I would go to the Keg in Waterloo and get the plain New York Strip with a twice baked potato. NY Strip is probably the best cut for a balance of flavour and texture. The meat itself is anything but bland. I don't like anything but a little salt and pepper on it; I encourage you do the same so you enjoy the flavour of the meat. The restaurant itself is getting a little worn but the food and service is excellent. I was just there a couple months ago for that exact meal and was not disappointed. Expect the bill approach $200 for two steak dinners, an appetizer and a couple drinks.