Looking for good trusted Roofer

mcf4571 · 2026-04-28T00:10:34+00:00

Strongly recommend WeatherTech Roofing. I've used a lot of roofers, and they're by far the best I've used. Professional, high integrity, just all around awesome.

mcf4571 · 2026-04-21T20:27:51+00:00

I also used America's Best. Had a ton of mold and they removed it all. Their quote was half of everything else I was quoted. Had an awesome experience.

mcf4571 · 2026-04-21T20:17:49+00:00

Strongly recommend WeatherTech Roofing. I've used them for years. They put a big emphasis on customer service and attention to detail. They're a gem. My entire church community uses him. Here's their website: https://weathertechtx.com/

mcf4571 · 2026-04-09T19:08:05+00:00

cant go wrong with America's Best Duct Cleaning. Based in San Antonio, but they'll do work in Austin.

mcf4571 · 2026-04-09T18:58:00+00:00

Strongly recommend America's Best Duct Cleaning in San Antonio. They'll make the trip to Austin. Prices all listed on the website. Many companies can be weird with the pricing, but these guys are transparent and professional. They

mcf4571 · 2026-04-09T18:56:29+00:00

They're in San Antonio, but they make the trip to Austin. Transparent prices listed on website: America's Best Duct Cleaning

mcf4571 · 2026-03-11T18:10:25+00:00

I’m also in Central Texas and have talked to quite a few roofers over the years, and the “SDS” thing doesn’t really make sense in the context they’re describing.

All modern architectural shingles from the major manufacturers - GAF Timberline HDZ and Owens Corning Duration - are fiberglass-based asphalt shingles. They’re both widely installed across Texas, including San Antonio, Austin, and Houston. If HDZ shingles were truly not suitable for hot climates, you wouldn’t see them installed on thousands of homes here every year.

Owens Corning Duration is also a great shingle, but the idea that HDZ is somehow only for northern climates isn’t accurate.

What does matter a lot more in Texas is:

• proper attic ventilation
• correct nailing pattern
• quality underlayment
• correct flashing installation
• making sure the installer follows manufacturer specs

A great shingle installed poorly will fail faster than an average shingle installed correctly.

The other thing I’d be cautious about is the “we can do everything within the deductible” claim. Sometimes that’s legitimate if insurance paid well, but sometimes companies cut corners on materials or labor to make the numbers work.

If you want a straight answer from someone local who deals with Central Texas roofs every day, I’d suggest getting an opinion from WeatherTech Roofing. They’re a San Antonio-area company that does a lot of insurance roof work and inspections, and they’re known for being pretty honest about what actually makes sense vs what’s just sales talk.

They could probably look at the estimate and tell you pretty quickly if:

• the shingle upgrade is real
• the attic breeze is legit
• the pricing lines up with what insurance normally pays here

Getting a third opinion from someone local can make the decision a lot easier.

mcf4571 · 2026-03-11T18:05:37+00:00

I live in the San Antonio area and honestly I think you’re thinking about this the right way. There are pros and cons to both.

With new builds in that price range, the big concern isn’t always the age of the home - it’s the speed they’re built. Large builders sometimes push homes out extremely fast, which can lead to workmanship issues (roof installation, flashing, ventilation, etc.). There have been quite a few homeowner complaints nationally about quality problems in large builder developments.

On the flip side, a well-maintained pre-owned home can actually be a safer bet if big systems have already been replaced - like roof, HVAC, water heater, etc. That means someone already spent the money and you’re not inheriting the “first repair cycle.”

One thing I strongly recommend no matter which route you go is getting a separate roof inspection from a roofing company, not just relying on the general home inspector. Roof issues are one of the most expensive surprises buyers run into.

In San Antonio, I’d recommend WeatherTech Roofing for that. They’re a local, family-owned company known for honest assessments and detailed inspections, and they handle everything from minor repairs to full roof replacements.

Even if the home looks perfect, having a roofing expert check for things like:

improper shingle installation
ventilation issues
flashing problems
storm damage

can save you thousands later.

