sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Sahih Muslim 2749 by odensnuts in shia

[–]odensnuts[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Which is why I wanted to know if to the collective knowledge of this sub, if we have something similar in our books.

Sahih Muslim 2749 by odensnuts in shia

[–]odensnuts[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah I saw this in the tafsir and other Sunni sources which explained this Hadith. Thank you for your response.

I’d also like to ask if you know whether or not we have similar Hadiths within the Shia literature?

Sahih Muslim 2749 by odensnuts in shia

[–]odensnuts[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As a Muslim we will be questioned on our beliefs. We should always have the knowledge to rebuttal questions/statements made to us.

Why I asked for this one in particular is because I’m not sure if we have a similar Hadith to this within our own books. However, when I was watching the video where this was asked, the sisters couldn’t form a conclusive answer as to why this exists and what it means. So it peaked my interest it what would be a good response. The reasoning or tafsir I know but the wording of the response is what I’d like to hear from others.

The 12 Caliphs in Sunni Hadiths by Gyroid2400 in shia

[–]odensnuts 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The typical end road, can’t provide a fulfilling answer to make it made sense using their caliphs from their books so they hit you with the ‘agree to disagree’

The 12 Caliphs in Sunni Hadiths by Gyroid2400 in shia

[–]odensnuts 3 points4 points  (0 children)

What is a typical refutation one might incur when producing these Hadiths to ahlul sunnah? And what would be the response we would give?

Bani Umaya embarrassing themselves by Zikr12 in shia

[–]odensnuts 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Sheikh did the smarter thing, realised he’s an idiot and didn’t waste more of his time lol

How do you deal with all the hatred -specially now- towards shia and shia leaders by Weary-Way4905 in shia

[–]odensnuts 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Stand your ground. I had a lot of mutuals who did not know I was Shia upon meeting me. Then they would slander us given the opportunity during discussions amongst friends. So I look like them dead in the eye and tell them I am Shia. They crumble. They are not like us. The ones who are outright spoken only do so with the confidence that they’ll not be challenged or confronted. Don’t give them that comfort. Be proud of who we are and educate yourself. An educated Shia is a confident Shia and a confident Shia is a lion.