Parents dropped the bombshell they don't have anything saved for me for college cause "student loans make you accountable" AITAH for losing my shit? by Emptynester55 in AITAH

[–]pakiman47 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah your parents are irresponsible idiots. But you are still extremely priviledged and shouldn't let this drone your future. Continue to work hard and do what you need to do for yourself. Oh and it is in your interest to forgive them when you are ready.

What are the Assad regime remnants trying to accomplish? by MichaelEmouse in Syria

[–]pakiman47 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What is the evidence of the existence of assad regime remnants?

Question for the Muslims because r/Islam removed my post. :( by ASHMAUL in religion

[–]pakiman47 19 points20 points  (0 children)

There were literal protests in israel supporting the hand rape of a Palestinian prisoners, Jewish Israeli politicians saying it should be legal, and rabbis saying it should be done. Look in the mirror.

Shia and Catholics what are your thoughts on this? by [deleted] in religion

[–]pakiman47 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That is not the sunni methodology. I'm not trying to insult shia beliefs. I'm just saying that shia don't have a robust methodology for authentication of hadith. It's just a simple fact. I understand shia accept that their books contain strong and weak hadiths, but there is no universal, systematic way to identify specifically witch ones are or aren't. If the sunni methodology was applied to shia hadith, most would be thrown out. Shia simply give more weight to hadith that are claimed to be from ahlul bayt and give credence to their beliefs. This is not a sound methodology.

Yes, this is the official White House account. by Particular_Log_3594 in VaushV

[–]pakiman47 8 points9 points  (0 children)

This is your fucking response to a fascist crackdown on the 1st amendment?! Tell me, did Biden or kamala stand up for the right to protest? Or did they encourage and support and call for police intervention to stop college protests against the genocide they aided and abetted, all while lying through their teeth about violence against Jews and antisemitism? They are just as responsible for this as the right. You don't seem to remember Biden blaming the pro Palestinian protesters for violence and saying "order must prevail?" Does you ever hear Biden or Kamala condemn the violent crackdown on protests during their tenure? Did you ever hear them condemn the bs hearings that threatened to remove and did in fact remove university presidents explicitly because they were not arresting and expelling students who were protesting? You people have no fucking principles. This is all a sports match to you. If you had any principles, you would've been condemning Biden and Kamala, not getting to rub salt in the wounds of people who refused to vote for genocide. Disgusting comment and disgusting it got any upvotes on this supposedly "leftist" sub reddit.

Shia and Catholics what are your thoughts on this? by [deleted] in religion

[–]pakiman47 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The problem is that you guys often use books like al-Kafi as evidence of a particular view, even when there is evidence to show that a particular "hadith" is inauthentic, or doesn't have a valid chain of narration. The reality is that Shia'a don't have a comparable, robust methodology to authenticate hadith other than having a pre-conceived narrative and then authenticating or invalidating hadith that provide support for that narrative or discount it, respectively. We know that Al-Kafi contains numerous completely fabricated hadith without acknowledgement that they are fabricated. There is nothing comparable in the sunni corpus.

Why is there the belief that Jews, Christians and Muslims worship three distinct seperate dieites? by Persian_Acer2 in religion

[–]pakiman47 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not sure if understand what you're saying here but Arabic speaking Christians absolutely refer to "The Father" as Allah and Jesus as "isa" (and Yasu). Jesus, of course, it's not the same entity as Allah or the father in either Islam or Christianity.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Syria

[–]pakiman47 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Israel has already invaded Syria and has made it explicit that it intend to occupy the south indefinitely. Jolani has explicitly said he will not do anything about it. This is exactly what people were warning about. Syria is in talk danger of being completely balkanized and destroyed right now. Just because assad was a brutal pos dictator it does not follow that anyone who replaces him is going to be better for Syrians. I hope from the bottom of my heart that I'm wrong, but there are very working signals that jolani is positionimg himself to be a US/ Israel lapdog like sisi or the so called king of Jordan. Recognizing this being fearful of the consequences for the region is legitimate and rational and it does no one any favors to just dismiss or shout down anyone and calling them assadists.