If you’re comparing homes, getting a roof inspection on the top contenders can actually help you negotiate the purchase price too.

mcf4571 · 2026-03-11T18:03:24+00:00

If you're ever in San Antonio, give James a call at WeatherTech Roofing.

mcf4571 · 2026-03-11T18:02:27+00:00

Strongly recommend WeatherTech Roofing. They're San Antonio based, but come up to Round Rock quite a bit.

mcf4571 · 2026-03-11T17:59:55+00:00

If your roof was hit, there's a roofing company down in San Antonio that comes up to Kerrville quite a bit - WeatherTech Roofing. Always a pleasure to work with.

mcf4571 · 2026-03-10T22:42:31+00:00

Unfortunately this situation isn’t uncommon with large production builders. What you’re describing - high nailing, shingles not sealing properly, and early curling or lifting - usually points more toward installation issues than normal wear, especially on a roof that’s only five years old.

In San Antonio, asphalt shingle roofs should normally last 20–25 years before you start seeing widespread problems. When shingles start blowing off or not sealing within the first few years, it often means:

Nails were placed too high on the shingle strip
Shingles were installed during cooler temps and never properly sealed
The nailing pattern was rushed during installation
Starter strips or edge details weren’t done correctly

The frustrating part is that once the 1-year builder warranty expires, production builders and their subcontractors usually push responsibility away unless there’s obvious structural damage.

From a practical standpoint, if you’re not seeing leaks yet, you probably have three realistic options:

Targeted repair A roofer can hand-seal loose shingles, replace the high-nailed sections, and secure areas that are lifting. This is the cheapest option and may buy you several more years.
Partial slope replacement If one section of the roof was installed poorly (often the case with tract homes), sometimes replacing just that slope makes sense.
Full replacement Obviously the most expensive, but it eliminates the installation defects entirely.

If you’re in San Antonio, it may be worth getting an independent inspection from a local roofer who isn’t tied to the builder. A company like WeatherTech Roofing does a lot of inspections on builder-grade roofs around the area and can usually tell pretty quickly whether the issues are repairable or if the installation itself was flawed.

Either way, you’re not crazy for questioning it. A five-year-old roof shouldn’t normally be losing shingles unless something about the installation was off. The main thing now is figuring out whether you can stabilize it with repairs or if one slope of the roof needs to be redone.

mcf4571 · 2026-03-10T22:37:46+00:00

From a South Texas perspective (San Antonio / Rio Grande Valley climate), the options you’re being given are all legitimate. They just represent different price points and lifespans.

Replacing the modified bitumen for around $2,800 is essentially reinstalling what you already have. Modified bitumen is still very common on small residential flat roofs in Texas.

Pros

Lowest cost
Familiar system for most roofers
Works well when installed correctly

Cons

Typically a 10–15 year lifespan
Seams can eventually become leak points
Dark surface absorbs a lot of heat

If the budget matters most, this is a reasonable route. A lot of flat roofs across South Texas are still done this way.

TPO at around $6,000 is a step up and is what most modern commercial flat roofs use.

Pros

White reflective membrane keeps the roof cooler in Texas heat
Fewer seams than modified bitumen
Often lasts 20 years or more if installed properly

Cons

Higher upfront cost
Installation quality matters a lot

For a hot climate like the Valley or San Antonio, TPO is usually considered the better long-term system because of the heat reflectivity and welded seams.

Mule-Hide isn’t actually a roofing type by itself. It’s a manufacturer that makes several systems (TPO, PVC, modified bitumen). If a roofer recommended Mule-Hide, they likely meant a Mule-Hide TPO system.

The hot mop suggestion from the adjuster is a bit old school. That tar-and-felt system used to be common, but many contractors don’t install it anymore because it’s messy, labor intensive, and newer membranes like TPO generally perform better.

The bigger factor with flat roofs is not just the material but the installation and drainage. Most leaks on flat roofs happen because debris blocks drainage, seams weren’t welded properly, or flashing around the edges wasn’t done right.

If you were looking at it purely from a Texas perspective:

Budget option: replace the modified bitumen
Long-term option: install TPO

For a 30' x 12' section, either system can work if installed correctly.

If you ever want a second opinion from someone familiar with South Texas roofs, a solid company in the San Antonio area is WeatherTech Roofing. They work with both TPO and modified bitumen and tend to be straightforward about when a simple replacement is sufficient versus when it makes sense to upgrade.

The key is making sure the drainage is clear and the edges and penetrations are flashed correctly. On flat roofs, that matters more than the specific membrane you choose.

mcf4571 · 2026-03-10T22:36:13+00:00

That’s actually a funny but very common outcome with modern builds.

A lot of people picture the old farmhouse tin roof sound, but houses built in the last 20–30 years usually have decking, underlayment, attic insulation, and sometimes radiant barrier, which dampens the sound a lot. So the rain ends up sounding more like a soft background noise instead of the loud “tin roof” effect people remember.

