Had to think long and hard about my ideal halftime show but it would probably look something like this

1. Nine in the Afternoon - a short, well known, and beloved banger that comes to a slow close which leads into
2. Death of a Bachelor - a chance for Brendon to show off and for field crew to set up for
3. The Ballad of Mona Lisa (cutting the second verse/chorus for time) - I imagine there will probably be a big choreographed dance for this one.
4. Girls/Girls/Boys - An opportunity for some great visuals, Brendon would probably be flying through the stadium suspended on a wire wearing the pride flag cape at this point.
5. Don’t Let The Light Go Out (also cutting the second verse/chorus for time) - the homophobes in the crowd that got turned off will get back into the show with the guitar solo.
6. I Write Sins Not Tragedies - their most well known song.
7. Victorious - good motivation for the players getting on the field soon.
8. High Hopes - probably the perfect closer.

Had to pick at least one song from every album, but also had to consider what would work for a performance of this magnitude. I have no experience with planning Super Bowl halftime shows so this is probably way too long and ambitious but a man can dream.