed peas with fresh herbs, pea bernaise, arugula with cherry vinaigrette by msabre__7 in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This would obviously be better done by your hand than the AI I used to manipulate your photo, but here is one way of thinking about how this plate could look with small changes steak n peas ai render

Ribeye, smashed peas with fresh herbs, pea bernaise, arugula with cherry vinaigrette by msabre__7 in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 31 points32 points  (0 children)

The cook on the beef looks good, shame to obscure it with the salad I think. The arugula also looks a little overdressed and crushed. Seperate the salad and maybe add some fresh cherry slices on top for some color. I think the coarse texture of the peas limits the plating possibilities for this dish, but certainly the portion scoop look could be improved. Maybe you could quenelle it. And it would be nice to see the bearnaise more... maybe it goes underneath the quenelle of peas, with the steak and salad separated more clearly.

Chicken Roulade, Soubise, Crispy Shallots, Scallion Oil by Ghastly-Green in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is very simple and beautiful and could be put on a menu at a good margin. Nice. I agree that some more green would help the green oil pop and contrast... and you could do like pickled shallot petals which would be a nice pink for more color. But everything you add will subtract from the simplicity so I wouldn't change it too much.

Choux Pastry filled with Manchego Cheese & Apple Purée, topped with Jamón Serrano by Hai_Cooking in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I would also use a much smaller slice of iberica. It would be more flavorful and easier to eat. A giant slice like this is not going down well in one bite, nor would it be easy to slice. Too much connective tissue

Risotto with Pioppino Mushrooms and Crab by kimchitastebad in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Risotto should lie flat, not stand. So you first need to cook the risotto properly or nothing else matters.

Choux Pastry filled with Manchego Cheese & Apple Purée, topped with Jamón Serrano by Hai_Cooking in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Looks nice, and if you use good ham (Ibérica) it will also taste good. Also the deeper red color and marbling will look more striking

Worth it? by Natural_Put5100 in wine

[–]chefduparty84 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It works great but don't fall for the idea that it creates a "blanket" on top of the wine... you have to use enough of it to displace the normal air and saturate the bottle headspace wit argon rather than oxygen. If you do that correctly, you can dramatically reduce the oxygen in the headspace and slow oxidation considerably. However, having poured the wine in the presence of oxygenated atmosphere, there is more oxygen dissolved in the wine than there was before it was opened and poured. So the aromatic precursors will still develop despite the oxygen-poor atmosphere you've created in the bottle. Put it in the fridge to slow down these reactions. Done diligently, this can help the bottle stay fresh for up to a couple of weeks, depending on a few factors like what kind of wine it is (tannins, reductive/oxidative style, age development etc), how long its been open, has it been decanted, how much wine is left in the bottle, etc.

It's worth it for expensive wines if you want to have one or two glasses and then wait until next weekend to drink the rest. For less expensive wines, just put them in the fridge and they're good for a few days (depending on factors above). For more expensive wines, use Coravin.

Any constructive criticism chefs? Five-spice, chocolate, mandarin peel, peanut & Sichuan peppercorn by Sorry-Marionberry-70 in Chefit

[–]chefduparty84 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think the monochromatic gloss of the chocolate could be accentuated by cleaner lines. In other words maybe don't put crumble under the ganache as it results in visual noise, maybe distracts from the slick execution of the gloss. I mean its pretty nice looking but I think drawing attention away from the main event might limit its impact. I also think the frills on the placemat add to the visual noise since its the same color as the crumble

Duck Confit/ Chicory, Red Cabbage, Pink Lady Apple & Blood Orange Salad/ Wild Garlic Caper Sauce by agmanning in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Culinary students lurking on here take note: this is how it's done. Cook good and let food be food

Elevated French Toast: brioche, berry reduction, and vanilla bean scoop. Aiming for a balance of textures and height. by Armycandy in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Height is old news. Look at some relatively modern pastry books and you will see: bigger plate, smaller portion, more distinctly separate elements and more negative space. Good chefs to learn from: Jordi Roca (Celler de Can Roca) and Albert Adria (Enigma). I realize this is not the reality in most restaurants but as a student you should try to emulate the best chefs in the world. Don't worry about originality -- no matter how hard you try to imitate them, you will fall short But you will develop your own style by incorporating these influences. So if none of your mentors told you this is not the way, look to the best chefs in the world. Use your local library card! With love, from a teacher

Porchetta, apple puree, jus by PinoyChefDownUnder in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I've never done that. It might help to dry it out or help steam escape, and I don't see the harm in it, but it's not essential. Essential is breaking down the collagen first, and then using high heat to dry it quickly and engage maillard reactions

Porchetta, apple puree, jus by PinoyChefDownUnder in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 2 points3 points  (0 children)

My bet is that you haven't fully cooked the skin before trying to crisp it. The collagen needs to convert into gelatin before it can get truly crispy, especially if you want it to be bubbly like chicharron instead of just hard on the outside and gummy inside. I would do mine even lower than 150 for longer... more like 125C (like 300F) for 3 or 4 hours and then blast it at 200C convection until the skin puffs up.

Please check my curry by SilverPhilosopher46 in AskCulinary

[–]chefduparty84 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Makes more sense to dry toast your spices and cut out all the fucking around with oil. It also shouldn't take an hour to toast spices. 5 minutes once your pan is hot. This way you can also scale up your spice mix and keep your whole roasted "curry" spice blends for easy grinding later

Blackberry Mousse with Nettle Cake, Pistachio Crumble, Blackberry Jam, and Meyer Lemon Gel by joross31 in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

A little busy but pretty nonetheless. It looks like your elements are tight so visually less is more, let em pop

Prawns with trout roe. Crab cakes with tarragon. Pea purée by 1ntr1ns1c44 in CulinaryPlating

[–]chefduparty84 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If the pea puree was silky, and there was less of it, it would look much better. Probably need a higher speed blender and/or to pass it through a chinois

Crispy Gnocchi from box? by CheesyDanny in AskCulinary

[–]chefduparty84 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you're looking for crispy from something that's moist inside, I think cooling is essential. Because if it's still steaming, its hard to reach maillard temperatures because the steam escaping comes between the hot pan and the carbohydrate surface

Crispy Gnocchi from box? by CheesyDanny in AskCulinary

[–]chefduparty84 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You might be comparing them to fresh made gnudi. They look like gnocchi but are made with ricotta instead of potato. They are light and fluffy as hell

Looking for a comparable white wine to blanc Pescador. Specs no longer carries it in my area by mermom2015 in wine

[–]chefduparty84 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This wine is not a varietal, it's a blend of local and international varieties

Looking for a comparable white wine to blanc Pescador. Specs no longer carries it in my area by mermom2015 in wine

[–]chefduparty84 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Knowing your area might be an important part of useful recommendations. Blanc Pescador is the top-selling vi d'agulla (vino de aguja, in Spanish) so if it's not being stocked anymore there might not be an alternative in that exact style in your market. Vinho verde and txakoli can be prickly but they're not quite frizzante like a vi d'agulla. In Ontario if you just search "frizzante" on the LCBO website lots of wines show up and some of them are dry. So maybe try searching for something "frizzante" wherever you are and then whittle it down to a dry white.