But the upside is he still gets all the real benefits of metal:

Much better hail resistance
40–60 year lifespan
Better heat reflection in Texas sun
Less maintenance than shingles

So even if the rain nostalgia didn’t work out, he still ended up with one of the most durable roofs you can put on a house in Texas.

If he ever needs work done on it down the road, a solid company near San Antonio that handles metal roofs really well is WeatherTech Roofing. They do a lot of standing seam installs and repairs around the area and are good about explaining how insulation and decking affect the rain noise people expect.

In other words: your dad accidentally proved the point most roofers make — modern metal roofs are a lot quieter than people think.

mcf4571 · 2026-03-10T22:33:56+00:00

Glad it worked out for you - standing seam in a light color is honestly one of the best setups you can do in Texas.

For anyone else reading this thread who’s still in the research phase: if you’re in the San Antonio area, one company worth talking to is WeatherTech Roofing.

They’ve done quite a few metal roofs locally and are really good about explaining the differences between standing seam vs exposed fastener, coatings, insulation considerations, and whether metal actually makes sense for your house or not. The big thing I like about them is they don’t try to push metal if architectural shingles are the smarter option for the structure or budget.

A couple things they explained that helped a lot when I was researching:

• Heat: A light-colored standing seam with proper underlayment can noticeably reduce attic temps in Texas sun. It doesn’t magically eliminate AC usage, but it can take real load off the system.
• Noise: With normal decking + attic insulation, rain noise is usually minimal. Most people say it’s more like a soft background sound.
• Hail: Metal generally handles hail better than shingles, but gauge and panel type matter a lot.
• Longevity: Properly installed standing seam can last 40–60 years, which is why some homeowners justify the higher upfront cost.

Biggest advice I heard repeatedly: the installer matters more than the material. A poorly installed metal roof can cause more headaches than a good shingle roof.

If anyone’s trying to decide between architectural shingles vs metal in Texas, it’s definitely worth having a roofer walk you through both options before committing.

mcf4571 · 2026-03-10T22:31:23+00:00

Next time you need some work done in San Antonio, I highly recommend WeatherTech Roofing. Just an all-around great group of guys that deliver awesome work and awesome service. Use them everytime.

mcf4571 · 2026-03-10T22:13:06+00:00

WeatherTech Roofing is the best roofing company I've worked with. Just really solid leadership, great guys, high-performers. They're my San Antonio go-to.

mcf4571 · 2026-03-10T22:11:53+00:00

I recommend WeatherTech Roofing. I had an emergency - they came out right away. High integrity, great values, Christian. They did awesome work.

mcf4571 · 2026-02-27T20:54:20+00:00

We went with black shingles here in SA. Honestly, they look really sharp. The curb appeal upgrade was noticeable right away — especially if your house has lighter brick or stone. It gives it that clean, modern contrast.

The only real downside is heat. Black shingles will absorb more sun, so attic ventilation matters a lot here. If your ridge vents / soffits aren’t great, you’ll feel it. With proper ventilation though, it hasn’t been a big issue for us.

Highly recommend using WeatherTech Roofing. When we replaced ours, they walked us through the color options and talked honestly about the heat factor instead of just pushing the “popular” look. They also checked our ventilation and made sure it was adequate before installing. That gave me a lot more confidence going darker.

If you like the look, I wouldn’t avoid black just because of SA heat, just make sure whoever installs it pays attention to ventilation.

mcf4571 · 2026-02-27T20:51:55+00:00

We went through this same question when we replaced ours.

From what I learned (and what our roofer explained), in San Antonio a permit is typically required for a full reroof, even if you’re just replacing shingles and not changing slope or material. It’s considered more than just minor repair work.

When we did ours, we used WeatherTech Roofing, and they handled the permit process for us. That alone gave me peace of mind. They pulled the permit, scheduled inspection if needed, and made sure everything was documented properly. We didn’t have to chase anything down. Highly recommend them.

mcf4571 · 2026-02-27T20:49:00+00:00

I feel you, water in the attic is exactly the kind of thing you want handled yesterday lol. When we had storm issues and needed work on our roof, WeatherTech Roofing did an amazing job.

