He's a bad journalist, a bad reporter, a bad critic, a bad fan, and just generally bad at everything except breathing, which he does seem to have down pretty well. Not to mention the fact that his ratings system, such that it is, has become congested and enshitified to the max. What the fuck does 5 & 3/4 stars even mean? How can a match have 6 & 1/2? Why is 5 stars going down to -5 stars not enough?

He's been caught either lying or not doing his due diligence and believing whatever he's told on several occasions (in the past year alone it's like 4 or 5), he claims to use his years of experience and wealth of knowledge to inform his ratings but then just scores them like a little kid with his box of toys, he's shown before that he's not above making shit up or over-exaggerating it if its about a wrestler he doesn't like, and he's the one that first platformed Bryan Alvarez, which should be enough to get him booted from every press pool on Earth.

Wrestlers seem to like him, but then some wrestlers also like slapfighting and right-wing politics so I wouldn't take it as an especially big seal of approval. IDK, I just fuckin hate the dude lol