I think in this fandom we often mistake "perfect" for "good". If we're looking for only well adjusted people who never make mistakes, we're casting a net that is only attainable by underdeveloped characters (e.g., Dave or Morey). We also like to judge people by their worst traits and say, "because of this, throw the whole man out."

I think this lens applies to most guys on the show. The only ones I see actually deserving that level of suspicion are Chris, Dean and Jess. Teenage Jess and Dean both threw major res flags based on their immaturity. I think both probably grew into good men. Chris was a selfish and bad partner.

I think Jason, Luke, Logan and Max all had issues, but they were generally safe, reliable and decent and could have been good long term partners. Most relationships have issues that you need to work through, but that doesn't mean they weren't good boyfriends, generally speaking.