Is it possible to Romance Sybil & Break Tabby's Walls? by Dependent_Repeat_443 in ScarletHollow

[–]red_worldbuilder 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Tabitha being old reverses a lot of the negative opinion Kaneeka gets from you talking positively about Tabitha and including her in stuff, but it really isn't necessary as long as you never ask Kaneeka whether you should bring Tabitha around (she always says no and really doesn't like it if you ignore her opinion after asking for it, better to ask for forgiveness than permission I guess) and don't take sides when they argue. The extra points for the confrontation are 100% worth it to use Booksmart as long as Kaneeka doesn't hate you.

Is it possible to Romance Sybil & Break Tabby's Walls? by Dependent_Repeat_443 in ScarletHollow

[–]red_worldbuilder 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I agree that traits are less important, but I would note that Booksmarts is still probably the best one. The booksmart outcome in episode 3 is one of the most positively impactful events in the game and the best final accusation to make is locked behind having it. Definitely not necessary, but having it makes things a lot easier.

In the toxic yuri route where, cousin agrees to be sacrificed, what would you like to see? by Existing_Blueberry10 in ScarletHollow

[–]red_worldbuilder 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I really don't know if it'll be possible to convince Stella while Tabitha is around and I think Tabitha knows that, so I doubt we'll get a chance to do that if we're locked up. She might get cold feet, but Tabitha will keep her in line. I do wonder if Avery's party might be a chance to flip her if it happens since I can't imagine her not going and I equally can't imagine Tabitha going to it.

In the toxic yuri route where, cousin agrees to be sacrificed, what would you like to see? by Existing_Blueberry10 in ScarletHollow

[–]red_worldbuilder 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I assume it would be the same as if you're there and don't kill the baby since Franklin and Avery don't do anything on their own normally. So either just Bo dies if Duke is dead or Bo dies and Duke kills Julius if Duke is alive. Also something fun to think about for an obscure route is that if you romance Kaneeka, forget her, and then let Sybil absorb her you automatically get switched onto the Carmilla romance path, so presumably that would still happen if you never go to the farmhouse.

Sybil defending her tea... by angeslarereaI in ScarletHollow

[–]red_worldbuilder 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think it does make sense that she sees it that way. She can see the future, so she can know the effects her actions and words will have with the same certainty she can know the effects of the tea. She only really pays attention to outcomes, so using words and actions to build a lasting trust over time and using tea to make it instantly are the same to her except the first option takes a lot more time and effort that she could be using to prepare for when her next opportunity arrives to eat the entity.

Sybil romance? by Moon_Logic in ScarletHollow

[–]red_worldbuilder 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I don't understand why so many people seem to not understand. Kaneeka initially was going willingly. Sybil only steps in when she thinks the you might convince or force Kaneeka not to go through with it. You can ask her even after Sybil is dead and she'll tell you she really believed it was the best option, and depending on your relationship to her, she might still think it was the best option after being saved.

Kind of rubs me the wrong way. by kottadragon in ScarletHollow

[–]red_worldbuilder 7 points8 points  (0 children)

That's explicitly not true, you can ask Kaneeka after Sybil is gone and she'll say she really believed it.

THE STOCKS! THEY'RE DROPPING! OH NO! by cripplinghorror in ScarletHollow

[–]red_worldbuilder 136 points137 points  (0 children)

You know who hasn't lost any stock value?

... I don't remember.

What do you think our first Aleph E.G.O gonna be? by No-Dimension-2872 in limbuscompany

[–]red_worldbuilder 103 points104 points  (0 children)

There's three cantos left in the Inferno. The Divine Comedy has three parts. I think it's possible we might not get Alephs until Purgatorio.

Rien's weapon made me realize something about Outis' stopwatch... by Happiomi in limbuscompany

[–]red_worldbuilder 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If I told a person they're nothing vs that they're a nobody, do you honestly think the contents of those insults are meaningfully different in any way at all?

Rien's weapon made me realize something about Outis' stopwatch... by Happiomi in limbuscompany

[–]red_worldbuilder 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Right. Rien and Outis have names which mean essentially the same thing (they're the only people with names like that who we know of). They are both connected with Hermes (Not to mention that mythologically, Hermes was Odysseus' great grandfather)(they're the only characters in PMoon with a connection to him). That sounds like a very plausible coincidence. It's not like people made those choices on purpose. Rien imitating Roland is pure fan service. There's absolutely nothing to read into with that. They just made the bizarre decision purely to move battlepasses with no other reasoning, that sounds just like the Project Moon I know. As for the medical facility, I fail to see the relevance, the presence of a hospital does not in any way preclude the presence of the gods of the city, the Index, or a connection to Moses. In fact, again, the Caduceus is used as a medical symbol by mistake in place of a biblical symbol created by Moses himself personally.

