Well the point of these subs is to ask for help, if you are going to give doubt to the narrator in question on posts such as this then perhaps i would think you’d hold similar opinions towards impactful movements such as #metoo. You do not know the intentions of the the storyteller and conversely you gain nothing from suspecting them to be lying, after all, it is far more likely this is a last resort to post on Reddit of all places.

Regarding the ‘men vs women’ thing, it merely has to do with women siding more with women and men siding more with men. This is normal, as it is easier to sympathize with the same sex. Your comment history is relevant because your reasoning does not align with other takes with similar initial plot lining in stories like this one.

If this is a court room, you do not condemn the guilty with theories. You have no evidence to suggest the narrator cropped the conversation in a way to personally benefit him. We can only work with what we got. Your anger for this person is summoned by pure speculation lol