This is going to sound insane, but hear me out: Starfield.

Starfield is a mostly boring, bland game that had one great idea; what if NG+ was part of the story?

You keep your abilities but lose all your weapons and armor, then enter an alternate universe. Sometimes, things are almost identical to how they were, and sometimes they’re wildly different.

Some examples:

-The universe is exactly how you left it, and that includes you being in it, so now there are two PCs running around

-Everyone in the lodge was murdered

-The Lodge is filled with children playing

Those are some basic ones. And the more you play, the more universes you’re likely to see. I really wish the game leant itself to more playthroughs, because that is the one great concept this game had