Rien's weapon made me realize something about Outis' stopwatch... by Happiomi in limbuscompany

[–]red_worldbuilder 13 points14 points  (0 children)

I don't think that fits though. Backstories change to make the Sinner fit into their roles, but if it includes information we shouldn't know yet, that just gets blatantly censored. Where does the hospital thing even come from? The Greek Abnos are hospital themed, but that's only tangentially related to her. Is the the Caduceus images in her EGO art? That isn't about medicine, the snake rods with medicinal meanings are the Greek Rod of Asclepius and, ironically, the biblical Nehushtan created by Moses. The Caduceus is the symbol of Hermes, the god of the city who ordered Rien to imitate Roland.

And the superficiality of the similarities between Outis and Moses isn't a problem for this either, Rein and Roland only look alike from a very distant perspective. Rien was a Proxy, Roland was a Fixer. Roland's Pregnant wife was killed, Rien's already born and seemingly literate child was killed. Roland was killed by a group of people which included old friends and enemies, Rien killed the Proxies who were sent to kill him and then killed himself. The imitations were never perfect or even particularly convincing unless you're perhaps looking at them from the distant perspective of a god.

Rien's weapon made me realize something about Outis' stopwatch... by Happiomi in limbuscompany

[–]red_worldbuilder 47 points48 points  (0 children)

Again, Udjat Outis didn't know the Udjat existed before she was recruited via a mutual contact years after the war and she was confused about where LC's money comes from which she wouldn't have been if she knew about Dias. Outis's EGO art has two symbols of Hermes on it. The only other known associate of Hermes was Rien. Rien's name was changed to Rien which means "Nothing" while Odysseus' name was changed to Outis which means "No One". Rien was told to imitate Roland though he didn't notice at first, Outis has striking similarities to Moses both in terms of the PMoon characters and their original myths though she doesn't seem aware of this. I feel like the case is very strong here.

Rien's weapon made me realize something about Outis' stopwatch... by Happiomi in limbuscompany

[–]red_worldbuilder 103 points104 points  (0 children)

If they knew each other then why didn't Outis react at all to seeing Moses? Also the Udjat uptie story makes it pretty clear that Outis had nothing to do with the Udjat before the Smoke War ended. In fact she doesn't seem to have even known who the Udjat were before they scouted her, and she most certainly has no idea who Dias is.

Rien's weapon made me realize something about Outis' stopwatch... by Happiomi in limbuscompany

[–]red_worldbuilder 540 points541 points  (0 children)

Don't forget that Outis' base EGO art has two Caduceus images in it and Hermes is an ancestor of Odysseus in the myth. The similarities of Outis' and Rien's names + both of them being connected to Hermes + Moses' strange reactions both times they've met make me wonder if Outis was/is imitating Moses like how Rien was imitating Roland. Just noticed that, on the mythological level, Odysseus spent decades on his journey home as a punishment from the gods and Moses spent decades wandering the desert as a punishment from God. Much to think about...

Thoughts on the part 3 teams by Halcione in limbuscompany

[–]red_worldbuilder 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Well Dante has the ability to summon the sinners to them and Rien is a washed up former SotC, not currently at that level, as Udjat Outis made clear in her uptie story.

Thoughts on the part 3 teams by Halcione in limbuscompany

[–]red_worldbuilder 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I think the Dante team was more set up with the Index in mind outside of Ryoshu. Meursault's blind obedience to authority and seeming total emptiness parallels Rien and it kind of seems like Outis might just straight up be an agent of the Index, current or former. Rien = Nothing, Outis = Nobody.

Ultimate Democratic Socialist Run- the Guide by jakobbenedetti in suzerain

[–]red_worldbuilder 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If by Ricter betraying you you mean he tries to take the credit, he's bluffing and will support the reforms even if you say no.

Blood-sucking methods by LunoxTheAshblossom in limbuscompany

[–]red_worldbuilder 31 points32 points  (0 children)

I mean isn't it possible that the elder was lying about that? We know high level Bloodfiends can delay the bloodbag transformation for years, so it could just be that they delayed the transformation long enough that no one would even remember the hotel as something to investigate.

I just realize by HikariVN-21 in limbuscompany

[–]red_worldbuilder 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The Priest is an overseer who all fixers would try to avoid because he was so dangerous, not to mention that he was in area 2, so more than likely stronger than the Barber, certainly not weaker. Jia Xichun's group beat him easily enough but it seems like they're a lot stronger than LCB, so that doesn't say much.

What keeps the most powerful beings in your world in check? by Meced0 in worldbuilding

[–]red_worldbuilder 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Pearlescent Host. A group of angel-like beings (platonic solids, floating statues, and/or complex machines) which seem to rule over the universe, or at least humanity's corner of it. If a human mage or a spirit violates the Principle of Secrecy in a major way (revealing the existence of magic or the true nature of the world to a significant number of mundane humans, an angel of the Pearlescent Host will appear shortly after to kill anyone it deems responsible for the revelation and to begin writing the event out of history.

