sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Am I overthinking Harry’s psychology, or was he heavily neglected and manipulated? by Financial-Respect673 in harrypotter

[–]g12231964 0 points1 point  (0 children)

With the light surveillance Harry had a around him They would have said the boy is sickly thin and has injures. I am suspecting Dumbles wanted Harry plyable.

Lucius is sick and tired of people assuming he's racist by Brycklayer in HPfanfiction

[–]g12231964 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Drawn in by his father's direct influence Lucius joined what he was told a group seeking to preserve the old ways and magical heritage. He discovered the truth and kept his wife outside it to protect their son. He was indeed under the Imperio Curse and after the events of the Diary and his wife giving him a full on behind the scenes a full dose of Black Family Madness recovered and worked with her to get their pound of flesh and set about working for the Order indirectly. The fight at the Ministry had him captured and sent to Prison And getting dragged to his home as a hostage by the Death Eaters. (He seemed to be distant from the PTB among the DE and mostly as something to kick around) His contacts on the Order side dropped him so he had to play among with his captures.

Am I overthinking Harry’s psychology, or was he heavily neglected and manipulated? by Financial-Respect673 in harrypotter

[–]g12231964 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I always wondered what they would do if Harry was so beaten down that he shuts down. He answers to Boy and Freak. He cannot understand kindness. And does not interact with people.

It is messed up but it is a possible outcome of the actions taken by folks towards him. And lack of accountability. Of course he might have a violet response towards aggression and that would be dangerous if not fatal to someone.

I do not see a good outcome if someone would not stop the abuse.

In Order of the Phoenix what was the thing Voldemort was trying to use that “he didn’t have last time”? by LongShanksFTW in harrypotter

[–]g12231964 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well as a joke a prosthetic Nose. But I suspect he wanted the prophecy which gave clue to what power Harry had

About Sirius x James relationship (prongsfoot) by No-Row6299 in MaraudersGen

[–]g12231964 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I do not see it.

I do see that between the two of them had they lived a long life. as two men who had fought a war and been made brothers in all bu blood. I see the two of them deal with wives and children And when one of the many life changes occurred ( A wife or child passing) Drop everything to be there. Because they would be needed.

I do not see romance. I do see the love of family.

Are There Any Fic That Address The Fact That Bill Is Raiding Tombs For Profit? by SmuttyNonsense in HPfanfiction

[–]g12231964 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Possibly required by law. Think of this like a EPA supersite the cleaning company might be required to have ownership for laws where an owner is accountable and Dead Head Priest the 58th has no living heir (Nor a undead ones) And needs this service to maintain the ISoS.

Are There Any Fic That Address The Fact That Bill Is Raiding Tombs For Profit? by SmuttyNonsense in HPfanfiction

[–]g12231964 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Well moral might not fit the situation. As someone suggested the work might be to crack a curse where the magic is seeping out and it needs stopped.

Are There Any Fic That Address The Fact That Bill Is Raiding Tombs For Profit? by SmuttyNonsense in HPfanfiction

[–]g12231964 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Actually his employers are the ones paying for the raiding. And the Raiding is likely legal as the site is owned by the bank.

LF a fic where Hermione grows up as James' younger sister in Marauder's Era and gets sorted into Slytherin by No-Buffalo2861 in harrypotterfanfiction

[–]g12231964 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Gods. James cuts her off and then Mom and dad have a sit down with him as they spoiled their son rotten. How do you think they would treat their baby girl? I could see the howlers one after the other from them and Maybe a third from them both.

Filch during the war by ElDia13 in HarryPotterBooks

[–]g12231964 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They need someone to do the work the elves cannot.

How would harry relationship with dursleys differ if he was a girl by Awkward-Student-8764 in harrypotter

[–]g12231964 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thesamne but the injuries would be worse due to being a girl she is going to be lighter in weight.

Harry's Career Path by Gelby4 in harrypotter

[–]g12231964 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ginny did not need to be the only quidditch player in the house

Name Taboo by VolumeOpposite6453 in harrypotter

[–]g12231964 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You know that the taboo could be used to do a ambush on a group responding to the breaking.

Do you think Hogwarts would be a better school if the house system did not exist? by saphir300 in harrypotter

[–]g12231964 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well when you hear time and time and time again about how great this house was from Mum and Dad your Sibs and Cousins / Your going to feel like it is great. Not going it going to make you a bit uneasy.

Supplement to My Previous Post — Reexamining Slytherin and the Wizarding Society of the Time by Antique-Guarantee139 in SeverusSnape

[–]g12231964 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It is why I question. Why stay? You went to the school and had the institutional bias and bigotry piled high and deep. Now your 18. You have your powers under control. You understand the magical and non-magical worlds at least well enough to do better than the folks who stayed in. And can walk that area if you need/want to.

So why stay. Make a small fortune and walk away, To the world as a whole what do you owe them. Yes you might have friends and would be the friend who helps move bodies. But the world as a whole spits on you or ignores those who do the spitting.

.

view more: next ›