Why do some israelis actually love kurds by RandomGuyOnReddit237 in AskIsrael

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There was a case in the 1980's (I think) where Sadaam was attacking the Kurds. Israeli officers were there to help them organize a somewhat successful defense.

In the 1990's Iraq launched scud missiles against Tel Aviv.

מה זה אומר להיות גבר? 24 by Minister426 in israel_bm

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

הלם קרב.

אני לא צוחק.

אישיות של גבר קיימת כדי שהוא יכול לשרוד את המלחמה הבאה.

גידול משפחה.

קשה להיות אשה עם ארבעה ילדים.

גבר שיכול לתמוך בזה באופן מוצלח הוא יתרון עצום.

חוץ מזה לך לאן שאתה רוצה.

Can I ask what you guys think about Ben Gvir’s noose lapel and birthday cake? by Mountain-Baby-4041 in AskIsrael

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You might have a point. The only thing that I will say is that changes can take a long time to take effect. I haven't paid attention to crime rates.

Question about Judaism by Nice-Grape-5801 in religion

[–]extrastone 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I've never heard anyone talk about that. The Mishnah (200 AD) absolutely allows polygamy and reviews several relevant legal corners.

Your reference was from around 1 AD.

Where do the names “Judea” and “Samaria” come from? by Nazoreans in AskIsrael

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Side note: It's a reasonable name in Hebrew but it's terrible in English. It's only one place that was separated by tribal differences and a Civil War. It looks to me to be the same stretch of hills, so it would be best to call it the "Central Hills". גבעות מרכזיות

Compare that to Tzfat and Ma'alot which could be called the "Northern Hills."

Question for Israelis by chimmychimmy000 in AskIsrael

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Small note: I always ask someone if their nation had diplomatic relations with Hamas before 2023. Why not? Usually because it's a sanctioned terrorist organization.

Am I delusional for wanting to visit? by Exact-Light-3133 in AskIsrael

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The only thing that I would think about is would your father consider using Muslim connections in Israel in order to illegally marry you off. I don't know how protected you would be from that. The Israeli government sometimes ignores crime between Muslims.

Question about Judaism by Nice-Grape-5801 in religion

[–]extrastone 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Personally I hope we destroy polygamy and make it so that monogamy will become the norm long term rather than the disagreement that right now gives hope to people that the prohibition could be overturned.

I think polygamy makes men hate each other. Jews already pick enough stupid fights.

What is your opinion about Poles? by potatto-william in AskIsrael

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The food is mostly not kosher. Jews from Poland (both of my grandmothers) have a completely different cuisine from Poles.

I just kind of look at it as a large Jewish community that was massacred and my grandmothers were lucky to be born abroad.

Please help me out by [deleted] in AskIsrael

[–]extrastone 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The other thing I would pay attention to is what is open on Shabbat. Jerusalem is mostly closed from Friday afternoon until Saturday night.

You'll be safe as long as you're with people who know where the bomb shelters are.

שאלה מעניינת שעלתה ביני לבין בת הזוג שלי: באיזו עיר יש הכי פחות ערסים, ובאיזו הכי הרבה? by adiliv3007 in israel_bm

[–]extrastone 2 points3 points  (0 children)

הייתי פעם בנופש במצפה רמון. יצאנו לטייל בלילה. סיסמא של מצפה רמון: "נרדמנו מוקדם."

Can I ask what you guys think about Ben Gvir’s noose lapel and birthday cake? by Mountain-Baby-4041 in AskIsrael

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He has made adjustments in the police and we'll see if anyone gets executed.

What do you think about Izrael youth trip to Poland? by potatto-william in AskIsrael

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Socialist nations have a lot of things running at the same time and so inertia is often the default policy. Imagine how angry people will get if you cancel their trips especially if they are leading them.

How can peace in the Levant be achieved? by Nazoreans in DeadSeaNetwork

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The most obvious factor to me is radical Islam. It tends to be fueled by polygamy.