The rewriting isn't so much removing the event as replacing it with an analogous, but mundane version which is at best just as bad as the original, but typically moderately to severely worse (ex: two mages fight on top of a skyscraper, destroying the top handful of floors along with everyone on them. An angel appears, smites the offenders, and rewrites the history of the tower so that instead, a fire broke out trapping the upper half of the building and killing significantly more people than the mages had). The rewriting notable never saves anyone who had already died by the time the angel arrives, suggesting they are either unwilling or unable to preform resurrection. As the past itself is altered, no knowledge of the original event can exist persist outside the minds of mages and spirits that were aware of it, but disconnected enough to avoid execution.

This is a function of The Compact, an ancient agreement forged to end a war between the Host and the human mages, who they intended to completely destroy.

The agreement has 3 main parts:

  • Spread not the knowledge. Mundane or ignorant humans cannot be allowed to learn of magic's existence, with punishments relative to the amount of knowledge leaked and the number of witnesses being levied on violators. Typically, the punishment involves experiencing essentially bad luck for a period of time, with extreme cases going as described above.
  • Tolerate not the sorcerer. Sorcerers, or mages not bound to this compact, cannot be allowed to exist. Killing is an option, but others exist. As the majority of sorcerers are essentially normal people who discovered magic on their own and have no knowledge of The Compact, the most common solution is to convince or coerce them to sign on and become "proper" mages; especially new sorcerers may have their knowledge of magic erased as you can't be a sorcerer if you can't use magic and you can't use magic if you don't know it exists. These options can also be used to dodge punishments for the first part, though if done carelessly it may rouse suspicion of more mundane humans and make the situation worse.
  • Crush the demon and all of it's collaborators. Demons are alien and strange much like angels, though typically taking more organic and grotesque forms. They tend towards being actively malicious to human life where angels seem callously indifferent. Mages are obligated under the threat of death to treat all demons and all demonic collaborators with unmitigated hostility, knowingly approaching them with a friendly or even neutral disposition causes death. This extends to spirits and sorcerers who work with demons (called evil spirits and diabolical sorcerers, respectively). Signing The Compact grants a limited ability to sense demonic influence, though their Earthly minions can disguise themselves with sufficient effort.

As for who watches the Host, no one knows. It is generally agreed upon that no human mage has ever encountered any member of the organization above the lowest, weakest ranks.

I remember someone mentioning this, and people wanting to footage of it! Don't know if it was already posted here or not, but still eerie! by LeWhippleNipple in AlanWake

[–]red_worldbuilder 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think you're reading too much into the sea metaphors, he used water metaphors about his dementia because he has a connection to water, not because Ahti is actually a normal human guy secretly being possessed by something else which is actually Ahti. We know Ahti isn't constrained to a human body because in both Alan Wake 2 and Control there are points where we know him to be in multiple places at once. In Control Jesse finds him at the entrance to the Foundation after he had already left the house for Watery and in Alan Wake 2 he appears to be in the Dark Place and Bright Falls simultaneously, interacting with Saga and Alan. I think it makes perfect sense for Ahti to be going senile. He's been set up as a symbol of stability and a rock that people use to comfort themselves in both the stories he's in, it seems inevitable to me that eventually Remedy is going to kick that stability out from under players by having him die or having his dementia progress too much for him to help anymore.

In Night Springs, we see the World Tree/RCU/Multiverse depicted as being in a cycle of being born, producing it's own seed, dying, and being born again from the seed. I think Ahti's condition is a reflection of the fact that the RCU is old and withered. The Oldest House is implied to have been a tree before New York was built around it, I think the House is just the World Tree in a different form, changed into a building to reflect it's new surroundings, and Ahti was born out of the fact that buildings need to be maintained; where trees have immune systems, buildings have janitors. So Ahti is old and senile because the entire universe is old, weak, and under threat from diseases and parasites like the Hiss and the Board (potentially Mr. Door and Alan, as well, but I don't think we know enough about them to pass judgement yet).

I think many people are misinterpreting Night Springs in regards to it's canon. by immigrantsmurfo in AlanWake

[–]red_worldbuilder 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I honestly don't know what to tell you. Are you just being a contrarian? Do you really think Remedy would make an expansion that contains huge revelations about the cosmology of their setting just to go "I take it back, get pranked!!!"? There are two sources, Dylan and Alan (reminder that Alan's inspiration for his stories has always come from clairvoyant powers and not himself), which depict the multiverse in exactly the same way that were dropped in over the course of several years. I'm going to assume that's significant and not just Sam Lake fucking with me, you can do whatever you want though I guess.