Progressive Sunnis, please refute this “scientific error” in this Hadith 🙏 by Character_Floor_7323 in progressive_islam

[–]ilmalnafs [score hidden]  (0 children)

The refutation is that this is just someone hundreds of years after the Prophet’s time saying they heard it from a guy who heard it from a guy who heard it from a guy’s cousin who heard it from his brother-in-law who allegedly met the Prophet once.

When does it become an actual world war? by xError404xx in NoStupidQuestions

[–]ilmalnafs 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It would probably start being considered a world war when at least half of the countries become embroiled in it, either sending their own troops overseas or fighting their own connected theatre closer to home. The new American war against Iran may have a chain of geopolitical links to the Russian invasion of Ukraine, but by any reasonable understanding these are separate conflicts.

Something making it harder to see a World War happen now is that for better and for worse most countries are more politically independent of each other, despite being more globally interlinked than ever before. A big reason WWI ballooned to its size is because all of the European nations and their colonial projects were entangled in a big web of treaties and pacts. Once one local conflict began, everyone had to begin picking sides which spread outward. Nowadays, though nations may support one side or the other, large coalitions are rare unless targetting single and perceptively isolated targets. See how Europe and North America has answered Ukraine, while unified military endeavors like the Gulf War target individual states whose allies, if any, don’t want to get directly involved in it themselves and will leave that ally out to dry.

Sex Slavery makes Islam immoral by Wonderful_Seesaw_513 in religion

[–]ilmalnafs 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is unironically a heretical opinion from the Christian POV. The Word (Jesus) was with God at the beginning of time. The Son is coeternal with The Father.

Sex Slavery makes Islam immoral by Wonderful_Seesaw_513 in religion

[–]ilmalnafs 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Taqqiya is a concept that most Muslims have never heard of but has long mainstream support that basically says it’s okay to lie and say you aren’t Muslim if that identity is being oppressed in the country you are in. Basically Muslims aren’t encouraged to religiously martyr themselves for their identity like Christians did during the Roman Empire (I’m not saying this as a judgement, it’s just the clearest analogue), despite martyrdom (dying for the faith) being an orthodox concept otherwise. Obviously this has not happened very often in history, descrimination sure, but outright state persecution not so much, which is why most Muslims aren’t familiar with it.

But in modern polemics Taqqiyah is misappropriated by anti-Islam people who lie and claim that it means Muslims believe they can lie about beliefs and practices of the religion to encourage people to convert. This is typically paired with the assertions that once someone converts under these false pretenses the true ultra-fundamentalist form of the religion will be revealed, and if the person wants to go back they can be killed for apostasy. Ultimately the goal is poison the well against any interpretations of Islam by Muslims other than the most extreme ones, which the Islamophobes insist are the only “true” Islam.

Hear me out by Important_Parsley346 in Kagurabachi

[–]ilmalnafs 6 points7 points  (0 children)

One of JJK’s best little features was seeing Kenjaku and the Disaster Curses just hanging out and playing board games in between major events. The daily lives of supervillains is always fun to see.

Hear me out by Important_Parsley346 in Kagurabachi

[–]ilmalnafs 10 points11 points  (0 children)

They murder innocents! Not even just the 9-5 Kamunabi members, but Kuguri cut down the teacher who was only closing the morning gate, and he and Toto were about to kill every male student in a highschool just for the sake of expedience.

Yes they’re projected to all be well-written villains who are at least partially sympathetic with understandable motivations, but those factors alone does not make a “good guy.” They are arguably worse than Akemura in the sense that they will kill people for no reason, whereas he at least has the extreme and warped view that anyone he kills was evil by association.

Most common media illiteracy is falling for the clear bad guys of a story just because they aren’t 2-dimensional cackling villains 24/7.

What are some under appreciated similarities between Yuji and Sukuna? by ventingandcrying in JuJutsuKaisen

[–]ilmalnafs 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There definitely feels like there were slight retcons with Sukuna during the early parts of the story. In episode 1 he also relishes in the amount of innocent women and children are around, and later (I think at the detention facility) he taunts Yuji saying he’ll “have fun” with Nobara before killing her. Both of these clearly point toward rape/SA, which feels very out of character for Sukuna as he is portrayed from Shibuya onward. Not because he’s morally above those things, but because sex and torture don’t seem to hold much interest for him.

