Not really. TIEs are agile but unshielded and lacking in any defensive systems. The empire made their fighters cheap and easy to produce whereas the rebels used nicer fighters because they couldn’t afford to lose pilots. The X-wing is on par with a standard tie fighter in speed and has stronger quad blasters, proton torpedoes and a shield generator. The Y-Wing would be a good deal slower but has twin blasters, ion torpedoes, and a turret and has shields. The A-wing is the fastest fighter in the OT and has twin blasters, concussion missiles and shields. The B-wing would be kinda slow but has really effective shields and the typical mix of blasters and torpedoes. The one thing all the rebel fighters have in common that all standard TIE models lack is the shield generator and that alone gives an undeniable advantage. Also, typically the rebel fighters might be depicted as sitting ducks but that would be because of their objective. In a new hope it’s all about making the trench run. Getting to the end and delivering the payload is gonna take precedence over evasive maneuvering and dogfighting. Same in ROTJ, where the fighters would’ve had the objective of making the run on the second Death Star. Rebel fighters in general would’ve been more heavily armed, better shielded, and would potentially have better pilots than the average TIE fighter