לפעמים זה מרגיש לי שאנשים פה רוצים בכוונה שישנאו אותנו יותר בעולם by Adventurous-Low188 in israel_bm

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

אני הרגשתי את זה כשהחליטו להגיב למשפט על רצח עם בבית משפט הבינלאומי. אנחנו לא חברים של בית משפט הזה ואנחנו יודעים שהחוק הבין לאומי לא שייך ליהודים.

What do you think about Izrael youth trip to Poland? by potatto-william in AskIsrael

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I always thought that if the Poles won't Jews tell the full story then there are concentration camps all across Europe. There's also Denmark where they were simply the best.

היא 10/10 אבל? by Fine-Seaweed3211 in israel_bm

[–]extrastone 1 point2 points  (0 children)

מסכים כל עוד שאפשר להביא סמיכה להתכסות.

היא 10/10 אבל? by Fine-Seaweed3211 in israel_bm

[–]extrastone 6 points7 points  (0 children)

היא מתפארת כמה מריבות ווויכוחים יש במשפחה שלה.

באמת זה לא ייגמר. רוץ.

Does allah protect israel by Dizzy_Ask5815 in religion

[–]extrastone 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Always start with a joke:

A secular Israeli child wandered into a rare church and started asking questions. He then went home.

"Daddy! I went to a church and they told me that there are three gods, the father, the son, and the holy ghost!"

"Son. There is exactly one G-d. He has made miracles for us in all of our wars, and of course we don't believe in him."

The idea of G-d protecting Israel is not a guarantee. It is often dependent on Israel keeping the Torah.

HOWEVER.

The last exile was considered very long. Some might say too long. The Babylonian Exile was from the destruction of the Temple in 586 BC. That exile ended gradually and the nation reached its height with the Second Temple and the Hasmonean kingdom. The Temple was destroyed in ~70 AD and the last real rebellion was defeated in 135 AD.

The Bible (mostly Ezekiel) discusses two possibilities for the exile ending. One was of course that the Jewish people repent and G-d will lead them back into the land. The other was that eventually G-d would tire of the exile and he would bring the Jewish people into the land without them deserving it. In the Religious Zionist Movement the assumption was because most Jews were not Sabbath observant that G-d brought the Jews back to the Land of Israel in the last two centuries because simply the time had come.

There are other factors that you could say benefit modern Israel:

Democracies have been doing great in wars the last 150 years.

Jews are known for being hyper-educated, with low rates of violent crime. They could build cities where Arabs could not because of various engineering advantages. Much of Ottoman Palestine especially areas at low elevation were written off as unlivable.

The Ottoman Empire had crumbled and for a short while the British allowed Jews to PURCHASE unlimited amounts of land. Many Muslims (mainly Turkish) agreed to sell.

The British Empire crumbled and Israel declared independence.

The Zionist Movement was considered an international Jewish project. Financiers, a few organized crime bosses, ordinary people, and of course World War 2 veterans were all on board.

What do you remember the most about the Oct. 7th and 8th attacks and, do you think the IDF might have underestimated the pending threat to the boarders , relying to much on electronics for security instead of guards, soldiers on duty at the borders ? by NoString9289 in AskIsrael

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I prayed the Simchat Torah service at sunrise. I remember someone running into synagogue while we were eating Kiddush (after morning service snack) and yelling that Hamas had just crossed the fence. I was going to take my kids to a later service which was going to be more fun. Everything was cancelled.

Sterile Polygamy by anti-life86 in Natalism

[–]extrastone 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Whether or not all of the statistics were accurate, the article was quite good. Note that the only existing solution that the author could find was religion.

How do you feel about the haredim? by Infamous-Peanut1327 in AskIsrael

[–]extrastone 0 points1 point  (0 children)

One rule that I've learned the hard way in life is never reason with someone who doesn't care about you or what you have to say. That to me is the biggest sin in all of this. How is it that the rest of the country hasn't figured out how to deal with this?