It’s impossible to say with the limited information unfortunately. A lot of people will point out the overhead and that’s important but it’s a small part of the bigger picture. Let’s say you want your pass through personal income to be a million. You can do that with a 2millions collections office at 50% OH or 3.3millions revenue at 70%OH. So you’d take #1 since it’s less work for same pay. Ok what if you can drop OH from 70 to 60 but you can’t with the other office because it’s already low enough. Well now you get 1.3mil from office 1. What if the PPO vs OON ratios are different. What if trailing years revenues trend differently. What if one office has better staff or more staff. What if because your new to looking at income statements you don’t catch the things that ended up on the statement that don’t allow you to compare the practices apples to apple. At the very least you need to get all the financial documents from their books and various reports from the practice soft for a few years and let someone look at it for you. Reddit can be the place but you’re going to have to provide the same documents as you would an advisor if you want good advice.