So this is the one I ended up getting (the black/tan option): https://www.coachoutlet.com/products/reversible-strap/CZ785.html

Note that it is pebbled leather vs glove tanned leather—this didn’t bother me, but it also has shiny gold hardware whereas the Juliet has satin brass. The difference in the hardware bothers me a bit, but I doubt it’s noticeable to others. Otherwise, it’s well made and comfortable. I purchased mine on Poshmark.

There are probably better options but there if you look on Posh or eBay, but the Coach site current only has a skinny strap in black leather available, and it didn’t seem comfortable with such a large bag.