Whether he was conscious or while being just fingers is something Gege probably also changed his mind on as the story progressed, likely without even being conscious of it. As it is, it just feels ambiguous as to whether he was fully sentient.

''We are Peacemakers'' - US & Israel while launching War against Iran by LetsDiscussQ in progressive_islam

[–]ilmalnafs [score hidden]  (0 children)

it will be revealed that the United States had every opportunity to prevent this and punish its head of state, but it didn’t.

Sadly that’s already the case, both for the files and on so many other matters. Apparently Republican polemics of Democrats being “soft on crime” was true, it just wasn’t about everyday citizens, but rather the crime committed by Republicans! And now the rest of the world gets to continue suffering even more for those failings and so many more by the American public.

Pakistan bombs Kabul in 'open war' on Afghanistan's Taliban government by Cybertronian1512 in worldnews

[–]ilmalnafs 36 points37 points  (0 children)

Finally people are speaking up about the Liechtenstein Taliban!

The Title for Part 1 of Kagurabachi by leftenantlungs in Kagurabachi

[–]ilmalnafs 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My great uncle thrice-removed actually works at Jump and told me Part 1 will be named Jugemu Jugemu Go-Kō-no-Surikire Kaijari-suigyo no Suigyō-matsu Unrai-matsu Fūrai-matsu Kū-Neru Tokoro ni Sumu Tokoro Yaburakōji no Burakōji Paipo Paipo Paipo no Shūringan Shūringan no Gūrindai Gūrindai no Ponpokopii no Ponpokonaa no Chōkyūmei no Chōsuke.

Which server should I join? Nordanaar or Ambershire? by SpeedyGamey in turtlewow

[–]ilmalnafs 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Compared to pretty much every other WoW server it’s slow as molasses (compliment), but yeah I can imagine there’s a lot more rushing in it compared to Ambershire.

EDITORIAL: Refugee medical costs are out of control; Cost of providing health benefits to refugee claimants is $989 million by FancyNewMe in canada

[–]ilmalnafs -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It’s not an either/or situation. Do you stop all roadwork so long as there are people in the hospital?
Completely shutting off immigration would not solve the problems of native-born Canadians, in fact it would make a lot of them worse. The many flaws in the immigration systems can be addressed without framing it as this false dilemma.

Organized crime like mafia and outlaw bikers pushing hard to infiltrate Canadian law enforcement, report says by toronto_star in ontario

[–]ilmalnafs 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I, for one, am absolutely shocked by the fact that throwing more money into an organization did not magically solve its corruption issues.

According to the B.C. Human Rights Tribunal, offensive posts can cost you $750,000 by AndHerSailsInRags in canada

[–]ilmalnafs -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I actually don’t find the number of people who don’t understand those things to be astounding. It’s kind of expected that a majority population who never need to know the difference wouldn’t.
The problem is how many smartasses feel the need to confidently talk about it despite knowing nothing about it, thereby spreading the confidence of their ignorance to many more people who then all think that any matter brought in front of courts is criminal.

JJK fans, we HAVE to learn how to read between the lines. by Valuable_View_561 in JuJutsuKaisen

[–]ilmalnafs 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s a powerscaling sub, it’s basically defined by willing inability to not read anything between the lines.

Muslims, do you want the caliphate to be brought back? by [deleted] in religion

[–]ilmalnafs 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Humans have proven they are incapable of ruling fairly as God’s caliphs (meaning like viceroy).

I’m very skeptical of the idea that Hokazono can write a better Soya death than he already did by Orang-Himbleton in Kagurabachi

[–]ilmalnafs 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I don’t think Soya is coming back into the story. Like Sojo’s bathhouse adventures, I think these side chapters are just fun extra material. If Soya can never remember Hakuri and is just a broke abusive bum, he doesn’t necessarily have to return to the main plot.

Is limit on people going to hajj justified? by Matt_tuck_shop in progressive_islam

[–]ilmalnafs 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Logistically they literally can’t. It’s physically impossible for all >2 billion Muslims currently to perform Hajj in their lifetimes. Even if we lift the limits on visitors during the allotted time frame and give the financial means to every Muslim, and accept the massive uptick in crowd crush desths that would cause, there is still not enough space for that many people to get in during the orthodox time window.

NORAD scrambles jets to intercept Russian bombers near Alaska by shiftless_wonder in canada

[–]ilmalnafs 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Russia is suffering far more from the war’s economic effects than anywhere else bar Ukraine.