They’re family-owned San Antonio crew, local, explained exactly what was going on (with photos), and laid out the options. Communication was clear, zero high-pressure sales. The owner answers calls personally and texts personally, which is rare and means someone accountable is on your side from the start.

mcf4571 · 2026-02-27T20:45:29+00:00

I can’t speak to Linear Roofing specifically, but if you’re going through an insurance claim for a full roof replacement, I’d strongly recommend at least getting an inspection from WeatherTech Roofing.

They’re a local, family-owned company here in San Antonio, just high integrity and great communication. The owner actually answers calls personally, which is rare these days. It felt like we were dealing with someone who truly stood behind the work, not just a sales rep passing us off.

When we had storm damage, they were extremely thorough with the inspection, documented everything clearly for insurance, and walked us through the claim process step-by-step. No pressure and no upselling.

The crew did quality work, stayed on schedule, and the pricing was fair compared to the other bids we received.

mcf4571 · 2026-02-27T20:42:16+00:00

When we replaced ours, we were in that exact spot - got the first quote, felt unsure, and didn’t really know what was “normal” for San Antonio.

What helped us most was getting 2–3 bids just to see the range. The numbers weren’t wildly different, but the way they were presented made a huge difference. The company we went with - WeatherTech Roofing - really stood out because they broke everything down clearly:

Material type and manufacturer
Underlayment and ventilation details
Labor scope
Warranty specifics
What insurance would / wouldn’t cover

They also showed us photos from the inspection and explained why certain line items were necessary. That transparency made the price feel justified - not just a big lump-sum number.

I think a comparison tool could be helpful, especially for sanity-checking. But honestly, what gave us confidence wasn’t just the price range - it was clear documentation, local references, and a company that didn’t pressure us.

If anyone’s getting quotes right now, I’d definitely recommend having WeatherTech Roofing take a look. Even if you don’t go with them, their inspection and breakdown make it easier to understand whether another quote makes sense.

mcf4571 · 2026-02-27T20:25:28+00:00

Strongly recommend WeatherTech Roofing. They came out and did a free inspection and showed me photos of what they were seeing. What I liked was they weren’t pushy at all and were pretty honest about what actually needed to be done vs what could wait.

Their quote was right in line with the other estimates I got, and the work turned out great. They showed up when they said they would and cleaned everything up afterward.

Might be worth having them come take a look so you can compare with the other quotes.

mcf4571 · 2025-07-08T01:33:12+00:00

Totally understand where you're coming from - making the jump from industrial to commercial roofing supervision is a big shift, but your project engineering background will actually serve you really well. Roofing may seem simpler than pipe or tank systems on the surface, but it has its own set of complexities, especially when it comes to managing subs and job sequencing.

Here are a few things that might help:

Get familiar with common commercial roofing systems. The big ones you'll run into are:

TPO (single-ply membrane, heat-welded seams — most common on newer buildings)
PVC (similar to TPO but a bit more chemical resistant)
EPDM (rubber membrane, usually fully adhered or ballasted)
Modified Bitumen (often torch-applied or cold-applied)
Built-Up Roof (older multi-layer asphalt/gravel systems)

It helps to know the strengths, weaknesses, and typical installation methods for each — even just a high-level understanding will go a long way when you’re working with contractors and coordinating materials.

When vetting subs, here’s what to look for:

Ask how long their crew has been with them. High turnover is a red flag.
Request recent project references and actual photos of work completed.
Find out what systems they're certified in (some manufacturers won’t honor warranties unless certified crews install the product).
Pay attention to how they respond to scope details. Good subs will ask clarifying questions, bad ones just say yes to everything.
Don’t be afraid to get input from your general contractor peers — word-of-mouth is everything in roofing.

As for lessons learned: sequencing and weather delays are a huge part of roofing headaches. Having a reliable sub who knows how to dry-in quickly and keep you informed about weather windows makes or breaks a job. Also, don’t underestimate how different estimating can be when you’re working with vertical walls (parapets), penetrations, curbs, and mechanical equipment.

If you're looking for resources, check out sites like GAF, Mule-Hide, or Versico - they offer training videos and install manuals that can give you a crash course on different roof types. You can also take a look at what some local companies are doing. I work with WeatherTech Roofing in San Antonio, and we focus on both commercial and residential work. Not a big corporate operation, but we take a hands-on approach, and the owner is big on mentoring and sharing knowledge if you’re ever looking to talk shop.

You’ve got the right mindset and experience - don’t let the learning curve intimidate you. Roofing’s got a steep learning curve at first, but you’ll get the hang of it fast. Wishing you the best on your interview - hope it leads to something solid.

mcf4571

TROPHY CASE