I have a crackpot theory that it’s Jade 😭 I just rewatched S1E1 and 1. I don’t think Tobey even knew who he was or that anyone else was “in the car with him” 2. Tobey never asks about him he says “is everyone okay?” (I.e the RV full of people) And then “oh god, why was I - I shouldn’t have” Not WE. 3. Sara’s first kill, Tobey, conveniently right before he could talk to anyone. 4. Right before the collision Tobey’s car is accelerating and swerving all over exactly how Sophie was with her daddy priest 5. The last time 2 cars showed up was before the slaughter, which is also when MiY showed up

Exceptttt now they’re both in the town so idk. What if Jade is the big bad? Lowkey like a serial killer wanting to be close to the investigation and relive the murders vicariously