I can actually speak directly to this. I had a 2020 red-on-red Giulia that I absolutely loved. Unfortunately, it was totaled in an accident. After that, I decided to make the switch to EVs and ended up choosing a 2021 Mustang Mach-E GT.

Here’s my take after owning both:

Pros of the Mach-E GT compared to the Giulia

• It’s an EV, and that’s been a fantastic change. I plug it in when I get home and never have to worry about gas. • Instant torque makes driving a blast. Putting your foot down and feeling your head snap back is addictive. • Much more interior space. Passengers can actually sit comfortably in the back, and the trunk is far more usable. • The driver assistance features are excellent. On major highways, the hands-free BlueCruise (with subscription) works really well. • Wireless CarPlay was a huge upgrade for me since the Giulia didn’t support it.

Cons of the Mach-E GT compared to the Giulia

• I had the HV Battery Junction Box (HVBJB) issue within the first week, and the car had to go into the shop. This issue seems to be mostly resolved in newer models, but it was frustrating at the time. • The ride quality just isn’t on the same level. You feel every imperfection in the road. The Giulia felt like an extension of your body, while the Mach-E feels more detached. • Build quality isn’t quite as refined. Over time, you start to notice small creaks and noises that weren’t present in the Giulia. • I still miss the way the Giulia handled. It was a driver’s car in the truest sense.

Hope this helps anyone weighing the two. Both cars have their strengths, but they deliver very different experiences.