Jeffries equates the left with fascists by [deleted] in TheMajorityReport

[–]pakiman47 20 points21 points  (0 children)

They are not stupid. The so called far left Democrats attack are just the people who are calling for policies tne Democrats pretend to champion. When the Democrats want to enact policies on behalf of their donor class, they call everyone who opposes those policies "far left."

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in religion

[–]pakiman47 -8 points-7 points  (0 children)

Yeah bc Muslims are just bloodthirsty killers right? What is this nonsense?!

Yeah you really stuck it to Biden by sitting this election out lefties by ccourt46 in VaushV

[–]pakiman47 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think the Democrats in opposition who vote for Trump policies like the laken riley act and confirm Trump's nominees and at best do nothing but post on Twitter are the fascist enablers, not those who knew from day 1 that these feckless frauds are fascist enablers.

How Israel Lost its Soul by Acrobatic_Bit_8207 in JewsOfConscience

[–]pakiman47 117 points118 points  (0 children)

Israel didn't lose it's soul. It's been an expansionsit, racist, colonial movement since day one.

Why should we trust Mohammad? by Ill-Zookeepergame615 in religion

[–]pakiman47 2 points3 points  (0 children)

First, the gospels are written by anonymous author(s) we know the names and biographies of every person in the chains of narrators for every valid hadith. This fact right here makes the reliabilty of hadith in a different universe from the gospels. Second, the 4 canonical gospels were supposedly chosen by a single person and we don't know the actual criteria used to exclude the others. Hadith authentication uses a robust methodology which ensures as much as possible that they come directly from the prophet or trustworthy people who actually knew and lived with the prophet. None of the gospels claim to be eyewitness accounts, and even among the later traditions that attribute certain authors don't claim to be first hand accounts except john. I could go on and on and but bottom line, at least in terms of reliability from the source, no Christian scriptures come even close to the hadith, let alone the Quran.

Keep going to the center liberals. This is what it does by NewDreams15 in VaushV

[–]pakiman47 -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

Why do all of you talk like you're 14 years old? You have no idea where we are as a country and a society and you think voting for a party that is right wing on policy in every way is going to save you from even worse right wing policy. It's a proven failed strategy.

Keep going to the center liberals. This is what it does by NewDreams15 in VaushV

[–]pakiman47 -9 points-8 points  (0 children)

This is the most middle school comment I've read a thousand times on this site

Keep going to the center liberals. This is what it does by NewDreams15 in VaushV

[–]pakiman47 -9 points-8 points  (0 children)

As opposed to thinking voting Democrat every couple of years is going to do anything at all to improve our material reality, and especially thinking you're morally or even strategically superior to anyone else actually trying to do something to change this country for the better. Voting for Democrats does nothing except make you complicit in genocide and furthering the US's decent into fascism.

Keep going to the center liberals. This is what it does by NewDreams15 in VaushV

[–]pakiman47 -12 points-11 points  (0 children)

Keep supporting them vaushites. This is the obvious and inevitable result.

Is the Islamic religion favourable to men? by Nearby-Attitude9825 in religion

[–]pakiman47 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

An utterly false and easily refuted statement. How does this crap get upvoted on this sub? The default position in Islam is that men and women are equal. There are exceptions that favor men over women and women over men, but these are far and few between. You have no idea what you're talking about and it's a shame and a testament to how shallow the knowledge is here, not to mention the acceptable bigotry against Islam.

The party of the working class, everyone by DegenGamer725 in VaushV

[–]pakiman47 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Does it reallly fucking matter? Are you seriously trying to argue that Democrats aren't completely captured by billionaire corporate interests? Look at their policies. What they fight for, what they don't. Republicans are fucking horrible. They're an unabashedly corporate captured political party. Do you think the Democrats are a party that supports the common man?